Graeme Wearden 

Markets shrug off prospect of new Italian government – as it happened

All the day’s economic and financial news, as Italy’s League and Movement Five Star move towards forming a new government
  
  

The leader of Italy’s Five-Star Movement, Luigi Di Maio, arriving for talks with the Lega party over forming a government.
The leader of Italy’s Five-Star Movement, Luigi Di Maio, arriving for talks with the Lega party over forming a government. Photograph: Flavio Lo Scalzo/EPA

European markets close drably as traders await news

Italy’s stock mark shrugged off its earlier losses to end the day 0.26% higher at 24,221, a gain of 61 points.

Traders have hunkered down for a longer wait before learning who will succeed Paulo Gentolini as Italy’s PM.

That’s a fairly calm reaction to the prospect of an anti-establishment party teaming up with a right-wing rival to form a new government that might rip up Italy’s budget targets, cut taxes, introduce a universal basic income, and possibly take issue with Brussels on a range of issues.

Investors seem hopeful that the League and M5S will step back form their more radical policies. Or they think that any deal will collapse, bringing fresh elections. Alternatively, they retain faith in the European Central Bank to steer the eurozone through any looming storms.

Other markets ended the day in the red, with Britain’s FTSE 100 losing 13 points to finish at 7,710.

That’s all for today. GW

Some reaction to the news that the Italian government negotiations haven’t quite reached the fulltime whistle....

The rumour mill in Italy has been working overtime, as politicians, analysts and the media speculate about the identity of Italy’s new prime minister.

The FT has the details:

Ahead of the meeting between [M5S’s] Mr Di Maio and Mr Salvini [of the League], Rome was gripped by rumours of possible candidates.

Il Corriere della Sera, Italy’s leading daily, said there was a horse race between Giulio Sapelli, an economic historian and a former board member at Eni, Italy’s largest oil and gas group, and Giuseppe Conte, a jurist from Puglia and an expert in public administration.

Mr Sapelli’s star seemed to be on the rise after he said that he had been contacted by the parties and had offered his full availability for the job, if Domenico Siniscalco, the former finance minister, returned to his old job. But Five Star officials then said Mr Sapelli would not be selected as prime minister.

This triggered new speculation that Mr Di Maio himself might clinch the post, but Mr Salvini denied it as he entered the meeting with the Five Star leader.

Newsflash from Rome: Italy’s two populist parties haven’t reached a deal yet.

An agreement could still be a few days away, according to M5S’s leader Luigi Di Maio....

Newsflash from Washington: the International Monetary Fund has announced that its board will consider Argentina’s request for help on Friday.

Gerry Rice, the International Monetary Fund’s spokesperson, says:

“IMF staff are continuing discussions with the Argentine authorities toward a Fund-supported program. Our shared goal is to reach a rapid conclusion of these discussions. An IMF Board meeting on Argentina is scheduled for Friday, May 18. This will be an informal meeting, as part of our usual process of briefing the Board on negotiations for high access IMF programs.”

Last week, Argentina announced it is seeking a $30bn precautionary credit line to shore up the peso, which has slumped in recent weeks.

It’s quite a move, almost 20 years after the government threw out the IMF amid a massive financial crisis.

The US stock market has indeed opened higher, with the Dow Jones industrial average gaining 95 points or 0.4% to 24,926.

Traders are hopeful that US-China trade tensions are easing, following Donald Trump’s olive branch to China’s telecoms firm ZTE.

Reuters has more details about how Movement 5 Star and the League’s policy pledges could blow a hole in Italy’s budgets:

Five-Star’s flagship policy of a universal income for the poor would cost an estimated €17bn ($20bn) per year. The League’s hallmark scheme, a flat tax rate of 15% for companies and individuals, is tipped to cut tax revenues by €80bn per year.

Scrapping an unpopular pension reform would cost €15bn, and another €12.5bn would be needed to head off an automatic hike in sales tax due for next year.

Tax cuts might give Italy a growth boost, though, while universal basic income could help tackle inequality and encourage people to retrain and get back into the labour market.

