Julia Kollewe 

UK borrowing surges to February record; consumer morale at one-year high – as it happened

Government stake in NatWest reduced to just under 60%, as Bank of Japan edges away from monetary stimulus
  
  

Paddleboarders in the sea at Talland Bay near Looe in south Cornwall in August 2020.
Paddleboarders in the sea at Talland Bay near Looe in south Cornwall in August 2020. Photograph: Richard Saker/The Observer

Closing summary

Most stock markets are in the red today, with the UK’s FTSE 100 index down 0.9% at 6,777, a loss of 62 points. Germany’s Dow and France’s CAC have both declined by 1% while Italy’s FTSE MiB dow down 0.8%. On Wall Street, the Dow Jones has lost nearly 250 points, or 0.76%, to 32,613 and the S&P 500 dropped 3% while the Nasdaq is flat.

The dollar is rising against major currencies, up 0.3%, hitting a more than one-week high, after the US Fed announced today that it would let a temporary bank leverage rule exemption expire on 31 March (which had been put in place to encourage bank lending). The dollar has risen in recent weeks, along with US Treasury bond yields.

Here are today’s main stories:

UK government spending to combat the coronavirus pandemic pushed the public finances further into the red in February, to the biggest February deficit on record.

The UK’s supreme court has dismissed a claim by care workers who carry out “sleep-in” shifts that they should be paid the national minimum wage for hours when they are not awake and actively helping the client.

The former prime minister David Cameron reportedly lobbied senior government officials to give Greensill Capital special access to the largest available tranche of emergency Covid loans just months before the lender collapsed.

The UK taxpayers’ stake in NatWest has been reduced after the government sold £1.1bn of shares in the bank, which was bailed out during the financial crisis more than a decade ago.

Cornwall has replaced London as the most searched for place to live on the property website Rightmove, as the coronavirus pandemic sparks a new era of flexible working and lifestyle changes that have fuelled a surge of interest in relocating to rural locations.

Britain’s competition watchdog has ordered the housebuilders Taylor Wimpey and Countryside Properties to remove terms in contracts that have made it impossible for some homeowners to get a mortgage or sell their properties. The Competition and Markets Authority told the two firms to remove certain contract terms that mean leaseholders have to pay ground rents that double every 10 to 15 years.

Tim Martin, the outspoken boss of the pub chain Wetherspoon, has hit out at the government’s Covid restrictions as the the company racked up a £68m loss.

Thank you for reading, and have a great weekend. We’ll be back on Monday. Good-bye! – JK

Despite the suspension of the AstraZeneca/Oxford University vaccine by 13 EU countries this week over fears of a link to blood clots, Nicola Nobile, economist at Oxford Economics, reckons that the EU should still be able to meet its vaccination target of giving 70% of adults the jab before the end of the summer.

The main story this week in Europe concerned the vaccination programme. The AstraZeneca saga ended yesterday with the EU regulator agency stressing that the vaccine is safe. Most EU countries have since announced the resumption of vaccinations.

At this stage, it is hard to assess if this will have any confidence impact on the uptake of the vaccines, but it is clear that the “operational” impact of the suspension will not have meaningful consequences. In fact, despite these bad few days, the EU target of vaccinating 70% of adults before the end of the summer is still likely to be met, in line with our view set out at the start of February.

Iggo adds:

The US is leading the reflation [stimulating the economy by increasing the money supply or by reducing taxes]. It is doing a great job vaccinating people (100 million people so far) and much of the economy is re-opening. Households are now starting to receive $1,400 checks per person. That will boost spending.

Excess savings should also come down, boosting spending. The Fed is not exactly tipping another bottle of Vodka into the punch bowl, but it is letting the Treasury do that and is in no rush to take the booze away. After the last year of no partying….the message is turn up the music. (Side note: my son, having had two jabs, is off to Miami for spring break. If the idea of lots of 20-22 year-olds dancing around the swimming pool is not a sign of a return to normal I don’t know what is!).

On Wall Street, the Dow Jones has slid 1% and the tech-heavy Nasdaq has fallen 0.5%, while the dollar is rising and Treasury yields are also heading higher again.

