Nick Fletcher 

Markets rattled by Italian and Spanish political turmoil – as it happened

Eurozone crisis rears its head again with prospect of new elections in Italy and vote of no confidence in Spain
  
  

Five Star Movement leader, Luigi Di Maio, ahead of a Rai Uno TV program ‘Porta a Porta’ hosted by journalist Bruno Vespa
Five Star Movement leader, Luigi Di Maio, ahead of a Rai Uno TV program ‘Porta a Porta’ hosted by journalist Bruno Vespa Photograph: Alessandro Di Meo/EPA

Summary: Markets hit by new eurozone uncertainty

The turmoil over the failed Italian coalition, with the prospect of new elections in the autumn, has revived memories of the crisis which engulfed the eurozone over Greece. Investors have taken fright that Italy might effectively vote to leave the euro, sending markets and bond prices tumbling.

And on top of that, there is concern over Spain, where the government faces a no confidence vote on Friday.

Various comments from EU and ECB officials have hardly helped calm the mood, while separately billionaire financial George Soros has warned the EU faces “an imminent existential threat.”

Moody’s meanwhile said Italy’s credit rating could be downgraded if the next government does not get to grips with its huge debt pile. Oh yes, and Italian consumer confidence was weaker than expected in May.

With all that, Italian bonds suffered their worst day since 1992, with two year bond prices falling and yields surging more than 150 basis points to 2.73%. They have since recovered slightly to 2.36%.

Stock markets were also under pressure although again they are off their worst levels, with Italy’s FTSE MIB down 2.3% at the moment. Elsewhere Germany’s Dax is down 1% and Spain’s Ibex has lost 2.3%. The FTSE 100 has fallen 1.25% while on Wall Street the Dow Jones Industrial Average is currently.0.8% lower.

The euro dropped to a new six and a half month low against the dollar of $1.1510 before regaining some ground to $1.1580.

But the pound failed to benefit, remaining virtually flat against the euro and down 0.26% against a strengthening dollar.

On that note, it’s time to close for the day. Thanks for all your comments, and we’ll be back tomorrow.

Could this be a slap on the wrist from the President of the European Council for some of the earlier comments from the ECB and EU?

Wall Street opens lower

The global market slump in the wake of Italy’s latest political problems has spread to the US, with Wall Street opening sharply lower.

The Dow Jones Industrial Average is down 190 points or 0.7% while the S&P 500 fell 0.6% at the start of trading and the Nasdaq Composite losing 0.4%. US Treasury bonds, one of the perceived havens for investors in times of turmoil, have moved higher, with the 10 year yield conversely at the lowest level since April.

It’s not just Italy causing concern of course:

At times like this it is worth looking at the VIX index - the so-called fear index which shows investors’ expectations of near term market volatility.

So far today it has jumped 17% to 15.49, the highest level since the beginning of May.

Unless there is something lost in the translation here, this appears to be another unhelpful comment, this time from EU commissioner Günther Oettinger:

As the Italian crisis continues, billionaire financier George Soros is in a negative mood about the EU in a speech today:

As the Italian crisis grips investors, markets had become complacent in the wake of the QE support programmes from the world’s leading central banks, says Premier Asset Management’s Jake Robbins:

The Presidential rejection of a democratically elected coalition government has thrown Italy into a constitutional crisis, one made worse given it was because of the coalition’s anti EU beliefs. In echoes of the euro crisis earlier this decade, these events could ultimately threaten the future of the EU, or at the very least, question it in its current form.

Whilst it is no surprise that Italian yields have soared and equities plunged as investors reprice the actual risk of holding Italian assets, this crisis has been on the cards for some time and shows how complacent financial markets have become in the era of quantitative easing. At the same time there has been a noticeable slowdown in growth across the EU this year which will also continue to weigh on sentiment towards both Italian and EU wide assets. Throw in heightened geopolitical risks in other parts of the world such as the US and Asia, rising interest rates and the reduction in central bank support through quantitative easing, then the outlook for financial markets is far less certain than over the past few years.

Here’s Reuters’ latest report on the volatility in the markets:

A deepening political crisis in Italy, the euro zone’s third biggest economy, fuelled a heavy selloff in Italian assets and the euro reminiscent of the euro zone debt crisis of 2010-2012.

Short-term Italian bond yields, which move inversely to price, were set for their biggest one-day jump since 1992, while Italian and wider euro zone banking stocks were set to suffer their worst day since August 2016.