Back in the UK... and fans of Poldark will be interested to learn that Cornwall could soon have a working metal mine again.

My colleague Julia Kollewe explains:

Tin mining is set for a comeback in Cornwall, as a Canadian company that plans to reopen the South Crofty mine in 2021 announced it would float on the London stock market next month to help fund the venture.

Vancouver-based Strongbow Exploration acquired the rights to the tin mine in the Cornish town of Pool in July 2016. After operating for more than 400 years, South Crofty was the last tin mine to close in the UK 20 years ago, due to a lack of investment and falling metal prices.

But since then demand for tin has increased while global supply is falling, driving a 60% surge in tin prices since January 2016 to $21,000 (£15,457) a tonne. Tin is used as solder in consumer electronics and other electronic devices, electric cars and solar cells.

The US stock market is expected to open a little higher today, with the Dow called up 60 points.

Full story: M5S and League are close to power

From Rome, our correspondent Angela Giuffrida has the latest on the Italian government talks:

Italy’s anti-establishment Five Star Movement (M5S) and its far-right partner, the League, are preparing to present their government programme to President Sergio Mattarella on Monday and name a prime minister.

Matteo Salvini, the leader of the League, and M5S counterpart Luigi Di Maio, worked over the weekend in Milan on a policy document in which they are expected to take a tougher approach towards illegal immigration and the EU.

In line with their campaign pledges, the parties, which between them won more than 50% of the vote in the 4 March elections, have also reportedly reached agreement on introducing a flat tax as low as 15%, a universal basic income and dismantling a change to pensions in 2011 that increased the retirement age. They have also pledged to attempt to renegotiate European treaties.

“If the rules, parameters and constraints imposed by Europe do not change, Italy suffocates. This seems to be a shared commitment,” Salvini said.

Italian media reported that Di Maio had told the president’s office on Sunday night they would be ready to submit their plan to Mattarella and name a prime minister on Monday. Earlier in the day, the 31-year-old said the pair were “writing history” and needed time, but that talks had been positive.

If Mattarella endorses the candidate, programme and cabinet lineup then he could nominate a prime minister on Monday, paving the way for a government to be sworn in this week before facing a vote of confidence in both houses of parliament. However, Mattarella warned over the weekend that he would not be a “pushover”...

More here:

Italy’s stock market has dropped a little further into the red, as traders in Milan brace to learn who their next prime minister might be.

The FTSE MIB has shed 150 points, or 0.65%, today to 24,005.

Overnight, Asian markets had rallied with Hong Kong up 1.3% and Japan’s Nikkei gaining almost 0.5%.

Mihir Kapadia of Sun Global Investments thinks the European markets may be getting a little jittery:

Despite the gains made in Asia, European markets started off on a cautious tone as increasing global tensions played a part in the decline.

With Italy struggling to form a government and the UK government facing internal struggles to cope with Brexit, banking and technology pulled Stoxx Europe 600 lower over the sentiment.”

The growing possibility of a populist government in Italy is just one reason why the markets could be choppy in the months ahead.

Brexit, the trade talks between the US and China, and geopolitical tensions in the Middle East are all potential triggers for a selloff too.

Mark Haefele, chief investment officer at UBS Global Wealth Management, warns that some investors aren’t ready for the challenges ahead:

The period of exceptionally low volatility that investors enjoyed in 2017 is over.

2018 has seen a number of risks surface that could end the economic cycle, triggering a bear market in global equities, or at a minimum, leading to even higher market volatility. Investors need to respond. Based on our analysis of our own positioning data, many investors are entering this higher volatility environment unprepared.”

So, is it time to sell up? Haefele says not...

“The road ahead will be more difficult to navigate than the road that’s behind us. Returns will likely be lower – we’re assuming annualised equity market returns in the mid-to-high single digits. But we don’t believe a pick-up in volatility signals the end of the bull market. This is not a time to jump to cash. The cost of being uninvested remains high.”

The news that Italy’s president will meet the party leaders in the mid-afternoon hasn’t given the markets a jolt.