Chris Iggo, chief investment officer of core investments at AXA Investment Managers, has sent us his thoughts on bond and equity markets. He reckons bond yields will rise quite a bit higher. The yield, or effective interest rate, on the 10-year US Treasury is at 1.74%.

Equities are outperforming bonds, yields are rising, and the US curve is super-steepening. The Fed is doing a reasonable job of anchoring short-term interest rate expectations, but the longer end of the curve reflects the reflationary boom. It is making US fixed income attractive again. Yet the move up in yields is probably not over and few will be surprised now if and when the market crosses the 2% yield level. That is no disaster. The US economy is in fully party mode.

It is worth thinking of how high yields could go. One metric would be to think about where long-term inflation expectations will settle and where real yields will settle. Our view is that inflation break-evens at around 2.4% are consistent with the Fed’s average inflation target. Real yields have averaged 0% since the global financial crisis. Putting the two together would target 2.4% 10-year Treasury yields.

A second approach would be to look at the cyclical position... by looking at current yields relative to their 3-year average and plotted that against the ISM index of manufacturing activity. There is a good fit in terms of how they behave through the cycle and it suggests that the level of yields is still too low relative to where the economy is. This is not an econometric model, but it could be used as an argument to point to yields being closer to 3%. At any rate, it should not be surprising if yields move higher still – after all that is what forward markets are pricing.

Stock markets are sliding deeper into the red, with the UK’s FTSE 100 now down 1.2% at 6,699, a loss of nearly 80 points. Germany’s Dax and France’s CAC are both down 0.8% and Italy’s FTSE MiB has slid 0.7%.

Oil prices have also turned negative again after yesterday’s big sell-off, with Brent crude trading 0.55% lower at $62.90 a barrel and US crude down 0.3% at $59.80 a barrel. Fresh coronavirus lockdowns in Europe (in France, Poland and Italy) have dampened expectations of economic recovery, and more demand for oil.

Updated

Finland remains the world’s happiest country for the fourth year running, with people’s trust in each other and their government proving a key factor.

It’s the fourth straight trophy for the Nordic country in the World Happiness Report 2021 published on Friday by the United Nations Sustainable Development Solutions Network.

Market summary

In the markets, shares are heading lower.

  • UK’s FTSE 100 down 64 points, or 0.95%, at 6,714
  • Germany’s Dax down 91 points, or 0.6%, at 14,684
  • France’s CAC down 39 points, or 0.65%, at 6,023
  • Italy’s FTSE MiB down 86 points, or 0.35%, at 24,272

Oil prices have reversed earlier losses and US light crude is now up 0.17% at $60.1 a barrel, while Brent crude, the global benchmark, is flat at $63.27 a barrel.

Bond markets have calmed down following yesterday’s sell-off, after the US Federal Reserve indicated its willingness to let inflation rise above target. This pushed 10-year Treasury bond yields (which move in inverse relationship to prices) to their highest levels since January 2020 and pulled up eurozone bond yields with them.

German 10-year yields, the benchmark for the eurozone, are down 3 basis points at -0.29%, and are set to end the week almost unchanged.

The massive, $1.9 trillion fiscal stimulus package in the US has sparked fears that it will stoke inflation, as well as boosting economic growth.

Care workers will be disappointed by the ruling, but for care home providers it comes as a huge relief.

Matt McDonald, employment partner at the law firm Shakespeare Martineau, said:

This ruling will be disappointing for any care worker who believes they should be paid minimum wage for the entirety of the time spent on ‘sleep-in’ shifts. The case has been in the pipeline for some time and if the Supreme Court had sided with Mrs Tomlinson-Blake, the shockwaves would have been felt throughout the care sector.

By contrast, care providers will be mightily relieved that their longstanding approach of paying a fixed rate for ‘sleep-in’ shifts has been confirmed by the Supreme Court as legally sound.

If the Supreme Court’s decision had gone the other way, the bills facing care providers for historic underpayments would have been substantial and, in some cases, devastating. Many simply couldn’t have afforded to pay and we would therefore seen a large number of providers teetering on the brink of financial ruin, putting further pressure on UK care standards.

