Finally, business leaders have been expressing their concern and barely-contained anger over the Brexit crisis.
As the Institute of Directors puts it, Brexit is a merry-go-round that long ago stopped being fun (was it ever?!)
On that note, goodnight! GW
Updated
The FTSE 100 has ended the week up 45 points, at 7279.
Investors should recognise that the chances of a general election have risen, says Dean Turner, UK Economist at UBS Global Wealth Management.
“The third defeat of the Withdrawal Agreement crystallises the UK’s departure date as 12th April. Before then, we expect MPs to converge on the view that more time will be needed in order to determine the path for Brexit. Therefore, a long extension to Article 50 looks increasingly likely, boosting the chances of a general election.
“Sterling hasn’t responded favourably to today’s result, likely interpreting an increased risk of a no-deal scenario two weeks hence. That said, our view remains that MPs will ultimately avoid this outcome.”
Mervyn King, who led the Bank of England in the run-up to the financial crisis, has argued that Britain shouldn’t fear a no-deal Brexit...
The London stock market shrugged off the drama in Westminster, leaving the FTSE 100 up 36 points today at 7270.
Analyst Fiona Cincotta of www.cityindex.co.uk says trade war optimism is helping markets, following Treasury secretary Mnuchin’s claim of ‘constructive progress’ at today’s talks.
However, she also cautions that we don’t know exactly what’s being agreed (if anything).
Optimism that the US and China were moving towards a trade agreement has boosted risk appetite. Whilst any agreement could still be some months in the making, Economic Advisor Larry Kudlow hinted that some tariffs on Chinese imports could be removed. Progress in the US – Sino trade dispute is ensuring a strong end to the quarter for equities, despite lingering concerns over the health of the global economy.
We have seen investors pile into riskier assets across this quarter thanks to positive trade talk developments and a more accommodative Fed. Whether the bulls stay in control in the coming quarter could depend largely on further developments in US – Sino trade talks. Particularly amid a lack of solid evidence.
Jeremy Thomson-Cook, chief economist and head of currency strategy at WorldFirst, predicts that the pound will hover around $1.30 until we have some Brexit clarity.
GBP-USD is now at its centre of gravity around the $1.30 mark and that is where we expect it to stay until the next catalyst, which will likely be the second round of indicative votes next week.”
Pound hit by latest Brexit defeat
Newsflash: Sterling is weakening, after the government has lost its latest attempt to get Theresa May’s Brexit deal through parliament.
The pound has fallen through $1.30 against the US dollar for the first time since 11 March, and is also weaker against the euro.
Traders remain concerned that the UK could crash out of the EU without a deal, after seeing May lose by 58 votes.
The PM also warned that parliament is “reaching the limits of the process”, a suggestion that Britain may need a general election to break the deadlock.
Our Politics Live blog has all the action from Westminster.
As predicted, the US stock market is ending the week with gains - following the rally in China and then Europe today.
The Dow Jones industrial average is up roughly 100 points, or 0.4%, at 25,815 points. At that level, it’s up almost 11% so far this year.
Better economic news from the US: Nearly 5% more Americans managed a house in February, reversing most of the slump in January.
Canadian growth picks up
Canada has bucked the recent trend of disappointing growth, by posting its strongest monthly growth since last summer.
Canadian GDP rose by 0.3% in January, driven by a pick-up in manufacturing and construction. That beats a 0.1% expansion in December, and is the best reading since last May.
Monthly GDP reports are volatile, of course, so this won’t calm all the worries over the global economy....
....especially as we also have separate data showing that US consumer spending only rose by 0.1% in January, after dropping 0.6% in December.
Newsflash: The Chinese news service Xinhua is reporting that progress was made at today’s negotiations between US officials Steven Mnuchin and Robert Lighthizer and Chinese vice premier Liu He.
Alas, we don’t have concrete details on that progress.
Back in the financial markets, Wall Street is expected to open higher as trade war optimism reaches New York.
Investors are cheered by this morning’s tweet from Treasury secretary Steven Mnuchin, that his talks in Beijing today were ‘constructive’.
TUC General Secretary Frances O’Grady is urging ministers to address the weakness in Britain’s economy.....
“Falling business investment, a low savings ratio and record unsecured household debt are very worrying – especially with growth already so weak.
