Andrew Sparrow, Alexandra Topping and Kevin Rawlinson 

Papers indicate Robert Jenrick rushed through planning decision so Tory donor could reduce costs by £50m – as it happened

Housing secretary releases documents after accusations of ‘cash for favours’
  
  

A cache of papers relating to a major property development involving Tory donor Richard Desmond has been released.
A cache of papers relating to a major property development involving Tory donor Richard Desmond has been released. Photograph: Toby Melville/Reuters

We’re closing this live blog down now. Thanks for reading and commenting. For the latest developments in the Jenrick story, read my colleague Rajeev Syal’s latest article:

And, for those not fully up to speed, here’s the background:

You can read a summary of the day’s earlier events here.

Updated

PM claims Jenrick 'matter is closed'

Despite this evening’s revelations, the cabinet secretary Mark Sedwill has written to Labour to say the prime minister “considers that the matter is closed”.

Following those comments in the Commons, Reed has now said:

These explosive new revelations show clear discrepancies between what the secretary of state told the House of Commons and what appears in the official documents.

The documents clearly show that Mr Jenrick did not notify officials immediately after his meeting with Mr Desmond; rather than ‘closing down’ the discussion as he claims, he initiated contact with Mr Desmond by text message the following day; and it confirms that he rushed through the decision specifically to help the developer avoid a £30-50m levy payable to the local council for infrastructure in one of the poorest local authorities in England.

The housing secretary needs to come to the House to explain these discrepancies as a matter of urgency: the public must be reassured that there is not one rule for the Conservatives and their wealthy donors and another rule for everyone else.

The Lib Dem MP Layla Moran has said the revelations make Jenrick’s position untenable.

These documents are further evidence that he rushed through this planning decision to help a Tory donor avoid paying millions in tax. This whole grubby saga netted the Conservative party only £12,000, but could have helped Richard Desmond save up to £50m.

The public will be appalled at what looks like a clear abuse of power. Robert Jenrick must go and the Conservative Party must hand back this donation.

Raising a point of order in the Commons, the shadow communities secretary Steve Reed asked whether Jenrick had indicated if he would make a statement following the release of documents relating to the Westferry development application.

Has the Speaker received notification from (Mr Jenrick) that he wishes to give a statement on the documents he has recently released regarding the Westferry decision if there appear to be significant discrepancies between what (Mr Jenrick) told the House and what is revealed in the documents?

Specifically that he did not immediately notify officials following his dinner with the applicant Richard Desmond, that rather than closing discussion down with the developer, as (Mr Jenrick) implied, he instead initiated contact with him the next day via text.

And the letters confirm that he rushed through the decision deliberately to help the developer avoid a 30 to 50 million levy payable to Tower Hamlets Council?

The deputy speaker Dame Rosie Winterton responded:

I have received no notification that (Mr Jenrick) intends to make a statement but obviously the Treasury bench will have heard his (Mr Reed’s) comments, and it is obviously up to ministers to come to the House if they wish to say anything to correct the record through any statement or other means.

According to the documents, that site visit did not take place and no further communication followed because Jenrick “did not take Mr Desmond’s calls” when he attempted to get in contact “on a number of occasions”.

Updated

Another message from Desmond followed on 23 December, in which he said:

Morning Robert How does the advice look? We have to get the approval before January 15 otherwise payment of 45 million pounds to tower hamlets (sic) meaning we have to stop and reduce social housing.

According to the documents, Jenrick again did not reply and it was not until 22 January that he got back in touch, after he approved the development, overruling both Tower Hamlets Council and a planning inspector. His message read:

Richard I hope you understood that I could not speak with you or have contact whilst I was making my decision with respect to the planning application at Westferry - which was why I did not return your messages. Best wishes, Robert.

Desmond replied:

Robert I totally understand why we could not have contact with you or your department while you were making the decision. I have now pushed the button on a further 600million investment at the development as a result of the decision, enabling the social housing and market housing to more than double together with the delivery of the magnificent new school etc etc.

This will create thousands of new jobs pretty much straight away - as we are ‘on it’ and don’t hang around!!!

That exchange, the final messages included in the documents, ended with the pair agreeing to a site visit in March.

Updated

Further text message exchanges followed, beginning on 13 December, when Desmond congratulated the Jenrick on the Conservative election win.

Robert, fantastic day today! So happy and relieved as the whole country is. Well done for keeping calm.

Looking forward to next Thursday. Are you coming here to our offices at 10.30 am and then we’ll all go down to Westferry together? Do you need transport?

But, two days later, Jenrick said he would be unable to make the meeting due to the Queen’s speech.

However we will meet up soon. And I will look at the advice regarding the application this week. Best wishes, Robert.

Desmond replied on the same day asking if they could meet before Christmas but the documents say Jenrick did not reply.

The documents also include text messages exchanged between Jenrick and Desmond shortly after the Tory party fundraiser in November 2019.

On the night of the event, 18 November, Jenrick texted the former media mogul saying it was “good to spend time with him” and looked forward to seeing him again.

In another exchange two days later, Desmond tried to arrange a meeting with the housing secretary for 19 December, as well as a site visit to the Westferry Printworks, complaining about dealing with “Marxists”.

Good news finally the inspectors reports have gone to you today, we appreciate the speed as we don’t want to give Marxists loads of doe for nothing!

We all want to go with the scheme and the social housing we have proposed and spent a month at the Marxist town hall debating, thanks again, all my best, Richard.

Jenrick replied declining a meeting until after a decision had been made due to his position.

As Secretary of State it is important not to give any appearance of being influenced by applicants of cases that I may have a role in or to have predetermined them and so I think it is best that we don’t meet until after the matter has been decided, one way of [sic] another – and I can’t provide any advice to you on that, other than to say that I will receive advice from my officials after the general election assuming I remain in office and will consider it carefully in accordance with the rules and guidance.

Jenrick is under pressure to resign as the newly released documents indicate that he insisted the planning decision for the £1bn development should be rushed through so that a Tory donor’s company could reduce costs by up to £50m.

