The blog is closing now, but read our full story of the day’s developments here:
A summary of today's developments
- Four of Boris Johnson’s aides have resigned today. Johnson’s longstanding policy chief Munira Mirza was the first to go, using a stinging resignation letter to accuse the prime minister of “scurrilous” behaviour when he falsely linked Keir Starmer to the failure to bring paedophile Jimmy Savile to justice. Jack Doyle then resigned as director of communications at Downing Street. Dan Rosenfield, Boris Johnson’s chief of staff and Martin Reynolds, the prime minister’s principal private secretary, resigned later in the evening. The latter has been thrust into the spotlight after it emerged he sent an email inviting more than 100 Downing Street staff to a drinks party in May 2020.
- The foreign secretary, Liz Truss, has accused Russia of “unprovoked aggression and underhand activity” to destabilise Ukraine following reports of a plan by Moscow to fabricate a pretext for an invasion using a faked video.
- The Northern Ireland first minister, Paul Givan, announced his resignation from Stormont’s power-sharing Executive. The move by the Lagan Valley MLA is part of the DUP’s escalating protest strategy against Brexit’s Northern Ireland protocol.
- Rishi Sunak responded to the prime minister’s attempt to smear Starmer by saying: “With regard to the comments, being honest, I wouldn’t have said it and I’m glad that the prime minister clarified what he meant.”
- The chancellor also had his say on partygate and what would happen on “his watch”. In an opinion piece for the Sun, he wrote: “We have always been the party of sound money — we will always continue to be on my watch — and that is the only kind of party I am interested in.”
Updated
Friday’s Guardian front page:
Tomorrow’s Times front page:
A selection of some of Friday’s front pages beginning with the Mail:
Rishi Sunak has also rejected calls for a windfall tax on energy companies making profits while customers struggle to pay rising bills.
The chancellor told the Martin Lewis Money Show such a levy would “deter investment”.
Lewis asked him: “People have said … why the hell are they having to pay money back when energy companies are publishing – the big ones – record profits?”
Sunak said a windfall tax “does sound superficially appealing”, but added: “I don’t think a windfall tax is the right thing to do, most obviously because it will deter investment.”
He said more investment was needed in the North Sea, which he claimed would help to boost the economy and employment levels.
Updated
The chancellor, Rishi Sunak, has had his say on partygate and what would happen on “his watch”.
In an opinion piece for the Sun, he wrote: “We have always been the party of sound money — we will always continue to be on my watch — and that is the only kind of party I am interested in.”
Updated
Conservative MP Chris Loder gives his forthright reaction to the four resignations this evening.
Here is more from ITV’s Robert Peston on the motives behind the shakeup.
Outgoing communications director Jack Doyle gave a resignation speech to staff in No 10, according to the Daily Mail.
The newspaper reported Doyle said “recent weeks have taken a terrible toll on my family life”, but that he always intended to resign after two years in the role.
The former Daily Mail journalist has been accused of attending at least two of the 12 social gatherings during lockdown that are under investigation by the police.
Updated
And following that tweet from Schofield....
The Huff Post’s Kevin Schofield on the stance from pro-Johnson MPs following the four resignations.
The BBC’s Laura Kuenssberg on the future of the PM’s inner circle.
ITV’s Anushka Anthana with a question on the prime minister’s strategy.
Updated
The FT’s Sebastian Payne discloses a new nickname for one of Johnson’s advisers.
ITV’s Robert Peston gives his reaction to the spate of resignations this evening which he believes have been prompted by Boris Johnson following the fallout from the partygate scandal.
Updated
No 10 confirms Reynolds and Rosenfield resignations
Here is the confirmation from Downing Street that both Martin Reynolds and Dan Rosenfield have resigned.
A No 10 spokesperson said:
Dan Rosenfield offered his resignation to the prime minister earlier today, which has been accepted.
Martin Reynolds also informed the prime minister of his intention to stand down from his role as principal private secretary and the prime minister has agreed to this.
He has thanked them both for their significant contribution to government and No 10, including work on the pandemic response and economic recovery.
They will continue in their roles while successors are appointed, and recruitment for both posts is underway.
It has also been confirmed that Reynolds will be returning to the Foreign Office.
Updated
Several journalists are now citing sources telling them that Dan Rosenfield and Martin Reynolds are also set to resign from their posts at Downing Street tonight.