Italy’s president has set the country on a path to fresh elections by appointing a former International Monetary Fund official as interim prime minister, with the task of planning for snap polls and passing the next budget.

The concern is that fresh elections could deliver an even stronger mandate for Italy’s anti-establishment, eurosceptic politicians.

“The spectacular rise of 2-year yields in Italy this morning reflects break-up or redenomination fears,” Martin van Vliet, ING Bank’s senior fixed income strategist, said.

Earlier Italy sold €5.5bn worth of six month bonds, but at the highest yield for more than five years.

Amid the turmoil surrounding the country’s political future, it sold the expected amount of bonds but at a yield or interest rate of an average 1.213%. At the previous auction for this maturity the yield was negative at -0.421%.

There are more sales due on Wednesday - up to €6bn in five year and ten year bonds.

US markets are expected to open lower in the wake of the European declines, with the Dow Jones Industrial Average forecast to lose around 190 points at the start of trading.

"Italy knows the rules": ECB vice president

Not sure this is an entirely helpful remark from the European Central Bank’s Vitor Constancio. When asked about any ECB help for Italy he is quoted as saying: “Italy knows the rules. They might want to read them again.”

Reuters reports:

Any intervention by the European Central Bank to help Italy in the event of liquidity problems must meet the bank’s mandate and “certain conditions”, its outgoing Vice-President was quoted as saying on Tuesday.

“Italy knows the rules. They might want to read them again,” Vitor Constancio told Spiegel magazine in an interview, according to a pre-release, when asked if the central bank would intervene if needed and rescue Italy from insolvency.

The ECB’s never-used emergency bond buying scheme -- known as Outright Monetary Transactions or OMT -- is a potential tool to help Italy but comes with a long list of conditions.

For a country to be eligible for OMT, it must be in a European Financial Stability Facility/European Stability Mechanism adjustment or precautionary programme and support must be warranted from a monetary policy perspective.

A deepening political and constitutional crisis in Italy, the euro zone’s third biggest economy, fuelled a sharp rise in the country’s short-term borrowing costs on Tuesday and renewed selling in the euro and stocks.

Back with the markets, and analyst Joshua Mahony at IG, says:

With markets transfixed on affairs in Italy and Spain (amid a vote of no confidence for Rajoy), we are seeing a sharp shift into safe haven assets, driving the Japanese yen and gold prices higher in recent days. FTSE 100-listed gold producers Fresnillo and Randgold are the best performers in the bluechip index in early trade amid a shift into gold. We often see stocks benefit when currencies come under pressure, but the flight to safety this morning means the euro and the pound are also getting another pounding alongside the stock market declines.

Away from markets for a moment, and some good news for Pret A Manger employees after the takeover deal, as tweeted by the chain’s chief executive:

Moody’s, which recently put Italy’s Baa2 credit rating on review for a downgrade, has commented on the latest developments.

It said Italy was likely to be downgraded if the next government pursued fiscal policies which were not sufficient to place the public debt ratio on a sustainable downward trajectory in the coming years.

Its rating could be confirmed if there was an ambitious programme of structural reform by the next government.

Updated

Neil Wilson, chief market analyst for Markets.com, says:

We’ve seen a steep selloff in risk assets as the Italian political troubles deepen, with investors seemingly dumping their exposure to Italy. Whilst a lot has already been written on the topic, the moves this morning warrant attention as we are seeing some incredible price action in Italian bonds with the market moving at speeds not seen since the worst of the Eurozone debt crisis.

The big question is whether this is just an Italian problem or one that risks significant spill-over into the rest of Europe. The one thing that has become apparent is that markets treated the election result with excessive calm and has been jolted by the populists’ success in agreeing terms...

For now this looks contained largely to Italy, but the contagion risks mount. Italian bond moves are isolated and whilst the euro has given some ground again it is mounting a firm defence above 1.15 for the time being. Italian stocks today are underperforming Europe, with the FTSE MIB falling more than 3% before bargain hunters produced a slight paring of the losses. However, the situation – which increasingly is a crisis in the making – is seeing investors take risk off the table and stocks across Europe are 1-2% lower.

Italian bond yields have risen sharply and spreads are widening with Bunds. The Italian 2-year yield has jumped above 2% and has kept on going, approaching 2012 sovereign debt crisis territory at 2.4%. Spreads with 10-year Bunds are now at the widest since 2013 and the market is moving before our eyes.