In one document, a civil servant in the ministry for housing, communities and local government wrote that the secretary of state wanted the Westferry development in east London to be signed off the following day so that Desmond’s company would avoid the Community Infrastructure Levy. The official wrote:

On timing, my understanding is that SoS is/was insistent that decision issued this week ie tomorrow – as next week the viability of the scheme is impacted by a change in the London CIL regime.

Jenrick has also previously confirmed that he looked at images of the development on the phone of Desmond, the former owner of Express Newspapers, at a Tory fundraising event, as revealed by the Sunday Times.

Updated

Papers relating to Richard Desmond planning decision published

The government has released a cache of documents related to a major property development involving the Tory party donor Richard Desmond.

The housing secretary Robert Jenrick intervened to wave through the £1bn Westferry Printworks development but later had to quash his own approval, conceding the decision was unlawful. He agreed to publish the papers after coming under pressure from MPs who have accused him of breaking the ministerial code.

Journalists and other observers will now be combing them for evidence of wrongdoing.

Updated

Afternoon summary

  • Downing Street has refused accept a call from Britain’s medical leaders for a review into how prepared the country is for a second wave of coronavirus. (See 2.46pm.)
  • The Department for Health and Social Care has recorded a further 154 coronavirus deaths in the UK, taking the total to 43,081. (See 4.05pm.)
  • Liz Truss, the international trade secretary, has told MPs that the UK will not allow US chlorine-washed chicken to be stocked in supermarkets as a ban is already written into law. Giving evidence to the international trade committee, she said a ban on importing chlorinated chicken was “already in UK law” as part of the Brexit withdrawal agreement ratified by parliament.

That’s all from me for today.

But the coverage continues on our global coronavirus live blog.

The Guardian’s latest Politics Weekly podcast is out. Jonathan Freedland and Kate Proctor discuss the latest in Westminster, and Peter Walker updates us on Robert Jenrick’s troubles. Plus, Miatta Fahnbulleh and Anoosh Chakelian discuss what’s next for the UK economy, post-furlough scheme.

UK records a further 154 coronavirus deaths

The Department for Health and Social Care has recorded a further 154 coronavirus deaths in the UK, taking the total to 43,081. The full figures are here.

These figures only cover the deaths of people who have tested positive for coronavirus and died. The UK figure for all deaths caused by coronavirus is more than 54,000.

For comparison, here are the equivalent daily UK figures for the past two weeks.

Wednesday 10 June - 245

Thursday 11 June - 151

Friday 12 June - 202

Saturday 13 June - 181

Sunday 14 June - 36

Monday 15 June - 38

Tuesday 16 June - 233

Wednesday 17 June - 184

Thursday 18 June - 135

Friday 19 June - 173

Saturday 20 June - 128

Sunday 21 June - 43

Monday 22 June - 15

Tuesday 23 June - 171

And in another article for the Guardian Stephen Reicher, a psychology professor and member of SPI-B, the Sage subcommittee advising the government on behavioural issues, has strongly criticised Boris Johnson’s decision to abandon the two-metre rule. Here’s an extract.

Whatever the prime minister might say, his policies lead to banner headlines such as Freedom Pass and Independence Day. But we don’t even need to read the papers. Every time we pass an open bar, it will scream to us that the danger is all but gone and we are “back to normal”. After all, who in their right mind would reopen the pubs and abandon distancing in the midst of a deadly pandemic?

But perhaps that is overstating things a little. After all, the government isn’t abandoning all distancing measures. It is saying 1 metre is acceptable when 2 metres is impossible, as long as other measures are applied. True. However, research in the field of proxemics – the study of space and social interaction – shows that, in the UK, 1 metre is roughly the distance we ordinarily maintain with others. So reducing it to 1 metre is akin to removing any restrictions from distancing, and hence functions as another signal of back to normal.

The full article is here.

UPDATE: And this is what Prof Stephen Reicher had to say about Boris Johnson’s comments about the test and trace system at PMQs.

Updated

Labour has warned Rishi Sunak that the Treasury’s one-size-fits-all approach to ending wage subsidies risks a period of mass unemployment that will reverse much of the good done by the furlough, my colleague Larry Elliott reports. Writing for the Guardian, the shadow chancellor, Anneliese Dodds, called on Sunak to use his planned summer statement next month to extend financial support to vulnerable sectors beyond the October deadline for winding up the scheme.

The full story from Larry is here.

Tracey Crouch, the Conservative former sports minister, has revealed that she is being treated for breast cancer.

There has been one further coronavirus death in Northern Ireland, according to the Department of Health in Northern Ireland, taking the total to 547.

The head of Scotland’s largest teaching union has written an excoriating letter to members highlighting the “anxiety, frustration, confusion and even anger” prompted by the Scottish government’s decision yesterday to park agreed plans for a socially distanced return to schools in August, instead telling teachers to prepare for full-time return with no distancing.

The move came after a significant backlash from concerned parents who were facing indefinite part-time schooling as some years groups were told pupils would only be spending one or two days each week in classrooms and the rest at home.

The general secretary of the Educational Institute of Scotland (EIS), Larry Flanagan, described it as a “political announcement”, and said that the statement had not been discussed with the CERG (Covid Education Recovery Group), of which he is a member.

In a strongly-worded members’ email, Flanagan said the sudden policy shift from blended model of at-home and in-school learning to accommodate distancing to no distancing was a “maybes aye; maybes naw” scenario, dependent on levels of virus suppression in seven weeks’ time and giving no certainty in the interim.

He also highlighted to frustration of teachers who had been working hard to put blended learning in place, only to have the plans change dramatically in the week – and in some cases on the day – that term ends.

He added that the EIS “is not convinced that no physical distancing between pupils is safe and we are absolutely certain that physical distancing between pupils and teachers remains essential”. Accepting that by August the amount of distance required may have been reduced from the current 2-metre requirement – the Scottish government’s scientific advisory group will report on this by 2 July - Flannagan insisted “there cannot be a social distancing rule for outside of schools and a different one for inside classrooms”.

Updated

Public Health Wales has recorded a further eight coronavirus deaths in Wales, taking the total to 1,491. The full details are here.