Rosenfield is Boris Johnson’s chief of staff, while Martin Reynolds is the prime minister’s principal private secretary. The latter has been thrust into the spotlight recently after it emerged he sent an email inviting more than 100 Downing Street staff to a drinks party in May 2020.
The Telegraph’s Whitehall editor Harry Yorke has tweeted.
And some more detail from Steven Swinford, of The Times.
Updated
Civil service bosses may never know which of their staff are fined by police for attending Covid rule-breaking parties, a leaked memo issued by the Cabinet Office has revealed.
The five-page advice document for those who could be spoken to by Scotland Yard over 12 alleged gatherings also reassured staff it was “unlikely” their security clearance would be revoked if they were issued with a £100 fixed penalty notice.
Whitehall workers were told to “cooperate fully” with the Metropolitan police, and that while there was no fixed end point to officers’ inquiries they would be kept “updated as timelines become clearer”.
Advice was given for people to join a union to get legal support – if they wanted it – while those who wanted “time off” to handle the stress of the investigation were told they would be supported “through this difficult period” and given “flexibility”.
More than 70 witnesses were interviewed by senior civil servant Sue Gray’s team, as part of her investigation into a string of alleged parties in No 10 and across Whitehall when Covid restrictions were in place.
Liz Truss accuses Russia of 'unprovoked aggression'
The foreign secretary, Liz Truss, has accused Russia of “unprovoked aggression and underhand activity” to destabilise Ukraine following reports of a plan by Moscow to fabricate a pretext for an invasion using a faked video.
The New York Times reported that US had acquired intelligence about the Russian plan which involved staging and filming a fabricated attack by the Ukrainian military either on Russian territory or against Russian-speaking people in eastern Ukraine.
In a statement posted on Twitter, Truss said: “This is clear and shocking evidence of Russia’s unprovoked aggression and underhand activity to destabilise Ukraine.
“This bellicose intent towards a sovereign democratic country is completely unacceptable and we condemn it in the strongest possible terms.”
Updated
Families are facing the biggest fall in disposable income for three decades, according to the Bank of England, with rising energy prices and other consumer inflation hitting incomes.
The government has responded to the cost of living crisis with the announcement of a package of measures.
Here is a handy look at the impact on a range of different people.
“To be honest, I wouldn’t have said it.”
Rishi Sunak’s blunt remark about Boris Johnson’s comments on Keir Starmer and Jimmy Savile was the clearest indication yet that he is distancing himself from his beleaguered boss.
Speaking in the flag-bedecked Downing Street conference room without Johnson alongside him, Sunak was attempting to set out in soothing tones a package of measures aimed at easing the pain of the cost of living crisis.
But, as ever in recent weeks, another crisis – that facing the prime minister’s leadership – impinged on proceedings.
Less than an hour earlier, Johnson’s close aide Munira Mirza had resigned, citing the prime minister’s failure to apologise for trying to smear Starmer by falsely connecting him with the failure to prosecute Savile.
Pressed on whether Johnson should give a full apology for the remarks, as Mirza had asked, Sunak repeatedly replied it was a matter for Johnson himself.
Sunak didn’t say much. He didn’t have to. The comments are bound to be read by some of his colleagues as the strongest signal yet he may believe it is now time to act.
And to read exactly what the chancellor said, as well as his comments with regard to the energy price rise crisis, here is the full story below.
The Conservative mayor of the West Midlands, Andy Street, has said Boris Johnson’s behaviour is “bad by any measure”.
He also said that he is “waiting” to see if he can continue supporting the prime minister in his role.
In comments reported by the Birmingham Mail, he commented:
What he’s done, very clearly, is wrong. It’s bad by any measure. And I find it very hard to understand how on earth it could have happened. So I can’t be happy with it in any way.
However, he has apologised. He appears to me to be a man who is genuine in that apology. You can see that from his demeanour.
But what we’ve now got to see is that this apology follows through in terms of actions, how he leads and what is done within Downing Street to make it very, very different.
The honest answer is that we are waiting to see if he follows through on what he’s now said.
Updated
My colleague Peter Walker has more detail on the news that Boris Johnson, Priti Patel and the Home Office have been rebuked for quoting misleading crime statistics (see 18.02).
He reports:
The head of the official statistics watchdog has reprimanded Boris Johnson and the Home Office for incorrectly saying crime has fallen by 14%, when this excludes the fastest-rising category of crime.
Sir David Norgrove, the head of the UK Statistics Authority, said he would be writing to the offices of Johnson and Priti Patel, the home secretary, to highlight what he called a “misleading” use of statistics.