Supreme Court: Sleep-in care workers not entitled to minimum wage

The UK’s supreme court today dismissed a claim by care workers who carry out “sleep-in” shifts that they should be paid the national minimum wage for hours when they are not awake and actively helping the client.

The decision ends a four-year legal battle involving two care workers and the learning disability charity Mencap that threatened to leave many care providers with a potential £400m back-pay bill and jeopardise the care of vulnerable people, writes our social policy editor Patrick Butler.

Cllr Ian Hudspeth, chairman of the Local Government Association’s Community Wellbeing Board, was relieved at the ruling:

This significant ruling is in line with councils’ and social care providers’ understanding of the law. Had the appeal been upheld, care providers and councils providing social care would have faced massive bills, which would have increased the huge financial pressures they are already facing.

As we said in our submission to the Court, the LGA strongly supports care workers being paid a fair wage for their valued work. Of course, today’s decision does not remove the need for a sustainable funding settlement for adult and children’s social care, which includes important decisions on the workforce such as pay, recruitment and career development.

The government should bring forward its proposals on adult social care funding as soon as possible.

Anna Fletcher, employment director at the law firm Gowling WLG, said:

While the issue is a contentious one from an employee perspective, the potential damage that might have been caused to end user services as a result of the potentially huge cost of backdated claims cannot be ignored. Hopefully, the industry can now move forward following the Supreme Court’s decision, without the continued threat of closures while this issue was unresolved.

Here is our story, from media editor Jim Waterson:

Reach, which also owns the Daily Express, Daily Star and hundreds of regional newspapers around the UK and Ireland, will inform three-quarters of its staff on Friday morning that they will no longer be expected to come to the office full time. Dozens of mid-sized towns will lose their remaining newspaper office, with staff having to commute to the nearest major city if they want to work at a company desk.

The company will instead maintain hub offices filled with meeting rooms in Belfast, Bristol, Birmingham, Dublin, Cardiff, Glasgow, Newcastle, Hull, Leeds, Liverpool, London, Manchester, Nottingham and Plymouth. This means journalists working on the group’s local titles in East Anglia will have to head to the London HQ as their nearest office.

Returning to the home working trend...

City A.M. reports that the newspaper publisher Reach, which owns the Mirror and Express as well as a number of regional titles, is planning to close its offices and make most of its employees permanent home workers.

The company will close its Lower Thames Street office in central London and reduce its office space in Canary Wharf from two floors to one.

Here is our full story on the Treasury reducing its stake in NatWest.

Taxpayers’ stake in NatWest has been reduced after the government sold £1.1bn of shares in the bank, which was bailed out during the financial crisis more than a decade ago, reports Mark Sweney.

The government’s stake in NatWest, formerly known as Royal Bank of Scotland, fell to 59.8% from 61.7% after it sold 591m shares back to the bank at 190.5p a share in an off-market deal authorised by the chancellor, Rishi Sunak, and managed by UK Government Investments (UKGI).

It marks the third selldown of taxpayer-owned shares since the government injected £45.8bn for an 82% stake in the banking group to bail it out at the height of the financial crisis in 2008.

IWG, the world’s biggest flexible workspace provider, has published new data that show there has been a shift to the suburbs and away from city centre offices, as businesses turn to home or “hybrid” working (split between home and the office) because of the pandemic.

At the moment, most office workers have been ordered to work from home, and it seems likely that they will continue to work two to three days a week from home, and the rest in the office. IWG says:

  • Demand for office space in suburban areas is up 32% in the first three months of 2021
  • Demand for office space in rural locations is up 20%
  • Demand for city centre areas is down 11%

This change has been especially prevalent in London, with a host of towns around the M25 seeing significant increases in demand for office space. Uxbridge (175% increase), High Wycombe (52%) and Hayes (24%) are just some of the locations benefiting from the shift away from major urban areas. Over the same period the City of London has seen a 26% decline versus pre-Covid levels.

Mark Dixon, founder and chief executive of IWG said:

Across our customer base we are seeing firms taking steps towards a hybrid working model. While the pandemic has certainly had a dramatic effect, it’s merely accelerated a trend that’s been underway for several years.”