NHS England has recorded a further 51 hospital coronavirus deaths in England, taking the total to 28,435. The full details are here.

For comparison, here are the equivalent daily figures announced over the last two weeks.

Wednesday 10 June - 88

Thursday 11 June - 83

Friday 12 June - 70

Saturday 13 June - 67

Sunday 14 June - 27

Monday 15 June - 28

Tuesday 16 June - 79

Wednesday 17 June - 77

Thursday 18 June - 62

Friday 19 June - 46

Saturday 20 June - 71

Sunday 21 June - 26

Monday 22 June - 20

Tuesday 23 June - 46

No 10 refuses to accept call from medical leaders for review of UK readiness for Covid-19 second wave

The Downing Street lobby briefing is over. Here are the main points.

  • No 10 is refusing to accept the call from Britain’s medical leaders for a review into how prepared the country is for a second wave of coronavirus. (See 11.40am.) Asked about the letter from them in the BMJ, the prime minister’s spokesman said that the government had taken “unprecedented action” to support the NHS. He also said the emergency Nightingale hospitals were on standby and could be used in the winter if necessary. The Nightingale hospitals in London, Manchester, Bristol, Harrogate and Sunderland have all been mothballed. The one in Exeter is still being built, but will also be put on standby when it is ready, the spokesman indicated.
  • The spokesman defended Boris Johnson’s claim that no country in the world has a “functional” contact-tracing app. Echoing a claim he made in the Commons yesterday, Johnson told MPs at PMQs:

I wonder whether [Starmer] can name a single country in the world that has a functional contact-tracing app? Because there isn’t one.

When it was put to him that other countries do have apps, the spokesman said that they did not fully record people’s contacts and that they were not reliable enough to be used to tell people to self-isolate. The spokesman also referred to this blog from the Full Fact factchecking website. The article concluded:

While it’s certainly true that some countries have launched track-and-trace apps, it may be too early to know whether these apps are having the intended effect in helping to contain the spread of the pandemic.

  • The spokesman said, under the new rules coming into force in England from 4 July, the police would be able to break up “large and irresponsible gatherings of over 30 people”. But largely the new guidance will be advisory, rather than mandatory. The spokesman also said that the police would be able to enforce the rule about wearing face masks on public transport and the rules relating to quarantine.
  • The spokesman played down suggestions that it might be necessary for signs in England telling people to observe the 2-metre rule to be replaced. He said that at the press conference yesterday Prof Chris Whitty, the government’s chief medical adviser, had stressed that the 2-metre rule was still a good one to follow.
  • Downing Street was unable to defend Johnson’s claim at PMQs today that “actually there are 100,000 fewer children in absolute poverty and 500,000 falling below the thresholds of low income and material deprivation”. As the Mirror’s Dan Bloom reports, official figures suggest both claims are wrong (although Johnson did not explain what timeframe he was using).
  • The spokesman suggested that Johnson was not proposing any new help for people who have to self-isolate, when he told MPs at PMQs that “nobody should be penalised for doing the right thing”. (See 12.20pm.) The spokesman said that this was a phrase Johnson has used before. It was a reference to statutory sick pay being available, he said, adding that some employers also offered their own help to workers who were self-isolating.
  • The spokesman would not commit to the government holding a coronavirus press conference at least once a week, now that the daily one has been cancelled. He just said they would take place when the government had significant news to announce.
  • The spokesman said that the government would be publishing more documents today providing guidance for businesses about opening up in England from 4 July. It published 11 overnight. (See 9.29am.)

Updated

Jenrick to release government papers relating to controversial Richard Desmond planning decision

Robert Jenrick, the housing secretary, has pledged to release “all relevant information” connected to a major property development involving the Tory party donor Richard Desmond. Speaking in the Commons, in the debate on a Labour motion saying all the papers should be published, he said he would outline the timeline of events and the rationale for his decision-making over the Westferry Printworks planning decision.

As PA Media reports, Jenrick said further information would be released later today, noting that discussions and correspondence “which the government would not normally release” would be made public.

He accused Labour of making “wild accusations” against him and claimed the documents would show a decision was taken with an “open mind” on the merits of the case.

Updated

At the Commons home affairs committee this morning Yvette Cooper, the Labour chair, said she was “shocked” when told that full police data on the proportion of lockdown fines handed to BAME people would not be released until late July.

As PA Media reports, the chairman of the National Police Chiefs’ Council (NPCC), Martin Hewitt, told the committee the figures would only be ready in the third week of July. Publicly available data suggests that black, Asian and minority ethnic (BAME) people have been at least 50% more likely to receive coronavirus lockdown fines in England than white people. The Government Statistical Service is looking through all police data up to 8 June, before it will be published by the NPCC. Hewitt told the committee:

I think it is really important that data is contextualised. Ultimately each force has to account for the way that they ran the operation through the pandemic.

In response, Cooper said:

This is a very long time to wait for what seems to be some extremely basic data that actually seems to be really important in the policing decisions that need to be made.

I’ll be honest with you, I’m really shocked that you don’t have this data that you haven’t got a system for collecting this data built in from the beginning and that it is taking so long.

I do appreciate that these were completely new regulations that you had to enforce but I don’t understand why this data wouldn’t be collected normally anyway and that you can’t provide it more swiftly.

Updated

Labour says public should continue to get briefings from government scientists

Labour has said that, following the cancellation of the daily No 10 press conferences, the government should ensure that its scientists continue to brief the public. A spokesman for Sir Keir Starmer said:

Those press briefings were an opportunity for the public not only to hear from ministers but the scientists as well. And we would say to the government you do need to ensure there is a mechanism to allow the public to continue to hear from scientists.

Whether it is daily briefings, monthly briefings with the scientists, hearing advice from the scientists was a very crucial element of those briefings.

Students in year 11 who have missed out after six months of “neglect” need urgent financial support from the government so they do not fall further behind, an education leader has warned. Speaking to the Commons education committee, David Hughes, chief executive of the Association of Colleges (AoC), said he was worried that teenagers in year 11 had not been a priority for many schools during closures amid the Covid-19 pandemic.