Replying to a letter about the claims from Alistair Carmichael, the Liberal Democrat home affairs spokesperson, Norgrove said Johnson and Patel had been incorrect to claim that crime was falling.
A Home Office press release from last week twice “presented the statistics to give a positive picture of trends in crime in England and Wales” between June 2019 and September 2021, but did so by not including fraud and computer misuse, he wrote.
See the full story by clicking the link below.
The government has admitted it is spending £4.7m a day on accommodating refugees from Afghanistan and other asylum seekers in hotels, a figure four times the amount previously stated.
Refugee organisations criticised the Home Office for the slow progress it has made towards finding permanent homes for refugees brought to the UK from Afghanistan last year. Campaigners have consistently warned that, aside from the cost, hotels are inappropriate places to house families long-term.
The Home Office was forced to clarify the cost of the policy, after deputy permanent secretary Tricia Hayes told the home affairs select committee on Wednesday that a total of £1.2m was being spent every day on hotel accommodation. The department said on Thursday that that figure actually only covered the 12,000 people being resettled after being airlifted out of Kabul. Another £3.5m a day is spent on housing another 25,000 asylum seekers.
The home secretary, Priti Patel, admitted this week that the government was “absolutely struggling” to find accommodation for 12,000 people from Afghanistan who remain in hotels almost six months after being evacuated last August.
NI First Minister quits in Brexit protocol protest
If you missed it earlier today, the Northern Ireland first minister, Paul Givan, announced his resignation from Stormont’s power-sharing Executive.
The move by the Lagan Valley MLA is part of the DUP’s escalating protest strategy against Brexit’s Northern Ireland protocol, the PA Media news agency reported.
Givan said the protocol, which has created trade barriers between Northern Ireland and the rest of the UK, had undermined a cornerstone of power-sharing in the region - governance with the consent of both nationalists and unionists. He said:
Today marks the end of what has been the privilege of my lifetime - to serve as the first minister of Northern Ireland.
When I first entered the Assembly 12 years ago, I never expected to have the opportunity to lead the government and serve the people of Northern Ireland as first minister.
His announcement comes 24 hours after DUP agriculture minister Edwin Poots acted unilaterally to order a halt to agri-food checks required under the post-Brexit trading arrangements.
The secretary of state for Northern Ireland, Brandon Lewis, commented:
The decision by the DUP to withdraw the first minister from the Northern Ireland executive is extremely disappointing. I urge them to reinstate the first minister immediately to ensure the necessary delivery of public services for the citizens of Northern Ireland.
The UK government’s priority is to see a strong functioning Northern Ireland executive delivering a better, more prosperous, shared future for all the people of Northern Ireland.
We want to continue to build on the Belfast (Good Friday) agreement’s promise of a stable, cooperative and respectful power-sharing executive.
Updated
Downing Street's communications chief resigns - report
Jack Doyle has resigned as director of communications at Downing Street, according to the Daily Mail’s Jason Groves.
He reports that Doyle had always planned to step down after two years and is not linked to Munira Mirza’s resignation earlier today.
However, the timing of this latest resignation could not come at a worse time amid a police investigation into parties during lockdown at No 10 and mounting pressure on an increasingly beleaguered prime minister.
Doyle reportedly told staff at No 10: “It was always my intention to do two years. Recent weeks have taken a terrible toll on my family life.
“Thank you all for your hard work and dedication. I wish you all the best for the future.”
Groves has reported the news on Twitter tonight. Here are more details.
Updated
Johnson, Patel and Home Office 'rebuked' over misleading crime stats - report
Some breaking news from the journalist Danny Shaw on Twitter. He is reporting that Boris Johnson, Priti Patel and the Home Office have been “rebuked” by the UK Statistics Authority chair, David Norgrove, for misleading use of crime figures after claiming offences had fallen when they actually increased.
Here are the tweets, in which he says Norgrove said he has written to Johnson and Patel’s respective offices after a complaint to the authority was made by the Liberal Democrats.
Updated
A final question from PA Media for Rishi Sunak, as he is asked why households aren’t be given the opportunity to delay payments on national insurance.
The chancellor replies: “I think they are two very different things. We are putting in place a new dedicated health and social care levy so that people can feel reassured that every pound of that is going to the thing that they care most about, which is the NHS.
“And it means we can make a start on tackling the backlogs as quickly as possible.
“But where we can make a difference on these energy prices, we are and part of that is to smooth the impact of [rising bills].”