“The government must get off the sidelines and take urgent action to protect livelihoods and the economy.
“We need more investment in public services and infrastructure to counter the slowdown. And ministers should support families by raising the minimum wage to £10 and ending the benefits freeze.”
The harsh impact of the benefits freeze (now entering its 4th year) was highlighted yesterday by government data showing that child poverty has risen in the last year:
Economist Howard Archer of the EY Item Club is thoroughly unimpressed by today’s healthcheck on the UK economy:
- The expenditure side of the economy was largely unappetizing in the fourth quarter with business investment falling again and at an increased rate, net trade negative and consumer spending growth slowing.
- GDP growth in the fourth quarter was held back by a disappointing and worrying fourth successive contraction in business investment which fell at an increased rate of 0.9% quarter-on-quarter causing it to be down 2.5% year-on-year. This undoubtedly reflected heightened Brexit uncertainties. Meanwhile, net trade made a modest negative contribution to fourth quarter growth as import growth of 2.1% quarter-on-quarter out-stripped export growth of 1.6% quarter-on-quarter
In another blow, Britain has also suffered a fall in gross fixed capital formation (a broad measure of spending on new equipment, machinery, transport, property, etc).
GFCF shrank by 0.6% in the last quarter of 2018, today’s growth report shows. It was mainly dragged down by the drop in business spending.
This is the third quarterly decline in a row -- which hasn’t happened since 2009 (after the financial crisis).
It means Britain invested less in these assets (which are crucial to future growth) than any other G7 member....
John McDonnell MP, Shadow Chancellor, is (predictably) unimpressed by the picture painted by today’s economic data.
He says:
“Amidst the Government’s Brexit bungling, the Chancellor has repeatedly failed to get a grip on tumbling business investment, high household borrowing, weak growth, and a widening current account deficit.
“We need a general election to bring an end to the Tories’ chaotic management of Brexit and reckless economic management.”
McDonnell might get his wish; there’s speculation that Britain could head back to the polls this year.
Britain also continued to rely on the ‘kindness of strangers’ to support its financial position.
The UK’s current account deficit widened to 4.4% of GDP in the final quarter of 2018, the ONS says.
Interestingly, this was due to “a large net inflow of portfolio investment into the UK”. IN other worse, foreign investors bought more UK assets in the last few months of 2018.
Mark Tighe, CEO of R&D tax specialists Catax, says the “hideous and ongoing uncertainty over Brexit” is the main factor driving business investment down:
“This is the first time we’ve seen business investment crumble so badly since the financial crisis. It is a clear sign of dwindling business confidence and highlights the growing need for the UK economy to be put on a firmer footing.
Is it fair to blame Brexit for the steady fall in UK business investment in 2018?
Yes, according to this line from today’s National Accounts report:
The latest Deloitte CFO Survey reports that perceptions of economic and financial uncertainty continued to rise in the final quarter of 2018 while the outlook for capital expenditure has deteriorated.
Recent analysis by the Bank of England finds that “almost 70% of the slowdown” in business investment could be accounted for by uncertainty around the UK’s EU exit.
But...it’s also worth noting that business investment growth since the crisis had been modest, compared to previous post-recessions periods.
This doesn’t sound good....
In 2016, households financed their borrowing through long-term loans and the disinvestment in mutual funds. More recently, there has been a sharp drop in deposits made to UK banks by households, while the net acquisition of long-term loans and the disinvestment in mutual funds continued throughout this period to help fund households’ net borrowing.
Economist Rupert Seggins shows how UK households turned from net savers to net borrowers in the final quarter of 2016 (when the pound’s tumble after the Brexit vote pushed inflation higher)
Updated
UK households are net borrowers for 'unprecedented' 9th quarter in a row
In another sign of mounting economic stress, UK households and businesses spent more than they earned in the final three months of 2018.
The UK government was also a net borrower in Q4, the ONS says.
That means that every domestic sector was forced to borrow or run down their savings to finance their spending and investment.
The decline in household saving is a particular concern - it suggests more families were forced to borrow because inflation was eroding their wages.
The Office for National Statistics explains:
Households have traditionally been a net lender. However, in recent times that has not been the case, as households have now been net borrowers for the ninth consecutive quarter, which is an unprecedented run.