And he said it was “indefensible” that 16-year-olds starting college in September have been left out of the government’s £1bn plan to help young people catch up with their education in the autumn. He told the MPs:

We’ve asked for £200m - which will be a pupil premium type upgrade for funding for those students who need it most. Disadvantaged students getting the extra support in the autumn to catch up after six months of probably some neglect.

Updated

Here is the PA Media story about PMQs.

Boris Johnson was accused of either dodging questions or giving “dodgy answers” as he came under fire for the government’s Covid-19 contact-tracing app.

Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer cut a frustrated figure as he clashed with Johnson at PMQs over England’s readiness to ease lockdown restrictions.

The prime minister responded by urging Stamer to press Labour councils to encourage children to return to school when asked about the timescale for a working app to track people who have been in contact with someone with Covid-19.

Some £11.8m was spent by the government on developing its own NHSX app before it was ditched. It is now examining software created by Apple and Google to build one.

Speaking in the Commons, Starmer highlighted how two previous answers from the PM about a decrease in absolute child poverty and relative child poverty were judged “mostly false” by the office of the children’s commissioner for England.

He said another claim from the PM about fewer families living in poverty was also deemed “false”.

Starmer said of Johnson: “He’s been found out. He either dodges the question or he gives dodgy answers.

“No more witnesses, I rest my case. Will the prime minister do the decent thing and correct the record in relation to child poverty?”

Johnson replied: “I’m happy to point out to my learned friend that actually there are 100,000 fewer children in absolute poverty and 500,000 falling below the thresholds of low income and material deprivation.”

Updated

The Scottish government has published a graphic guide (pdf) to the lockdown easing measures announced by Nicola Sturgeon this afternoon. (See 1.12pm.) There is also a summary here.

And here is the text of Sturgeon’s speech to the Scottish parliament about the announcement.

PMQs - Snap verdict

Boris Johnson has never won an exchange with Sir Keir Starmer (or anyone?) on a matter of detail. He can survive by changing the subject (as he did reasonably effectively last week), but it does not always work, and it certainly didn’t today. He floundered badly. It was almost dismal.

Johnson’s first mistake, when Starmer asked about the biggest problem with the test and trace system (that it does not even pick up most of the people being infected with coronavirus) was to revert to outright denial. If he had said: ‘Yes, that’s an issue, but it’s early days, it is being addressed etc etc’, he might have done okay. (Exchanges like this after often “won” by whoever sounds most reasonable.) But his blend of full-on denial combined with feigned indignation was just too implausible to be a runner, and it felt as if Starmer did not even have to try too hard to point this out. After a question about local government, Johnson then tried the denial/indignation schtick all over again in response to Starmer’s question about the government’s app, and this time he was on even weaker ground. In the new socially distanced Commons, with fewer MPs and less shouting, it is not so obvious when a principal is losing the support of his backbenchers. But it is hard to believe that the Tory MPs were impressed. They are partisan and supportive, but that does not mean they can’t spot a duff argument when they hear one.

Last week Johnson got through PMQs by changing the subject and relentless taunting Starmer about ambiguity in Labour’s education position. He tried that again, but it has late, half-hearted, and we had heard it all before. More importantly, it was obvious that the questions he was avoiding were really important ones, that will be crucial in determining whether or not there is a second peak. (Last week Starmer was asking about poverty, which is really important too, but it matters less to many Tory MPs. At PMQs the most crucial audience of all are the backbenchers on your own side.)

It is a measure of how ill-equipped CCHQ is to see off Starmer that the one attack line Johnson has to resort to is that he is a lawyer. Perhaps there is a residual English distrust for lawyers. (The famous Shakespeare quote, “The first thing we must do is kill all the lawyers”, would probably appeal to Dominic Cummings.) But being able to denounce someone as a lawyer is not quite the same as being able label them as Marxist, antisemitic terrorist-sympathiser (the line used against Jeremy Corbyn - unfairly, but with enough substance for the jibe to work). The Tories also seem to have forgotten that Margaret Thatcher was a lawyer too. Interestingly, Starmer seems to have decided to embrace this line of attack. He even joked about it self-referentially in his final question, when he said:

[Johnson has] been found out. He either dodges the question or he gives dodgy answers. No more witnesses, I rest my case.

And he had. It was a compelling one.

Updated

Sturgeon announces further lockdown easing in Scotland

Nicola Sturgeon has announced further easing of lockdown restrictions – including an end to the five-mile travel limit, opening of beer gardens and more socialising - as weekly data from the National Records of Scotland shows reduction in deaths for the eighth consecutive week.

Sturgeon told the Scottish parliament:

Our pace is slightly slower than England but it is, in my view, right for our circumstances and, I hope, more likely to be sustainable than if we went faster now.

After the announcement yesterday that pupils can return to school full-time in August if virus suppression continues, she added:

I hope the prospect of getting children back to full-time education gives us all an added incentive [to comply].

She said that she was still waiting for a report from her government’s own scientific advisory group on 2-metre distancing, but hoped to find a “viable and safe balance” for businesses.

The Scottish government will also work with the retail sector on a campaign to promote use of face masks in shops, and she confirmed that hospitality businesses will be required to take details of customers and store for them for four weeks.

Giving indicative dates for the rest of phase 2 and some of phase 3, she said:

  • From 3 July they were planning to lift the 5-mile limit on travel for leisure and exercise, and holiday cottages where there are no shared services, can open from then. She asked visitors “to be sensitive to rural and island communities”.
  • From 6 July open outdoor hospitality like beer gardens would be allowed.
  • Going into phase 3, from 10 July people should be able to meet more households outdoors with distancing. The government is also planning an expansion of the extended household model and ways for young people to mix with friends over the summer.
  • From 15 July early learning and childcare services would resume, but it was likely that their capacity would be restricted. Also households would be able to meet indoors with hygiene restrictions.
  • From 15 July pubs and restaurants can open indoors, with distancing, as well as hairdressers and barbers.

Updated

Matt Rodda, the Labour MP for Reading East, asks about the attack at the weekend. Will the investigation get all it needs?