That’s it from the chancellor’s press conference as he leaves the podium.
Updated
The chancellor is now being asked if he would welcome a full apology from Boris Johnson over his smears against the Labour leader Keir Starmer.
Sunak says he has nothing further to add on the matter.
Lucy Fisher, of the Daily Telegraph, asks if there will come a point where Sunak will have to step in and say “people are paying too much tax”.
Sunak says that the announcements today will make a difference to people’s lives, the national living wage is set to go up in April to £9.50 an hour, as well as “tax cuts” for people on universal credit.
“Of course there are challenges but we are doing things to help people … we are making sure we are addressing the other thing that they care about which is having an NHS which is well funded and can make sure they don’t wait years and years for the treatment they desperately want for them and their families,” he replies.
He says his mission is to cut taxes over the remainder of this parliament but falls back on saying that we have gone through a “once in 300-year economic shock”.
Updated
The Daily Mail’s Jason Groves asks the chancellor why Sunak is still supporting the PM in the wake of the Sue Gray report update on ‘partygate’.
Sunak says: “I think he was right to say what he said in parliament recently and before. He has apologised for that and said he is going to fix it.
“He has acknowledged all of the recommendations from Sue Gray’s report and you can expect to hear more from him, as he said, about the changes he plans to make.
“That’s why he has my support and I’m glad that he’s doing what he’s doing.”
Sunak is now asked if he can promise to “do what it takes” to help people, as he said during the pandemic.
“I absolutely recognise this is a difficult time,” Sunak replies. “I know this is probably the number one issue on most families minds, they’re looking at the news, they’re seeing prices go up, they’re worried about the cost of living and that’s why we are taking action.”
He adds: “£350 is a significant amount of money that will make a big difference to the vast majorities of households and I hope actually people will be reassured by us stepping in to provide that support.”
Peston also quizzes Sunak over Mirza’s resignation letter comments and asserts that Johnson hasn’t in fact apologised. He asks if he should say sorry.
“It’s a question for the prime minister rather than me and there’s probably not much more I can add other than what I have already said, which I hope you can appreciate,” he says.
Updated
ITV’s Robert Peston has asked the chancellor why he isn’t helping just the poorest in society when it comes to tackling rising energy bills “if you believe in levelling up”.
Sunak replies: “Of course there are choices we have to make when we are designing a policy like this - my view was that the price rise is so significant that it’s not just those families on benefits that are going to feel the pinch, it actually [is] middle income families as well.”
He rather tellingly goes on to define middle income families as “families that are working hard, that are not on welfare”.
“That’s why we have decided to go to bands A to D … to help those families in the middle as well. That’s a deliberate choice.”
Updated
Sunak: 'I wouldn't have said' PM's false Jimmy Savile smear
Sunak is asked to respond to the breaking news we have brought you this afternoon about Boris Johnson’s policy chief Munira Mirza resigning over the prime minister’s attempt to smear Keir Starmer in the House of Commons.
Johnson made a false accusation that Starmer had failed to prosecute Jimmy Savile during his time running the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS).
“With regard to the comments, being honest, I wouldn’t have said it and I’m glad that the prime minister clarified what he meant,” Sunak says.
He also paid tribute to Mirza and said he will miss working with her.
Updated
The chancellor has been asked if high energy prices are here to stay and whether he would rule out having to help out with rebate schemes again further down the line.
He says: “The factors that are driving gas prices higher are global in their nature ... I don’t have a crystal ball as to what the future holds but I want to be honest with people.
“Higher energy prices are something we will have to adjust to, in common with other countries around the world and it would be wrong to pretend otherwise but what we can do is slow that adjustment to make it more manageable for people’s household budgets.”
He admits energy bills could rise again in October but says the rebate will kick in then and help with that.
He goes on to say the government will pay a “council tax rebate” of £150 to all households in bands A to D - around four in five households in England.
Sunak says: “[This] is the quickest way to get money to the families that need it.”
The rebate will be paid in April and won’t need to be repaid, he adds.
“Our plan is right, it is fair and I hope it will help ease the anxiety that millions of people feel about rising energy costs by sharing the burden between us all,” he concludes.
Updated
Rishi Sunak has started speaking and has set out the reason why the government is stepping in on the energy prices crisis.
He says: “There is in truth nothing the British government can do about a nuclear power plant going offline in Europe or a factory in China deciding to produce more goods.
“But what we can do is take the sting out of the price shock as we and the world adjust to high energy prices.”