After nearly four hours of trading, the European trading floors remain calm with the main indices slightly lower.

As well as Italy, investors are also pondering what to make of Donald Trump’s latest move.

The US president surprisingly tweeted yesterday that he was trying to save jobs... in at a Chinese telecoms firm.

It’s a remarkable twist, given Trump’s claims that Chinese firms have been unfairly taking jobs away from America.

It’s particularly odd, as ZTE is in hot water for violating US sanctions by illegally shipping American technology to Iran and North Korea. This prompted a a ban on US companies selling components to ZTE, after the US commerce department concluded that ZTE was not complying with an agreement over the sanctions-busting.

Trump’s decision to spring to ZTE’s aid may signal that relations with China are warming up - perhaps Beijing wants the ZTE issue resolved before reaching a wider deal on trade reform.

Updated

Jean Pisani-Ferry, senior fellow at the Bruegel think tank, says Italy’s next government needs to take urgent action to improve its economy and boost productivity.

Pisani-Ferry points out that Italy’s financial position is precarious, with a debt-to-GDP ratio of 132% (ie, Italy owes more than its entire annual economic output).

But that’s the product of weak growth, not reckless borrowing, he explains:

The root of Italy’s public-finance problem is that it inherited excessively high debt from the 1980s and has not recorded significant economic growth for two decades. Real (inflation-adjusted) GDP in 2017 was at the same level as in 2003, and real GDP per capita was at the level of 1999. With a stagnant denominator, it is hard to reduce the debt-to-GDP ratio: the legacy of the past continues to weigh excessively on the present.

A thought experiment helps in understanding Italy’s problem. Had France followed the same policy as its southern neighbor since the launch of the euro in 1999 – that is, had it recorded, year after year, the same primary balances – its public debt today would be 45% of GDP, instead of 97%. The difference between the two countries is not that France has been wise and Italy profligate. Quite the contrary. The reason why France has a significantly lower debt today is that it inherited a better fiscal position and has been growing faster.

The lesson, therefore, is that Italy’s key priority should be to revive growth. But this cannot be accomplished by relaxing the brake on public spending. The bulk of Italy’s growth problem comes from the supply side, not the demand side. As documented in a recent paper produced by the Bank of Italy, the country’s productivity performance is truly dismal: over the last two decades, output per employee has decreased by 0.1% per year, compared to 0.6% growth in Spain, 0.7% in Germany, and 0.8% in France. Furthermore, the demographic outlook is frightening: the working-age population, currently at the same level as in the late 1980s, is set to decline by 0.5-1% annually in the years to come. The burden of repaying the debt will fall on a smaller labor force – even more so if the retirement age is lowered....

More here.

Economist Daniel Lacalle agrees that the European Central Bank is holding down eurozone bond yields - but I don’t think he approves.....

Peter Rosenstreich of online bank Swissquote thinks investors are too complacent this morning:

Political risk is building in Italy, and markets are ignoring it.

Yield spreads failed to react to news that the Northern League and 5-Star parties have reached a tentative coalition. This might have dramatic implications for Italian government spending: but the Euro continues to firm against the US dollar.

The European Central Bank can also take some credit for today’s calm markets.

Back in 2011, Italy’s borrowing costs hit dangerous levels during the political crisis that forced Silvio Berlusconi out of office. Since then, the ECB has launched a series of schemes to shore up the eurozone, including its huge QE bond-buying programme.

That asset purchase scheme has driven eurozone bond yields (the cost of borrowing) down to record low levels. The ECB says the programme is meant to stimulate growth and fight deflation, but it is also acting as a safety net for the eurozone.

Kit Juckes of French bank Société Générale says:

As long as the ECB has the bond market’s back, the euro will try to ignore Italian politics.

Newsflash: Italian president Sergio Mattarella will meet with the leaders of Movement Five Star and the League this afternoon.

Mattarella must judge whether a stable government can be formed, avoiding the need for new elections.

Over in Milan, the Italian stock market has dipped by 60 points, or 0.25%, to 24,101 points.