Johnson thanks Rodda for the question and pays tribute to the police and members of the public who intervened. If there are any lessons to be learnt, they will be learnt, he says. And he says they will not let this sort of senseless murder change our way of life.

And that’s it. PMQs is over.

Flick Drummond, a Conservative, asks about tension between India and China.

Johnson says the government is monitoring the situation closely.

Johnson says of course he accepts responsibility for everything that happened.

But the discharge of patients into care homes was done on the basis of clinical advice, he says.

Ian Levy, a Conservative, asks about investment in Blyth Valley.

Johnson says UK steel manufacturers will be at the front of the queue for the infrastructure opportunities he is creating.

Johnson says the government is going to implement the recommendations of the Windrush report. It is committed to stamping out racism, he says.

The DUP’s Sammy Wilson asks about plans to put border controls at Larne in Northern Ireland.

Johnson claims there will be no new customs infrastructure because under the Northern Ireland Protocol it is clear that Northern Ireland is part of the UK.

Labour’s John Spellar asks for changes to rules relating to the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act, which he says discriminates against BAME people.

Johnson says any MP knows about the hard cases thrown up by this. He says the government is considering what to do in the light of a supreme court ruling on this.

Updated

Robert Butler, a Conservative, asks if the government will help people acquire new skills if they lose their jobs.

Johnson says he will. He wants to encourage as many in-work placements.

Labour’s Mohammad Yasin says the government does not know how many people are infected. Testing figures are not reliable, he suggests.

Johnson claims the government has a pretty good estimate as to the extent of coronavirus. And he says the government is getting better at local crackdowns.

The SNP’s Philippa Whitford asks what the government will do to protect aerospace jobs.

Johnson says he wants to use this as an opportunity to promote low-carbon technology. He claims this will help the industry.

Labour’s Jessica Morden says people with terminal conditions have to prove they are terminally ill if they want to access certain benefits. They are at risk of losing out. She asks the government to implement the recommendations of a review looking at this.

Johnson says he will write to her about this.

Liz Saville Roberts, the Plaid Cymru leader at Westminster, says Covid has broken out in three Welsh food processing plants. The workers in these places are low-paid. Will the government commit to local furlough-type schemes?

Johnson says the furlough scheme has been a massive commitment.

He says if we have to move back to local lockdowns, “nobody should be penalised for doing the right thing”.

(That sounded like an appeal to employers to ensure that staff who have to isolate don’t lose out, but it is unclear from what he said he intends to enforce that in any way.)

Ian Blackford, the SNP leader at Westminster, says MPs will want to pass their condolences to the family of the three children killed in a house fire in Paisley last week.

He asks about the BMJ letter (see 11.40am), and he says there is an economic emergency too. Will the PM welcome the plans in the Benny Higgins report presented to the Scottish government?

Johnson says he will look at the report.

Blackford asks Johnson if he will give the Scottish government the powers it needs for economic recovery.

Johnson refers to the sums of money the Scottish government is already getting from London.

Starmer condemns PM for 'dodgy answers' as he challenges him on test and trace and app at PMQs

Starmer says Germany has a functioning app. It has 12m downloads. When are we going to have a working app?

Johnson says Starmer is wrong. No country has a working, contact-tracing app. He says the UK has a fantastic test and trace system running that will be essential to the UK’s success. He asks Starmer is clear up whether he wants Labour councils to encourage pupils back to school?

Yes, says Starmer. He says he does want them back. He says the only U-turn came from the education secretary.

He says the children’s commissioner has said that Johnson was wrong about child poverty last week. He has been found out. He either dodges the question, or gives dodgy questions. Will he correct the record?

[Johnson has] been found out. He either dodges the question or he gives dodgy answers. No more witnesses, I rest my case.

Johnson does not accept that. He quotes some figures backing his case. And he says the biggest cause of child poverty is children not going to school.

Updated

Starmer turns to the app. This really matters, he says. How on earth do you contact everyone in a crowded place without one. The government used to say it was critical. Now it is only additional. Is it critical or not?

Johnson says Starmer cannot name a single country in the world with a successful app, because there is not one. He says the opposition is yo-yoing.

Starmer says he is using the government’s own figures. He says the PM should not resist challenge, because challenge makes for better policy.

He says councils want to know what local lockdown means. When will councils get the guidance they need?

Johnson says, when there are local outbreaks, there have been local lockdowns. There is an effective “cluster-busting operation”, he says. He says this is effective.

He says he is not going to pretend this is beaten. Councils will be supported, he says.

Updated

Starmer says Johnson did not address the question. He asks about those not being contacted. He says Johnson risk making the same mistakes as he did at the start. he says he will ask the question in a different way; what is the strategy for reaching those missed.

Johnson says Starmer has misled MPs.

The Speaker reprimands him.

Johnson says Starmer has inadvertently misled MPs. He says the scheme has contacted the vast majority of people who tested positive. He says he understands how lawyers work. Is Starmer for or against the scheme?

Sir Keir Starmer says Labour wants the plan to work. But for it to work, the UK needs an effective test and trace system. The latest figures show around 30,000 people are infected. But only around 10,000 people are being reached. There is a big problem, isn’t there?

Johnson disagrees. He says Starmer has been “stunned” by the success of the system. He says 87,000 people have been contacted and have agreed to self-isolate. He says Starmer would not have predicted that.

Updated

Sarah Atherton, a Conservative, says her constituents welcomed the decision to reduce the Covid alert level from 4 to 3. Does the PM agree a UK-wide approach is what works?

Boris Johnson starts by thanking Atherton for her work as a doctor during the pandemic. And he agrees.

PMQs

PMQs is about to start.

Here is the list (pdf) of MPs down to ask a question.

These are from Tom Newton Dunn from Times Radio on the new guidelines for England.

Shapps floats plan for memorial to transport workers who died from coronavirus

Ministers are considering a memorial to the 54 transport workers who have died from coronavirus, which could be erected at London Victoria station, where Belly Mujinga worked and is believed to have contracted the virus.