The past 12 months has shown that while businesses can largely operate effectively remotely, they are planning for a hybrid future. Companies are moving rapidly towards a hub and spoke model maintaining a central headquarters, but also empowering staff to access smaller co-working spaces, closer to their home and often accessible by foot or by bike.

In the UK alone during the last two years IWG has opened almost all its new centres in non-city centre environments, and today globally we are seeing enquiries and demand for suburban locations across our brands including Regus and Spaces exponentially increase.

Despite the improvement in consumer morale reported a bit earlier, people’s mental health has suffered hugely during the pandemic and lockdowns. The Institute for Fiscal Studies has published this analysis today.

Cornwall replaces London as most searched for place to live

One year on from the coronavirus outbreak, Cornwall has replaced London as the most searched for place to live. The Rightmove property website recorded more than 5m searches in February, as people seek out countryside and coastal towns and villages to move to. Dorset has jumped from position 20 to tenth place.

Here are some of the other findings:

  • Sales of five-bed detached homes have been the biggest growth in the market, up 38% compared to 8% for all homes.
  • Would-be buyers looking for a garden have hit a record and the term garage has been the most popular keyword used by home-hunters
  • More city dwellers are enquiring about properties outside the city; the biggest shift is in London where over half (52%) of Londoners are enquiring outside the capital, up from 39% this time last year
  • For renters. the two bed flat has been replaced by the two bed semi-detached house as people look for more space.

Updated

GfK: UK consumer morale hits one-year high

In another bit of good news, consumer morale in Britain has hit a one-year high.

The monthly consumer confidence index from market research firm GfK rose to -16 from -23 in February. While still some way below its long-run average of -9, the survey showed an improvement in all five measures. Economists polled by Reuters had expected a smaller increase to -20.

Household expectations for the economic outlook and personal finances over the next 12 months improved notably this month, with the latter hitting a three-year high.

GfK client strategy director Joe Staton said:

Spring is in the air on the back of well-received budget announcements, the successful vaccine roll-out and roadmaps in place for ending lockdown.

The scores looking ahead one year are recovering especially well... If this improved mood translates into spending, it might help reverse some of the economic damage the UK has suffered.

And the eight-point fillip in our major purchase measure to the new level of -11 suggests this may well happen. It’s highly likely this upward trajectory on all measures will build over the next six months and beyond.

The survey came a day after the Bank of England said Britain’s economic recovery was picking up pace, with the vaccination campaign powering ahead. More than 25m people have had at least one dose of a Covid-19 vaccine.

Updated

Gareth Shaw, Head of Money at the consumer group Which?, said:

Our research found that some leaseholders face onerous clauses from developers, bad advice from lawyers and spiralling ground rents that effectively rendered their homes unsellable.

It’s good to see the regulator taking action against some of the biggest housebuilders to protect homeowners and sending a clear message that bad practices like these must be a thing of the past.

CMA orders Taylor Wimpey, Countryside to remove unfair ground rent terms

There’s some good news for leaseholders. Britain’s competition watchdog has ordered housebuilders Taylor Wimpey and Countryside Properties to remove terms in contracts that have made it impossible for some homeowners to get a mortgage or sell their properties.

The Competition and Markets Authority has told the two companies to remove certain contract terms that mean leaseholders have to pay ground rents that double every 10 to 15 years, Mark Sweney writes.

Andrea Coscelli, chief executive of the CMA, said:

These ground rent terms can make it impossible for people to sell or get a mortgage on their homes, meaning they find themselves trapped. This is unacceptable. Countryside and Taylor Wimpey must entirely remove all these terms from existing contracts to make sure they are on the right side of the law. If these developer do not address our concerns, we will take further action, including through the courts, if necessary.

The CMA has written to the businesses stating that their practices break consumer protection law, giving them the opportunity to sign formal commitments, known as undertakings, to remove the terms from contracts.

Updated

Wetherspoon swings to loss

Let’s look at this morning’s other news. JD Wetherspoon has swung to a loss and revenues plunged by more than half in the six months to January as the latest lockdown took its toll, reports my colleague Mark Sweney.

Wetherspoon said that revenues fell by 54% from £933m to £431m in the six months to 24 January, as the business made an overall pre-tax loss of £68m. In the same period last year the company, which runs 872 pubs across the UK, made a £35.7m profit.