One theory for the muted reaction is that any alliance between M5S and the League will soon collapse, triggering new elections.

Robin Bew of the Economist Intelligence Unit thinks Italy may soon be heading back to the polls....

Rebecca O’Keeffe, head of investment at interactive investor, suspects those new policies could be unaffordable.

She writes:

After lengthy post-election negotiations, the populist Five Star Movement is poised to join a coalition government with the extreme right-wing League.

So far, their headline policy proposals include lower taxes and earlier retirement. Italy has struggled for decades with government deficits and resultant inflation, and there is a clear danger that the country’s finances may, yet again, be about to spiral out of control.

Updated

The draft programme being drawn up between the two parties may include some popular policies.

According to Bloomberg, it includes “a flat tax as low as 15 percent, a guaranteed income for the poor and a lower retirement age”.

This implies a certain degree of fiscal loosening, which might see Italy exceed its current borrowing targets.

Bloomberg says:

The parties’ economic program costs between 65 billion euros and 100 billion euros, according to an estimate in newspaper Corriere della Sera on Monday, adding that the flat tax is the most expensive measure.

Updated

The euro has actually risen this morning, up 0.3% against the US dollar at $1.198.

That indicates that the markets aren’t spooked about the situation in Italy.

Updated

Why isn't Italy spooking the markets?

An alliance between Italy’s M5S and the League had been seen as the ‘nightmare scenario’ for investors.

Royal Bank of Canada says it has been fielding calls from clients, wondering why there isn’t more market reaction to the prospect of a populist government.

RBS’s theory is that the two parties will resist trying to take Italy out of the euro:

The erstwhile ‘euro sceptic parties’ – particularly the M5S – have distanced themselves quite substantially from their anti-European rhetoric. The reason why such a scenario was initially feared was that this would somehow lead to an Italian version of Brexit (even though the actual practicalities of how to get such a result implemented were always questioned by the market).

The agenda: Italy close to new government

Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the global economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.

A few years ago, the prospect of two populist parties taking control in one of the eurozone’s biggest - and most indebted - members would have rocked the markets.

But times have moved on, and investors are remarkably relaxed about the latest developments in Italy, where the the anti-establishment Five Star Movement (M5S) and the far-right League are on the brink of power.

The two unlikely bedfellows informed Italy’s president yesterday that they have reached an agreement about a government programme, and are ready to choose a new prime minister.

As the AFP newswire reported late last night:

Matteo Salvini, head of the nationalist League, had earlier said in a statement he and Five Star Movement (M5S) leader Luigi Di Maio were “writing history” and would call President Sergio Mattarella.

Press agency AGI reported Di Maio made a brief call to the president’s office to “announce that they are ready from tomorrow (Monday) to report on everything, including the name of the prime minister”.

If the head of state accepts the nomination, the position could be filled within days.

A breakthrough would end more than two-months of deadlock following Italy’s inconclusive general election in March [Reminder: the League became the most powerful right-wing party, overtaking Silvio Berlusconi’s Forza Italia, while M5S won nearly as many votes as the centre-right coalition]

But it also creates a bucketload of uncertainty, given the two parties are radically different.

The League, whose powerbase is Italy’s wealthy north, favours low taxes and a crackdown on immigration.

Movement Five-Star, though, wants greater government investment in new infrastructure, stronger workers rights, and a push on green energy.

Both parties do represent a break from Italy’s past, though. And they share one instinct, though - scepticism about the European Union, and a dislike of the austerity measures imposed to keep Italy in line with Brussels.

And yet... traders aren’t panicking. European stock markets are expected to be calm this morning, with Britain’s FTSE 100 hovering at its highest level since late January.

The bond markets are also relaxed about the prospect of a new Italian government clashing with the EU over deficit targets.

As Michael Hewson of CMC Markets explains.

Any new program if implemented could well bring any new Italian government into conflict with EU budget rules.

So far market reaction has been muted to the prospect of an agreement, though Italian bond markets did fall sharply last week with the 10 year yield rising 12 basis points over the week, to just shy of 1.9%.

Updated

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*