He says that without government intervention, the average UK household would need to find an additional £693 next year.
“That is clearly a very significant sum,” he says.
He announces an “energy bills rebate” worth £350. The cash support will be received through an upfront £200 discount for all electricity customers - automatically repaid from bills over the next five years in instalments of £40-a-year starting next April.
Updated
Rishi Sunak gives news conference as cost of living set to soar
Good afternoon. I’m Tom Ambrose and I’ll be with you over the next couple of hours to bring you the latest from Westminster and UK politics.
There will, of course, be more reaction to the resignation of Boris Johnson’s policy chief Munira Mirza over the prime minister’s attempt to smear the Labour leader, Keir Starmer, in a House of Commons debate this week.
But first I’ll be bringing you details of anything that may emerge from Rishi Sunak’s 5pm press conference, where it is expected he will set out the government’s plans to tackle to cost of living crisis.
Stay tuned to follow along live here.
Updated
Here is some more reaction to the resignation of Munira Mirza.
From Paul Goodman, editor of ConservativeHome
From the BBC’s Laura Kuenssberg
From Sky’s Beth Rigby
From Nikki de Costa, former head of legislative affairs at No 10 for Theresa May and Boris Johnson
That’s all from me for today. My colleague Tom Ambrose is taking over now.
Ian Blackford, the SNP leader at Westminster, says it is always the women around Boris Johnson who seem to take responsibility for his misconduct.
The most prominent example is Allegra Stratton, who resigned as his spokesperson on Cop26 after a film of her joking about a lockdown-busting party at a private rehearsal briefing was leaked. Stratton said in the recording she did not even attend the party.
The only other person linked to government who has been punished so far in relation to No 10 parties is Kate Josephs, who was head of the government’s Covid taskforce when she attended a leaving drinks do in December 2020. She is now on paid leave from her new job as chief executive of Sheffield city council pending an investigation.
Updated
From the BBC’s Laura Kunessberg
Johnson appoints his PPS, Andrew Griffith MP, new No 10 head of policy
Boris Johnson has appointed Andrew Griffith MP, his parliamentary private secretary, as the new head of his policy unit, replacing Munira Mirza.
Griffith was a senior executive at Sky before becoming at the last general election. He has been Johnson’s business adviser, and he lent Johnson use of his £10m Westminster townhouse during the 2019 leadership campaign.
In a statement a No 10 spokesperson said:
We are very sorry Munira has left No 10 and are grateful for her service and contribution to government.
Andrew Griffith MP has been appointed Head of the No 10 Policy Unit and will work across government and with MPs as we continue to deliver and expand on our ambitious policy agenda.
Updated
Cummings urges ministers to show 'moral courage' and follow Mirza out of Johnson's government
These are from Dominic Cummings, Boris Johnson’s former chief adviser turned mortal foe, on the resignation of Munira Mirza.
Here is my colleague Heather Stewart’s story about Munira Mirza’s resignation.
PM's policy chief resigns over Starmer smear, suggesting Johnson's failure to apologise final straw
Munira Mirza has resigned as Boris Johnson’s head of policy over his Jimmy Savile smear about Keir Starmer, the Spectator’s James Forsyth reports.
In a blog on the Spectator’s website, Forsyth has published Mirza’s resignation letter in full. Here’s an extract.
I believe it was wrong for you to imply this week that Keir Starmer was personally responsible for allowing Jimmy Savile to escape justice. There was no fair or reasonable basis for that assertion. This was not the normal cut-and-thrust of politics; it was an inappropriate and partisan reference to a horrendous case of child sex abuse. You tried to clarify your position today but, despite my urging, you did not apologise for the misleading impression you gave.
Mirza has been working for Johnson since he was mayor of London and he once described her as one of the five women who inspired him most.
In her letter Mirza says Johnson is “a better man than many of your detractors will ever understand” and that she still hopes he will apologise. She says she was hoping he would apologise today (he didn’t - see 1.38pm) and she implies that it was his failure to say sorry in his interview earlier, despite her telling him he should, that tipped her over the edge.
Updated
UK government intervention in response to DUP bid to halt NI protocol checks 'unnecesary at this stage', Eustice says
The UK government is not doing anything to stop the DUP wing of the Northern Ireland executive trying to halt the checks on goods entering Northern Ireland. Brandon Lewis, the Northern Ireland secretary, has described this as a matter for the executive.