Whilst early estimates can be prone to revision, the underlying downward trend provides a clear reflection that households have recently saved less to support spending in the face of the squeeze in real incomes. Household net borrowing was 0.6% of GDP in Quarter 4 (Oct to Dec) 2018, an improvement from 1.1% in the previous quarter, reflecting an increase in wages and salaries.
Updated
UK business investment suffers longest decline since 2009
Worryingly, UK business investment fell in the last quarter of 2018, for the fourth quarter in a row.
Businesses spend 0.9% less on assets such as IT and machinery in October-December, today’s growth report shows. On an annual basis, business investment shrank by 2.5%.
This is the fourth consecutive quarter-on-quarter fall in business investment and the first time this has happened since the economic downturn of 2008 to 2009.
This is fresh confirmation that UK bosses have been holding back from making major investment decisions, until they have more clarity on Brexit.
The Office for National Statistics says:
ICT equipment and other machinery and equipment made the biggest contribution to the 2.5% fall in business investment between Quarter 4 2017 and Quarter 4 2018, contributing negative 2.4 percentage points.
Transport equipment and intellectual property products also made negative contributions of negative 1.0 and negative 0.3 percentage points respectively. Other buildings and structures made the only positive contribution of 1.2 percentage points.
Once again, Britain is relying on its service sector for growth.
Services expanded by 0.5% in the last quarter of 2018, while production shrank by 0.8% and construction output fell by 0.5%.
Updated
UK annual growth rate revised up
Newsflash: Britain’s economy grew even faster last summer than previously thought.
The Office for National Statistics has revised its forecast for growth in the third-quarter of 2018 to +0.7%, up from +0.6%.
This is due to the “one-off effects of the warm weather and the World Cup”, says the ONS (which both boosted consumer spending on food, beer, barbecues...)
That has pushed annual growth to 1.4%, from 1.3% before.
However, the ONS also confirmed its earlier estimate that Britain’s economy only grew by 0.2% in the last three months of 2018.
Growth in the latest quarter was driven by the services sector, while all four sub-sectors of production and construction contributed negatively to GDP growth, it says.
Mike Ashley: Advisors should be jailed
Back in the UK, Sports Direct may be preparing to concede defeat in its pursuit of department store Debenhams.
It has just told the City that it is “giving further consideration” to yesterday’s news that Debenhams creditors had agreed to back its restructuring plan.
That removes one hurdle in front of Debenhams’s plan for a £200m debt-for-equity swap.
Sports Direct had hoped to trump that plan with a takeover bid for Debenhams. It already owns almost 30% of its shares, and was considering paying £40m for the rest.
CEO Mike Ashley isn’t taking the imminent defeat terribly well, suggesting that some of Debenhams advisors should be doing porridge:
Now the results of the vote are known and we have also been subsequently advised that the supportive HSBC are no longer part of Debenhams RCF, I think that if there were any justice in the world the majority of the advisors would be put in prison.”
[RCF = Revolving Credit Facility]
Asian markets have continued to rally, on hopes that the ‘constructive talks’ between the US and China will deliver the goods.
Here’s AFP’s take:
Shanghai surged 3.2 percent and Tokyo ended 0.8 percent higher, while Hong Kong added one percent.
Seoul and Singapore each added 0.6 percent, Sydney put on 0.1 percent and Wellington gained 0.8 percent. Taipei, Mumbai and Manila were also sharply higher.
“Risk assets are being supported right now, in my view, by a dovish Fed, a China stabilisation and better sentiment around geopolitical risks,” Frances Donald at Manulife Asset Management told Bloomberg News.
“That probably gives this rally a little bit more juice.”
English house prices are now falling
We have fresh evidence today that Britain’s housing market is cooling.
Prices across England fell by 0.7% in the last quarter, compared to a year ago, the first annual decline since 2012.
London, once again, led the downturn - with prices sliding by 3.8%.
Overall, UK house prices did rise - but only by 0.7% year-on-year, as the slowdown continues:
Here’s the full story:
Despite TUI’s profits warning, European stock markets are higher across the board.
TUI shares slide after 737 Max profit warning
Newsflash: Holiday company TUI has warned that the Boeing 737 Max crisis will cost it at least €200m.
In an unscheduled announcement, TUI says it has been forced to lease additional aircraft to cover holiday trips, after the 737 Max was grounded by aerospace regulators around the world.