The transport secretary, Grant Shapps, told the Commons transport select committee that he had discussed a specific memorial or commemoration of transport workers killed by Covid-19.

Although he stressed it was not clear whether the 54, which included a large number of bus drivers, had been infected at work, he paid tribute, saying:

They were doing essential jobs … these were the people getting NHS workers, care workers and our food to the right place at the right times.

Belly Mujinga died after falling ill days after being spat at by a man who said he had Covid-19, while she was on duty working at Victoria. The CPS is reviewing the case after police initially said there was not enough evidence to bring a prosecution.

Updated

Medical leaders say second wave 'real risk' as they demand urgent review of national preparedness

As we’ve already mentioned (see 9.12am), the most senior figures in British medicine have signed an open letter to political leaders calling for a review to prepare the country for a possible second wave of coronavirus.

The full letter is on the British Medical Journal website and, since it may well come up at PMQs, it is worth quoting at length. Here’s an extract.

Several countries are now experiencing Covid-19 flare-ups. While the future shape of the pandemic in the UK is hard to predict, the available evidence indicates that local flare-ups are increasingly likely and a second wave a real risk. Many elements of the infrastructure needed to contain the virus are beginning to be put in place, but substantial challenges remain. The job now is not only to deal urgently with the wide ranging impacts of the first phase of the pandemic, but to ensure that the country is adequately prepared to contain a second phase.

You may have seen the recent editorial in The BMJ calling for a transparent rapid review of where we are and what needs to be done to prevent and prepare for a second wave. We believe that such a review is crucial and needs to happen soon if the public is to have confidence that the virus can be contained.

The review should not be about looking back or attributing blame. Rather it should be a rapid and forward looking assessment of national preparedness, based on an examination of the complex and inter-related policy areas listed below. These are too broad for any one of the existing select committees. That is why a cross-party commission was suggested, establishing a constructive, non-partisan, four-nations approach that could rapidly produce practical recommendations for action, based on what we have all learnt, and without itself becoming a distraction for those at the front line or in government. These recommendations should not require primary legislation or major organisational change. The approach would also help the public understand how and by whom they will be implemented. We believe this will be essential if the UK is to get ahead of the curve.

The letter also says the review should focus on five particular areas. They are:

  • Governance including parliamentary scrutiny and involvement of regional and local structures and leaders.
  • Procurement of goods and services.
  • Coordination of existing structures, in a way designed to optimise the establishment of effective public health and communicable disease control infrastructure, the resilience of the NHS as a whole, and the shielding of vulnerable individuals and communities.
  • The disproportionate burden on black, Asian, and minority ethnic individuals and communities.
  • International collaboration, especially to mitigate any new difficulties in pandemic management due to Brexit.

The letter has not just been signed by a random selection of senior doctors; more or less everyone of any importance at the top of the British medical establishment has signed it.

The signatories include: the presidents of the Royal College of Surgeons, the Royal College of Psychiatrists, the Royal College of Radiologists, the Royal College of Physicians, the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh, the Royal College of Emergency Medicine, the Royal College of General Practitioners, the Royal College of Pathologists, the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, the Faculty of Public Health, the Royal College of Nursing and the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Glasgow; the chair of the BMA; and the editors in chief of the BMJ and the Lancet.

Updated

The Times’s Patrick Maguire has some drinking news for people who work at Westminster.

Sadiq Khan, the mayor of London, has launched a consultation today on a proposal to move the Greater London Authority out of City Hall and relocate it to the Crystal building in the Royal Docks. He says this could save London £55m over five years.

The Liberal Democrat leadership candidate Layla Moran has said the government should hold a review of its handling of coronavirus now so that it can use the lessons to prepare for a potential second spike. In a statement she said:

The government needs to listen to the concerns being raised by scientists and medical experts and implement an urgent review into its handling of the coronavirus so far. We need to ensure that any review is fully independent from the government, fully transparent and that all parties are then invited to come together to develop practical recommendations.

We know that significant mistakes have been made, from the failure to get a test and trace system up and running to lack of PPE. An honest, independent appraisal of these mistakes would ensure the right lessons are learned.

In the Commons yesterday her rival in the contest, the acting Lib Dem leader Sir Ed Davey, made more or less exactly the same argument. In response, Boris Johnson said an inquiry now would not be “a good use of official time”.

Voting opens in the Lib Dem leadership contest at the end of next month, and the result will be announced at the end of August.

YouGov published some snap polling on the lockdown easing measures for England announced by Boris Johnson yesterday. It suggests almost half the public think he has got it about right, while just over a third think he is going too far.

Rachel Burden from the BBC’s Radio 5 Live has more on the new guidance issued by the government overnight.

The Scottish government has relied too heavily on food charity during the coronavirus outbreak, according to Food Workers for Food Justice, a group of independent food banks, community food groups and supporting organisations who have written an open letter to the first minister, Nicola Sturgeon.

While praising the Scottish government’s “cash first” approach to food aid, the letter calls for an end to the government’s dependence on food banks and stresses that direct monetary relief must be accessible to all those who need it.

The Trussell Trust reported an 89% increase in need for emergency food parcels during April 2020, while the Independent Food Aid Network figures show a 246% increase in the number of parcels distributed in Scotland in April 2020 in comparison with last year.

Setting out a manifesto for long-term change, the signatories - who represent over 35 different community food initiatives based in 14 Scottish local authorities – put forward a plan for nationwide food hubs that are community run but centrally funded as part of a move towards building a local and sustainable food system, as well as enshrining the right to food in law. “Now is the time to start creating these structures that will enable resilience for future crisis scenarios and provide essential support today.”

Sabine Goodwin, coordinator of the Independent Food Aid Network, said:

Independent food banks in Scotland have reported huge increases in need for emergency food parcels since the outbreak of Covid-19. The Scottish government’s “cash first” approach is most welcome but as the poverty crisis deepens much more needs to be done. Food bank teams are doing all they can but the voices of frontline volunteers need to be heard. They cannot continue to be relied on to pick up the pieces.