Outspoken founder and chairman Tim Martin, a regular critic of the government’s decision-making during the pandemic, criticised the regulations that have been put in place.

It is disappointing that so many regulations, implemented at tremendous cost to the nation, appear to have had no real basis in common sense or science.

For example, curfews, ‘substantial meals’ with drinks and masks for bathroom visits. The future of the industry, and of the UK economy, depends on a consistent set of sensible policies, and the ending of lockdown and tier systems, which have created economic and social mayhem and colossal debts, with no apparent health benefits.

The company is preparing to open beer gardens, roof-top gardens and patios at 394 of its pubs in England in line with Boris Johnson’s proposed roadmap for relaxing coronavirus social distancing restrictions through the summer.

Updated

Howard Archer, chief economic advisor to the EY Item Club forecasting group, explains that the public finances normally see a surplus in January, as it is a key month for tax receipts. The February public finances also tend to benefit from higher tax receipts than most months as some the tax due in January arrives late.

January’s shortfall was revised lower to £3.1bn from the previously reported deficit of £8.8bn. Even so, this was the first January deficit for 10 years and the largest since records began.

Archer has looked at the detail of the February data.

VAT receipts were down 12.0% year-on-year. VAT receipts are currently being limited by the temporary VAT cut (from 20% to 5%) for the hospitality and leisure sectors as well as the closure of non-essential retailers.

Additionally, Stamp Duty receipts, which were down 4.5% year-on-year in February, have been reduced by the temporary raising of the threshold since July. However, the ONS reported that self-assessed income tax receipts were up 26.2% year-on-year in February 2021 while PAYE income tax was up 4.0% year-on-year. Corporation tax receipts rose 0.2% year-on-year.

Meanwhile, central government expenditure increased 25.1% year-on-year in December following government measures to support the economy, businesses and jobs in the face of the pandemic.

Should the pattern of the first 11 months of fiscal year 2020/21 continue, the budget deficit would come in around £318bn. It will likely ultimately come in higher than this as not only will the March shortfall be lifted by extra supportive measures and relatively limited economic activity due to the current restrictions on activity, but the ONS is yet to incorporate an estimate of the likely write-off of losses from the various government-backed COVID-19 loan schemes.

Nevertheless, the chancellor looks on course to at least meet the budget deficit of £354.6bn for 2020/21 set out by the OBR in the budget at the start of this month.

Updated

Thomas Pugh, UK economist at Capital Economics, is also fairly optimistic.

February’s public finances figures showed that borrowing is course to match the OBR’s 2020/21 forecast of £355bn. But if we are right in thinking the economic recovery will be faster and fuller than the OBR expects, borrowing will undershoot the OBR’s forecasts further ahead.

This would allow the chancellor to cancel some of the proposed tax hikes before the 2024 general election.

While the UK government borrowing figure for February was the highest on record (at £19.1bn), it was below City forecasts of £21bn.

Samuel Tombs, chief UK economist at Pantheon Macroeconomics, notes that tax receipts have continued to hold up relatively well, given the lockdown, registering only a 1.4% year-over-year decline. He also says that borrowing for the whole financial year could come in below the Office for Budget Responsibility’s forecast.

Admittedly, the picture is flattered a bit by the relatively high level of self-assessment income tax and capital gains tax receipts in February, which refer to income and gains clocked up in the 2019/20 financial year. Even excluding these tax streams, however, receipts were down a mere 2.6%, similar to January.

The ONS’ figures still do not include an estimate of future write-offs on virus-related loans, which will accrue to when the funds were first dispensed in this fiscal year. The OBR judges that the eventual cost to the exchequer will be £27.2bn.

Even after allowing for this discrepancy, however, the OBR’s full-year borrowing forecast of £354.6bn in the Budget—or £327.4bn excluding write-offs—looks a bit too high. Borrowing has totalled £285.9bn between April and February and will total £309.6bn in 2020/21 as a whole, if the year-over-year rise in borrowing in March matches the average uplift in the previous three months.

Other reasons to be cheerful: while remaining high, the debt-GDP ratio fell.

Updated

The ONS has spelled out the impact of the coronavirus crisis on the UK’s economy and public finances.