This will take cost the company €200m, assuming that 737 Max’s are cleared to fly by mid-July.
TUI explains:
This impact is especially attributable to costs related to the replacement of aircraft, higher fuel costs, other disruption costs, and the anticipated impact on trading.
But if 737 Max flights don’t resume until the end of September, the total cost could hit €300m.
This has sent its shares down by 10% in early trading:
The 737 Max was grounded earlier this month, days after the Ethiopian Airlines crash that killed 157 people.
Boeing now faces claims that the plane’s automated flight control system was defective, and that its anti-stall system could have caused the crash in Ethiopia .
The Wall Street Journal reports today that:
Officials investigating the fatal crash of a Boeing 737 MAX in Ethiopia have reached a preliminary conclusion that a suspect flight-control feature automatically activated before the plane nose-dived into the ground.
Updated
Neil Wilson of Markets.com says Steven Mnuchin’s tweet has cheered investors, as they wrap up the first quarter of 2019:
“US 10-year Treasury yields are at 2.39%, still on the back foot but off the weekly lows. Equity markets are displaying a bit more optimism again. There is some hope flickering again in terms of trade as Mnuchin and Lighthizer arrive in Beijing for more talks – a tweet this morning saying that these talks were ‘constructive’, with the Chinese vice-premier Liu He set to head to Washington next week for ‘important’ talks.
A nice excuse to bid up markets on the last day of the quarter if ever there was one.
Mining stocks are rallying in London in early trading, as trade war optimism bubbles away.
Glencore, BHP Billiton, Rio Tinto and Anglo American have all gained at least 2%, driving the FTSE 100 up up 45 points or 0.6% to 7278.
Here are some photos of the US delegation arriving for today’s ‘constructive’ talks:
Mnuchin: Talks have been constructive
Newsflash: Treasury secretary Mnuchin has tweeted that today’s negotiations have wrapped up.
He says they were “constructive”, and that vice premier Liu He will return to Washington next week for further talks.
Chinese stock market soars
Optimism over a trade war breakthrough have sent stocks soaring in China.
The benchmark Shanghai composite index has leapt over 3%, on hopes that Beijing’s ‘unprecedented offer’ to address Washington’s concerns could end the deadlock.
David Madden of CMC Markets says:
Sentiment was largely positive after reports that the trade negotiations between the US and China were improving. It was reported that Beijing made ‘unprecedented’ proposals to the US in relation to forced technology transfers, and that it is a major step forward, as the trade talks were never just about China buying more US goods.
Introduction: US-China trade talks resume
Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.
It’s been a topsy-turvy week for the markets, pushed around by fears that the global economy is slowing. But stocks are ending the week stronger, on hopes that Beijing and Washington could finally make progress to end their trade war.
US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin have returned to the Chinese capital today and are holding fresh talks with Liu He, Beijing’s top trade negotiator.
It’s something of a flying visit - just 24 hours - so it’s not clear quite how much progress they’ll make.
But investors have been cheered by reports that China is making “unprecedented offers” on issues such as forced technology transfers.
The US-China trade war has been a major factor weighing on markets for weeks, pushing nervous investors into safe-haven government bonds, so any signs of a breakthrough would be welcome.
Mnuchin raised spirits as he left his hotel for the talks, telling reporters that:
“We had a very productive working dinner last night, and we are looking forward to meeting today.”
Rob Carnell, chief economist and head of Asia-Pacific research at ING Bank, told CNBC’s “Squawk Box” this morning:
“I think ultimately we will be rewarded with a deal of sorts which both sides will proclaim ... as a fantastic victory,”
“The thing to bear in mind is this is a process...Whatever we get out of this, it’s nice to say ‘right, okay we’ll draw a line under this bit, now we have to look forward to all the other things that we haven’t sorted out’.”
Also coming up today
At 9.30am, we get a better insight into the UK economy when the third estimate of GDP for the last quarter of 2018 is released.
Economists fear that this data will confirm that business investment kept shrinking, as Brexit approached. They’ll probably also confirm that the economy only grew by 0.2% in October-December.
The agenda
- 9.30am GMT: UK GDP for Q4 2018 (third estimate)
- 1.30pm GMT: Canadian GDP for January
- 12.30pm GMT: US personal spending figures
Updated