Updated

Scientists have proposed lifting lockdown completely for a “medium-sized city” to see if coronavirus can be controlled through weekly testing of residents, PA Media reports. A paper published in the Royal Society Open Science journal argues that a demonstration study is needed to see if such regular testing, strict household quarantine, contact tracing and mobile phone apps could end the Covid-19 epidemic.

Researchers suggest large-scale testing of city residents could be done through examining saliva samples - a technique called RT-LAMP testing, which they said is cheaper and more viable than nasal or throat swab tests. The paper, authored by Julian Peto, professor of epidemiology at the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine and 10 other experts, said 10 million tests per day are needed for weekly testing of the UK population. It said:

This is feasible with single-step RT-LAMP on saliva samples, which requires minimal equipment and training. A facility with about 100 staff could probably do 50,000 tests per day. If so, a city of 350,000 people could be served by a single laboratory.

As PA Media reports, researchers said no government has considered this option as it was assumed it would not be technically possible, but they argued that the technology could be implemented “even in low resource rural settings”.

Agenda for the day

Here is the agenda showing what is coming up later today.

9.30am: The Commons education committee takes evidence from the Association of Colleges, the BCC and others on the impact of coronavirus on education and children’s services.

10.30am: The National Police Chiefs’ Council gives evidence to the Commons home affairs committee about policing and BAME communities.

10.30am: Grant Shapps, the transport secretary, gives evidence to the Commons transport committee.

12pm: Boris Johnson faces Sir Keir Starmer at PMQs.

12.20pm: Nicola Sturgeon, Scotland’s first minister, takes questions in the Scottish parliament.

12.30pm: The Welsh government holds its daily coronavirus briefing.

Around 1pm: MPs begin a debate on a Labour motion requesting a “humble address” to force the release of papers relating to the decision by Robert Jenrick, the communities secretary, to approve a housing development belonging to the Tory donor Richard Desmond. The vote will come at around 4pm.

2.30pm: The Commons women and equalities committee takes evidence from disability charities about coronavirus.

2.30pm: Liz Truss, the international trade secretary, gives evidence to the Commons international trade committee.

Updated

And Steven Swinford from the Times has some highlights from the new guidance too.

Jack Blanchard from Politico Europe has already had a good look at the new guidance (see 9.29am) for his London Playbook morning briefing. For some reason, he seemed to take a keen interest in the rules that would apply for pubs. Here’s an extract from his write-up.

Meet ‘n’ greet: Pubs will be offering hand sanitizer at the door, while “encouraging compliance” among drinkers with the new limits on social gatherings. In other words — staff will be expected to explain to that big gang of lads who came in for some serious drinking on Super Saturday that, erm, sorry about this chaps, but “indoor gatherings should be limited to members of any two households”. It should make for some entertaining conversations about people’s supposed living arrangements, if nothing else.

This is England: Ministers clearly fear sudden rain showers could also be a problem, when beer gardens are packed and access to venues restricted. Pubs should be “planning for maintaining social distancing … in the event of adverse weather conditions,” the government warns, “being clear that customers cannot seek shelter indoors unless social distancing can be maintained.” Again, the conversations at the door with the now half-cut (and half-soaked) lads demanding shelter at the bar should be worth watching.

Updated

Ministers publish 11 guides saying how firms should operate as lockdown eases in England

Good morning. I’m Andrew Sparrow, joining the blog for the day.

Boris Johnson made his Commons statement yesterday about relaxing the lockdown in England significantly from 4 July before the government had published the guidance saying exactly how businesses like pubs etc would be expected to operate.

The guidance was finally published last night, and there are 11 separate guides covering 11 areas of work. They are:

Close contact services

Construction and other outdoor work

Factories, plants and warehouses

Labs and research facilities

Offices and contact centres

Other people’s homes

Restaurants, pubs, bars and takeaway services

Shops and branches

Vehicles

The visitor economy

Hotels and other guest accommodation

Commenting on the fact that gyms and swimming pools are still not able to open Mark Sesnan, chief executive of Greenwich Leisure, said the government needed to act soon to avoid “cataclysm” for public leisure facilities.

Speaking to BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, he said:

I think there is a big danger that if this goes on much longer, the light at the end of the tunnel was to be able to open from 6 July - someone has just switched that light off.

They need to turn it back on again fairly quickly if we are to avoid the kind of cataclysm because there is no money coming in and the expenses are still going out.

The furlough scheme is great and we thank the chancellor for that but staff is only half our costs.

At the moment, it is still rescue-able but much longer and I think the country will have a problem nationwide with public facilities struggling to ever reopen.

Updated

Health leaders are calling for an urgent review to ensure Britain is properly prepared for the “real risk” of a second wave of coronavirus.

In an open letter to the leaders of all the UK political parties, published in the British Medical Journal, the health leaders call for a “rapid and forward-looking assessment” of the state of national preparedness.

The appeal is backed by the presidents of the Royal Colleges of Physicians, Surgeons, GPs and Nursing, and the chair of the British Medical Association. They said:

While the future shape of the pandemic in the UK is hard to predict, the available evidence indicates that local flare-ups are increasingly likely and a second wave a real risk.

Many elements of the infrastructure needed to contain the virus are beginning to be put in place, but substantial challenges remain. The job now is not only to deal urgently with the wide-ranging impacts of the first phase of the pandemic, but to ensure that the country is adequately prepared to contain a second phase.

Read the full story here:

Updated

Burnham says decision to all pubs to open on a 'Super Saturday' risky

The mayor of Greater Manchester, Andy Burnham, has criticised the government for reopening the hospitality industry on a Saturday. In an interview on Sky News he said:

I would say that they have just come down on the side of risk, rather than caution, on the side of the economy rather than health. The plan to open everything on a Saturday is, I think, a mistake, certainly unwise. I think people in local police forces and councils across the country will think: why? Why is all of that happening on a Saturday? That is risky.

He admitted he was concerned about how the police would keep gatherings under control, following illegal raves in Greater Manchester, which over the space of two weekends left one man dead of a suspected drug overdose and two men shot dead in Moss Side.