Eurozone breakup risks are higher, although they remain small overall (unless you take the long term view that every empire falls at some point and the EU is no different). If snap elections produce a clearer mandate for the populists and they succeed again in forming a government, Italy heads for a collision for the EU shortly after. EU and Eurozone rules are far too inflexible to handle radical domestic policy shifts of this kind and based on experience of Brexit negotiations, Italy could not hope for the EU rule makers to back down. A disorderly Italexit would be nasty enough but as a founding member of the club it would be a moment that the bloc would not recover from.

The chief risk is that the developments over the last week lead to a snap election that becomes in effect a referendum on membership of the euro. The two main populist parties may well step up their anti-euro, and anti-EU positions.

Italy a few steps away from losing trust - central bank boss Visco

The head of Italy’s central bank has said the country’s economy is recovering and growth is increasingly self sustained, but said any move to weaken the country’s public finances could undermine confidence and years of valuable reforms.

Ignazio Visco, speaking to the bank’s annual meeting, made the comments amid the political turmoil which is likely to lead to a new election, with euro membership likely to be among the main issues for voters.

Visco added that moderate growth and gradually rising inflation were the most likely path for Italy.

He said he expected Italy’s smaller banks to come up with plans to tackle non-performing loans by the autumn, with a quarter of them showing a negative return on equity.

He said Italy must press on with reforms, and there were no short cuts for cutting debt. “We are only ever a few short steps away” from a serious risk of losing trust, he said.

Updated

The market rout is intensifying, in the wake of the Italian political crisis.

The FTSE 100 is now down nearly 120 points or 1.5%, Germany’s Dax is down 1.6% and France’s Cac has fallen 1.87%.

As for Italy, the FTSE MIB is now down 3.2%. Italian two year bond yields are on track for the biggest one day rise for more than 16 years.

But the yields on UK gilts have fallen to their lowest levels this year as investors seek havens for their cash amid the turmoil.

The euro is also being hit, down 0.3% against the dollar and below $1.16 for the first time in six and a half months.

But the pound is not benefiting much, flat against the euro at €1.1451 and down 0.6% against the dollar to $1.3220, its lowest since November.

Italian consumer confidence falls in May

It may not have taken in the latest developments, but the recent political uncertainty in Italy has hit consumer confidence.

The confidence index fell to 113.7 in May, the lowest since August last year and below the 116.5 level expected by analysts. The April figure came in at 116.9.

The business morale index fell from 105.0 to 104.7 in May, the worst level since January last year.

Time to call this a crisis, says Kit Juckes of Societe Generale:

Having rejected the NL/5-star leaders’ nomination of Paolo Savona as [Italian] Economy Minister, President Mattarella has called on Carlo Cottarelli to form an interim administration.

His chances of succeeding are slim and elections are likely in September. Which leaves us 3-4 months of uncertainty ahead of a vote that may be seen as a referendum on Euro-membership. The threat of further rating downgrades hangs over the BTP [Italian bond] market (and is largely priced-in), and the European Central Bank’s plans for providing forward guidance on policy normalisation are up in the air. Which means that the risk of EUR/USD reaching 1.10 by the end of the summer is significantly higher than the possibility of a recovery to 1.20.

With 10-year Bund yields under 30bp this morning, and the BTP/Bund spread heading towards 3% at a rate of knots, we should now call this a crisis. The 2010 and 2011-2012 Euro crises took EUR/USD down by 20-25%, which may put the 10% we’ve seen so far in context. Both those falls were almost completely reversed when the crisis passed, but that’s for another day, even if that day comes sooner as result of these developments. EUR/USD 1.1550 is the next key psychological level but I can’t see it holding. 1.0860, the springboard from which the euro rallied after the French election, should hold....

European markets open lower

As expected the threat of a new eurozone crisis - this time involving Italy and/or Spain rather than Greece - has sent markets sharply lower in early trading.

The FTSE 100 is down 0.78% at 7670, while Germany’s Dax has dropped 0.6% and France’s Cac 0.69%.

As for the two countries in the spotlight, Italy’s FTSE MIB has lost 1.9% to hit its lowest level since August last year, while the country’s banking index is down3.4% at a new 13 month low.

Meanwhile Spain’s Ibex is off 1.29%.

More on the sale of ubiquitous sandwich chain Pret A Manger:

Pret a Manger, the British sandwich shop chain, is being taken over by the German-controlled company behind Krispy Kreme donuts and Kenco coffee in a deal worth more than £1.5bn.