Downing Street took the same line at lobby this morning (see 12.28pm) and in a statement to MPs George Eustice, the environment secretary (the relevant checks relate to agrigoods), said UK government intervention was “entirely unnecessary at this stage”.
He also said the checks were continuing, despite the order given by the DUP agriculture minister in Belfast, Edwin Poots, because the relevant officials were taking their own legal advice.
Peter Kyle, the shadow Northern Ireland secretary, accused the government of standing by while their own deal fell apart. He said:
The protocol was signed into international law by the UK government, and now they are bystanders as their deal falls apart - pathetically claiming it’s all someone else’s responsibility.
Just think of the implications: Is the message that the Welsh senedd or Scottish parliament can break international law too and the government will have nothing to say about it?
Updated
In his statement to the Commons earlier Edward Argar, the health minister, said he was making no apology for the government having to write off almost £9bn spent on PPE during the pandemic. He told MPs:
We make no apology for procuring PPE at the pace and volume we did based on the information we had at the time. The action we took protected thousands of frontline healthcare workers in the NHS and social care.
However, now that the world market for PPE has stabilised, the value of some categories of goods is now inevitably much lower than the price they were originally purchased for.
Some Tories believe that the MPs hoping to trigger a no confidence vote in Boris Johnson are close to getting the 54 letters they need, the Telegraph’s Christopher Hope reports.
MPs who want a vote have to write to Sir Graham Brady, chairman of the 1922 Committee, calling for one, but they can do so privately. Only 11 of them have publicly said they have submitted a letter, according to this tally.
Johnson says current implementation of Northern Ireland protocol 'crazy'
And here are two more lines from the broadcast interview Boris Johnson gave on his visit this morning.
- Johnson said the current implementation of the Northern Ireland protocol was “crazy” and renewed his call for a “common sense” solution. Referring to the talks with the EU about how the protocol could be revised, he said:
What we’ve got to do is get to a sensible solution that recognises it’s crazy to have checks on goods that are basically circulating within the single market of the United Kingdom.
What you could have, of course, is a common-sensical ... practical steps to weed out, to check on things that might be at risk of circulation, as they say in Brussels, are at risk of circulation in Ireland, as well as Northern Ireland.
Now we can do that, but without having a full panoply of checks on the GB/NI coast and at the airport, and that’s the way forward. I think practical common sense is what’s needed.
Asked if that meant he was going back on the protocol that he agreed with the EU, which requires the checks he calls “crazy”, Johnson replied:
Actually, if you look at the protocol, which I’m sure you have studied in detail, there’s plenty about uninterrupted east-west trade.
- He said the UK had been “way out in front” in backing Ukraine in the face of the threat from Russia. He said:
The UK has played a very good role so far in bringing together the west and making sure that our partners understand the severity of the threat that Ukrainians face.
And if you look at what we’ve been doing for the last two or three months, the UK has been way out in front in making sure that people respond.
Updated
Government will need to intervene further over fuel bills because today's measures 'inadequate', says charity
National Energy Action, the fuel poverty charity, has said that it expects Rishi Sunak, the chancellor, to have to unveil further support measures later this year because today’s energy bills package is “woefully inadequate”. Adam Scorer, its chief executive, said:
These energy crisis measures are woefully inadequate and will leave those on the lowest incomes and in the least efficient homes in deep peril.
We needed deep, targeted support for the most vulnerable. We have shallow, broad measures for all. That simply does not work.
The depth of support is not proportionate to the increases. A household paying by prepayment will still have a £500 increase when you take into account rises from October 2021 and April 2022.
The rebates on bills and council tax are not sufficiently targeted, too small and too complex.
We expect the government will have no choice but to return to the issue of spiralling fuel poverty and another price rise later this year. By then they’ll be playing catch-up and great harm will already have been done.
Updated
One of the MPs most critical of the energy bills support package announced by Rishi Sunak in the Commons earlier was Labour’s Chris Bryant. He told Sunak the £350 offer was nothing like enough to help his constituents. He explained:
I know the chancellor is all pumped up but this is pretty puny stuff to be honest – £350 isn’t going to touch the sides of the problem for my constituents in Rhondda.
Gas and electricity up for the average family in my constituency by £686. Fuel up by £314. The average weekly shop up by £385 [a year]. Universal credit cut by £1,040. National Insurance up by £150 and frozen tax allowances by him will cost another £300. That’s £2,875 in a constituency where the average wage is £27,000.
That’s really going to cause hardships; £350 does not even touch it.