I am concerned about everything opening up on what Sky might dub ‘Super Saturday’. Why open everything on that day? Surely a staggered approach would have been fairer for our police force.

Burnham said that Boris Johnson had effectively “transferred the handling of the crisis from national to local government”. Councils were not yet properly resourced to deal with it, he said, noting that the Greater Manchester councils were facing a shortfall of £400m in their budgets.

He said the guidance around the “2-metre rule” was “too nuanced” and “on the risky side of the line”. The government should have told the public to stay two metres away from people unless they were wearing a face covering, he said. They should also be advised to cover their faces when going into pubs and restaurants, he added.

Burnham also criticised the government for dropping the daily media briefing. He said:

This is a time when the public needs more local and regional information to navigate the risks that are out there.

He suggested that the briefings wouldn’t always have to be fronted by a minister but the chief medical officer or senior scientists.

Updated

Scotland’s education secretary, John Swinney, has insisted that there is no contradiction between his announcement yesterday that pupils can return to school full-time with no physical distancing, and Nicola Sturgeon’s continued adherence to 2-metre social distancing.

He said the Scottish government was guided by international evidence of successful return to school with no distancing, as well as evidence that young people generally are not as affected by coronavirus or as significant transmitters of it. He added that there had been significant suppression of the virus in Scotland over the past month, going from 20,000 people capable of transmitting the infection to 2,000, and that there may be further changes to social distancing guidance across society by August.

Last week Swinney suggested that it was likely that part-time schooling – the “blending learning” model which had councils planning for a mixture of in-school and at-home learning with some year groups in the classroom for as little as one or two days a week – would continue for the entire academic year 2020-21.

But yesterday Swinney told teachers to prepare for a full-time return from 11 August, which opposition parties have dubbed a “screeching U-turn” in the face of growing parental pressure. But Swinney insisted on BBC Radio Scotland this morning that the decision was taken in light of continued suppression of the virus and compliance with public health measures.

Asked about the anger voiced by many teachers yesterday at the about-turn – the week that schools break up for the summer holidays – after they spent weeks preparing for a blended model, Swinney thanked them for their hard work and insisted that the blended model remains a contingency plan.

Updated

Sir David King, former chief scientific adviser to the government has been speaking on Sky News this morning. He believes the lockdown easing is happening “too quickly” and risks a “very significant” second wave.

The decision to exit lockdown is a “political” one, he says.

Updated

Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme Adrian Vinken, the chief executive of the Theatre Royal Plymouth, has said theatres are unlikely to be able to reopen until social distancing measures were scrapped entirely.

He said the Devon theatre has told more than 100 staff - a third of its operation - that their jobs could be at risk.

The government will allow theatres to reopen from 4 July but not for live performances - a change Vinken said was unlikely to benefit theatres, such as his, which did not have large screens to compete with cinemas.

Asked whether the new measure would have any benefit for his organisation, Vinken said:

None whatsoever.

Only when social distancing is a thing of the past and people feel comfortable and able to return safely to the theatre, the sheer economics of large-scale theatre just won’t work.

Updated

The closure of courts across the UK has created a huge backlog of cases.

This led to some judges suggesting that less serious crimes could be tried in crown courts before a judge without a jury in order to tackle the thousands of cases building up during the pandemic crisis.

Robert Buckland, the justice secretary, has told MPs that the backlog in the criminal justice system in England and Wales had grown to around 41,000 cases.

Read that full story here:

Caroline Goodwin QC, the chair of the Criminal Bar Association, has been on the BBC Radio 4’s Today programme:

She urged ministers to give the criminal justice sector access to more buildings in order to restart jury trials.

She said:

The courts are open, everything that is possibly being done is actually being put into place to open those buildings so we can have juries back in.

There is no question other than the way forward at this time, in this situation, is to open those buildings up, make sure that they are safe, give us access to more buildings where we can bring jurors in, give us those facilities and we can deliver in a very short period of time because we put our shoulder to the wheel.

What we are asking the Lord Chancellor to do is give us access to more buildings.

This is a question of practical logistics.

Updated

Dame Louise Casey, who was put in charge of a government specialist taskforce to tackle homelessness in May, has been speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme this morning.

She was very upbeat and positive about the opportunity that now exists to end rough sleeping for good, as hotels start to reopen for business. She said:

It’s a huge job to manage all of this .... it’s a hugely busy time already but we all have to keep going.

An extra £85m has been announced by the Treasury to provide emergency accommodation for 5,400 rough sleepers who have been placed in hotels in England for the duration of the pandemic, avoiding them having to return to the streets when the hotels reopen to the public this summer.

Read that story here:

She also said there had to be a solution for those rough sleepers who have no recourse to public funds.

Let’s remember Covid-19 has not gone away, and I am already concerned that people have gone out of hotels onto the streets in London.

Whether you are from Portugal, Eritrea or Kent, Covid-19 is still very much alive and still very much can kill people so you have to take the necessary precautions.

She added that organisations across the country had made extraordinary efforts to end rough sleeping, and there was a steely determination in the sector to ensure things did not go back to the way they were.

Enough people are really up for making sure we don’t go back to mass rough sleeping, and with the money we have, God willing, we won’t have to.

Updated

Morning summary

  • Health leaders have warned that there is a “real risk” of a second wave of coronavirus as the country opens up after lockdown. In an open letter signed by the presidents of the Royal Colleges of Surgeons, Nursing, Physicians, and GPs published in the British Medical Journal, ministers were warned that urgent action would be needed to prevent further loss of life.
  • Ministers are in talks to create “air bridges” with a number of “core” European countries including Spain, Italy, Greece, France, Turkey and Croatia to let holidaymakers go abroad this summer without having to quarantine on their return. Austria and Germany are also among the countries officials are considering, the Guardian understands. There are hopes an announcement will be made before the UK quarantine programme is officially reviewed next Monday, to give the travel industry more time to prepare.

Good morning to you all, I’ll be looking after the UK liveblog for the next few hours. If you have tips or suggestions - please do get in touch. I’m on alexandra.topping@theguardian.com and I’m @lexytopping on Twitter, my DMs are open.

Updated

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*