Central government tax and national insurance receipts in the 11 months to February fell by £36.8bn (or 5.7%) compared with the same period a year earlier, while government support for individuals and businesses during the pandemic contributed to an increase of £187.6bn (or 27.9%) in central government day-to-day spending.

The latest official forecasts, published by the Office for Budget Responsibility on 3 March, indicate that the £278.8bn borrowed by the public sector in the 11 months to February could reach £354.6bn by the end of March 2021.

European stock markets have opened lower.

  • UK’s FTSE 100 down 80 points, or 1.2%, at 6,698
  • Germany’s Dax down 0.6%
  • France’s CAC down 0.4%
  • Spain’s Ibex down 0.9%
  • Italy’s FTSE MiB down 0.8%

The chancellor, Rishi Sunak, responded to the public finance figures.

Coronavirus has caused one of the largest economic shocks this country has ever faced, which is why we responded with our £352bn package of support to protect lives and livelihoods.

This was the fiscally responsible thing to do and the best way to support the public finances in the medium-term.

But I have always said that we should look to return the public finances to a more sustainable path once the economy has recovered and at the budget I set out how we will begin to do just that, providing families and businesses with certainty.

Introduction: UK borrowing surges, BOJ edges away from stimulus

Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.

In the UK, the government borrowed £19.1bn last month, the highest February borrowing since monthly records began in 1993.

The worsening in the public finances was mainly caused by a spending splurge, according to figures from the Office for National Statistics. Central government bodies spent £72.6bn on day-to-day activities, £14.2bn more than in February 2020, including £3.9bn on coronavirus job support schemes.

At the same time, tax receipts were £1.5bn lower than a year ago, at £46.2bn, especially VAT, business rates and fuel duty. However, receipts from self-assessed income tax amounted to £4.2bn, £900m more than a year earlier.

Public sector net debt has risen to £2.1 trillion, or 97.5% of GDP, in the first 11 months of the tax year – levels not seen since the early 1960s.

David Madden, market analyst at CMC Markets UK, says:

Governments around the world are borrowing eye watering amounts to keep their respective economies afloat as the lockdowns have stifled growth and the UK is no different.

Earlier this month, Rishi Sunak, Britain’s Chancellor of the Exchequer, revealed various schemes to provide much needed assistance to the economy, so the national debt is on track to keep on increasing in the months ahead. Debt levels make interesting headlines but in reality, the sums involved are unlikely to impact the pound. Bond yields have been in focus lately and should the yield on the 10-year gilt top 1%,that could attract negative attention for sterling.

NatWest (formerly known as Royal Bank of Scotland) has agreed to buy back £1.1bn of shares from the UK government. This reduces the taxpayer’s stake in the bank, which was bailed out by the government during the financial crisis – to 59.8% from 61.7%. The off-market deal for 590.7m shares will settle on 23 March.

In Asia, the Bank of Japan has unveiled some tweaks to its policy that will move it away from its abundant monetary stimulus and towards a more “sustainable” policy. Bloomberg explains:

The bank set out a wider-than-previously-thought movement range for bond yields and scrapped a buying target for stock funds at the end of a three-month policy review. While the currency and bond markets largely took the moves in stride, the BOJ’s decision to focus only on exchange-traded funds on the TOPIX index briefly drove down shares on the Nikkei 225.

Many of the tweaks give the BOJ greater scope to buy fewer assets and could be viewed as a stepping back from stimulus, but the central bank tried to characterise the changes as shoring up the effectiveness and sustainability of its measures over the longer run.

The BOJ also tried to show its readiness to add stimulus if needed by offering lending incentives that would increase in size if it lowered interest rates.

Other central banks are still in stimulus mode. The European Central Bank plans to buy more bonds and the US Federal Reserve forecast that interest rates would stay near zero at least through 2023, despite an improving economic outlook.

Japan’s Nikkei lost 1.4% while other Asian stock markets also fell. Hong Hong’s Hang Seng tumbled 1.8% and the Australian market slid 0.63%. European stock markets are also expected to open lower.

Covid worries are weighing on markets: France has announced new regional lockdowns for some 21 million people in 16 areas, including Paris, from midnight on Friday.

Updated

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*