Bridgepoint, the UK-based private equity firm, has agreed to sell Pret to the investment group JAB Holdings, which has been rapidly acquiring companies linked to the coffee market in recent years.

Pret is based in London, where it was started by the entrepreneur Julian Metcalfe and his friend Sinclair Beecham with one shop in 1986. Metcalfe went on to create the Itsu restaurant chain and Metcalfe’s skinny popcorn.

Having expanded rapidly in recent years, opening 50 shops in the past year alone, Pret has more than 500 stores, generating revenues of £879m. It also has stores in the US, China and Dubai.

The company is trying to attract more British workers as it prepares for potential staff shortages after Brexit and seeks to expand further in the US and internationally.

The full story is here:

Back with Italy, and bond yields are continuing to leap higher:

Dixons Carphone shares slump 27% after it warns on profits

The unscheduled trading statement from Dixons Carphone shows it now expects profits of around £300m in its next financial year, well below the £387m expected by analysts.

It forecast the UK electrical market would contract, and new broom chief executive Alex Baldock - eight weeks in the job - seemed to take a swipe at previous management when he said:

We will correct recent underinvestment in both our colleague and customer proposition. In the coming year we expect to make a cost investment of around £30m in these areas across the UK and Ireland, giving our colleagues the right tools and the customer an improved experience.

It said it expected cost increases in UK electricals, notably the National Living Wage and IT depreciation.

On mobile, Baldock said the company had taken early action with the planned closure of 92 Carphone Warehouse standalone stores this year.

Its shares have slumped 27% to 170p on the news.

Retail analyst Nick Bubb said:

The share price of Dixons Carphone has been recovering strongly since new CEO Alex Baldock took over, on the back of vibes about strong trading ahead of the World Cup. But, out of the blue, the company has come out with a profit warning today! The issue appears to be that although headline of PBT of £382m for y/e April will hit City expectations that will be only down to an odd one-off £25m systems implementation benefit, given gross margin pressures in Q4. And the company has come out with detailed guidance for the year that has just started, y/e April 2019, warning of a fall back to headline PBT of £300m! That is partly because of the impact of one-off items, but also reflects continued problems in the mobile phone business (despite the much-vaunted talks with the networks about better terms) and, amazingly, a £30m hit to “correct recent underinvestment in both our colleague and customer proposition”. After all that, investors may not be in much of a mood to listen to the new CEO’s assertion that “though there’s plenty to fix, it’s all fixable”...

Indeed.

Italian bond yields have jumped on the political turmoil engulfing the country, with the two year yields rising above 1% for the first time since 2014.

The euro continues to come under pressure, falling to its lowest level since November 2017 against the dollar.

It is down 4% so far this month at $1.159, and is also at a new six and a half month low against the Swiss franc. It has fallen 0.1% against the pound.

The agenda: eurozone political uncertainty back in focus

Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.

It’s been a little while, but the eurozone looks like it could be heading towards another period of turmoil. And it is not Greece this time.

Both Italy and Spain are rattling stock markets, the former following the collapse of its eurosceptic coalition between the Five Star Movement and Lega party and the latter facing a vote of no confidence in the government on Friday.

Italian president Sergio Mattarella has vetoed the proposed anti euro candidate for finance minister, Paolo Savona, and appointed Carlo Cottarelli, a former International Monetary Fund official, as interim prime minister. In some ways the veto on Savona should be good for the euro, but any benefits have been overshadowed by the political turmoil caused and the prospect of new elections later this year.

Here is our story on the latest political developments:

Meanwhile in Spain prime minister Mariano Rajoy is facing the no confidence vote after a Spanish corruption case involving members of the ruling party.

Jasper Lawler, head of research at London Capital Group, said:

The overriding problem for investors is that these are two of the largest, most important economies in the eurozone. Euro traders are aware that the potential fallout from Italy mainly, but also this Spanish headache, dwarfs the fallout which could have been following the Greek debt saga and as a result the euro has fallen heavily out of favour and has continued to decline overnight. With potential elections just around the corner in both Spain and Italy, a summer of volatility now seems almost a given.

So with the euro weakened by these new uncertainties, European stock markets are expected to open lower:

It’s a fairly quiet day on the economic front but there are a couple of bits of corporate news. Sandwich chain Pret A Manger is being sold for around £1.5bn while Dixons Carphone has issued a profits warning. More to come on this....

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*