Updated
Johnson admits Starmer not personally involved in Savile prosecution decisions - three days after he implied otherwise
Boris Johnson has finally admitted that Keir Starmer was not personally responsible for any decisions taken not to prosecute the paedophile, sexual predator and TV personality Jimmy Savile.
On Monday, in response to a withering speech from Starmer telling him that he was not fit to be PM, Johnson retaliated by saying that Starmer “spent most of his time [as DPP] prosecuting journalists and failing to prosecute Jimmy Savile”.
This was widely seen as a smear, because Johnson was implying that Starmer was to blame for the failure to prosecute Savile when he wasn’t, and because it was redolent of an online conspiracy theory saying Starmer protected Savile from prosecution. Some of the Tory MPs calling for Johnson’s resignation this week have cited this comment as an example of why is is not a suitable person to be PM.
In an interview today Johnson said:
I want to be very clear about this because a lot of people have got very hot under the collar, and I understand why.
Let’s be absolutely clear, I’m talking not about the leader of the opposition’s personal record when he was DPP and I totally understand that he had nothing to do personally with those decisions.
I was making a point about his responsibility for the organisation as a whole. And I think people can see that. And I really do want to clarify that because it is important.
This is similar to the argument advanced by James Cleverly, the Foreign Office minister, who said that Johnson was trying to compare Starmer’s situation at the CPS over Savile with Johnson’s position in relation to partygate. (See 10.46am.)
But it has taken Johnson a while to issue this clarification. On Tuesday he told the Sun that what he said about Starmer was “fairly accurate”, in a comment interpreted by the paper as Johnson doubling down on his original claim.
And in the Commons yesterday, when Starmer accused him of parroting a conspiracy theory favoured by fascists, Johnson just said: “I do not want to make heavy weather of this, but I am informed that in 2013 [Starmer] apologised and took full responsibility for what had happened on his watch, and I think that was the right thing to do.”
Johnson did not say at that point he accepted that Starmer was not personally involved in the Savile decisions.
Updated
Families face biggest fall in disposable income for three decades, Bank of England warns
The Bank of England is today warning that families are facing the biggest fall in disposable incomes for three decades, my colleague Graeme Wearden reports. He writes:
The Bank of England fears that UK families are about to suffer the biggest fall in living standards since comparable records began three decades ago.
Its new forecasts now show that disposable incomes (post-tax labour income, after inflation) will shrink by 2% this year, and by another 0.5% in 2023.
That would be the biggest annual reduction in spending power since at least 1990.
There is much more on Graeme’s business live blog.
Ed Davey, the Lib Dem leader, and a former energy secretary, said (like Labour) that the government should be imposing a windfall tax on energy companies to fund support measures for customers. He said:
People around the country are facing an energy bill nightmare, including in the chancellor’s own backyard. But instead of taxing the record profits of oil and gas companies to fund a package of support, Rishi Sunak is simply spreading the pain for families over the coming years.
These plans are playing Russian roulette with taxpayers’ money, gambling that energy prices will fall instead of investing in keeping people’s bills down. It is an insult to take £150 of a family’s council tax while hiking their taxes by an average of £600, giving with one hand while taking away more with the other.
Updated
Energy bills rebate package not enough to protect the poor, say charities
Charities and campaigning organisations that represent low-income families seem unimpressed by the energy bills rebate package announced by Rishi Sunak. This is what some of them have been saying.
From Dame Clare Moriarty, the chief executive of Citizens Advice
This is a strange, complicated and untargeted package of measures. It provides some relief for all households come April, but for people on low incomes who need it most there are far easier ways for the government to deliver support. If the government is serious about helping families facing the desperate choice between heating and eating it should use the benefits system.
From Alison Garnham, the chief executive of the Child Poverty Action Group
A day after the levelling up fanfare, the government’s piecemeal measures won’t protect low-income families either now or in the future. Surging energy prices are only the start of the crisis and what’s needed is comprehensive help with across-the-board price rises. The most efficient way to help households is to increase benefits to match inflation and anything less than a rise by at least 6% will leave families in a desperate situation.
From Imran Hussain, director of policy and campaigns at Action for Children
Just over 100 days ago, the families we help lost £1,000 a year in universal credit, and will now have nearly £700 a year added to their bills. The help announced for these families today won’t be enough. We’re going to see more children going hungry as parents struggle to make ends meet.
From Katie Schmuecker, deputy director of policy and partnerships at the Joseph Rowntree Foundation said:
The chancellor has offered cold comfort to families in poverty, who are already rationing what they can spend on essentials such as heating and food. These families are now expected to find at least half of the eye-watering increases in energy bills, when many are already getting into debt to keep their houses warm and food on the table.
Three-quarters of those who can claim the enhanced support are not in poverty. Meanwhile, inflation is set to rise at more than double the rate of benefits. This support will not get people through the next few months and it will not protect those most at risk of hardship.
Updated
EU says it believes Northern Ireland protocol checks still being carried out, despite DUP bid to stop them
At the Downing Street lobby briefing this morning the PM’s spokesperson said the government was not aware that the Northern Ireland executive planned to stop the checks on goods arriving from Britain required under the Northern Ireland protocol. Asked if the PM wanted those checks to continue, he replied:
Yes, we would like this situation to be resolved, recognising it is a matter for the Northern Ireland executive.
At its own briefing, the European Commission said that EU observers in Northern Ireland were satisfied the required checks were still being carried out - despite Edwin Poots, the DUP agriculture minister in the Northern Ireland executive, saying they should stop.
Asked if the entire Brexit trade deal with the UK could be suspended if the Northern Ireland protocol’s requirements were not met, Eric Mamer, the commission’s spokesperson, said:
I’m not going to get into speculation about what we would undertake in case the checks were to stop ... for the moment our indications are that the checks are ongoing.
Although the UK government claims the operation of the checks is a matter for the Northern Ireland executive, Mamer said the protocol was a deal between the UK and the EU, not between Belfast and the EU.
Bank of England raises interest rates to 0.5%
The Bank of England has raised interest rates to 0.5% to tackle soaring inflation amid intense pressure on households in Britain’s cost of living crisis, my colleague Richard Partington reports.
Sunak says Labour's proposed windfall tax on energy companies would deter investment
In his response to Rachel Reeves, the chancellor, Rishi Sunak, mocked Labour by saying its call for VAT to be removed from fuel bills meant it was now converted to the benefits of Brexit (which would allow a UK government to do this).
He also dismissed Labour’s call for a windfall tax on energy companies. (See 9.34am.) Although superficially attractive, that would deter investment, he said. He said the government wanted to encourage investment.
He also suggests that voters would regard Labour’s stance not as “reasonable criticism” but as “political opportunism”.
Here is the Treasury news release with details of the package announced by Sunak.
Here is the summary of what the Treasury is calling its £9.1bn energy bills rebate package.
The energy bills rebate will provide around 28 million households with an upfront discount on their bills worth £200. Energy suppliers will apply the discount to domestic electricity customers from October, with the Government meeting the costs. The discount will then be automatically recovered from people’s bills in equal £40 instalments over the next five years. This will begin from 2023, when global wholesale gas prices are expected to come down.
Households in England, which are in council tax bands A-D, will also receive a £150 rebate. The rebate to bills will be made directly by local authorities from April. This will not need to be repaid. This one-off payment will benefit around 80 per cent of all homes in England and is £1 billion more generous and more targeted towards lower-income families than a VAT cut on energy bills.
On top of this discount, discretionary funding of £144m will also be provided to support vulnerable people and individuals on low incomes that do not pay Council Tax, or that pay Council Tax for properties in Bands E-H.
There are two Treasury factsheets here with more details about the announcement.
In response, Rachel Reeves, the shadow chancellor, said under Labour’s plan there would be £400 in targeted support for the poorest homes, as well as £200 in general support for most households. She said that meant the poorest families would be largely protected from the increase announced today.
UPDATE: Reeves said:
What do the government offer? A buy now, pay later scheme that loads up costs for tomorrow.
High prices as far as the eye can see - this year, next year and the year after that, give with one hand now and take it all back later. The party opposite used to talk about the nation’s credit card, well today we’ve seen the chancellor force British households to load up their credit cards.
By lending billions of pounds to energy companies, the chancellor is gambling that prices are going to fall - but they could go up further in October. What then? Billions more loaded onto people’s bills?
The best way of targeting support to those who need it most would be an increase to 400 and an extension to 9 million households of the warm homes discount, as Labour has proposed today. Their scheme today is a pale imitation of Labour’s, especially for the households and pensioners on the most modest incomes.
Updated
Sunak says some MPs have been arguing for VAT on fuel to be cut instead.
But this would help richer households most, he says. He says there is no guarantee that this cut would be passed on to families, and he says it would become a permanent cut, at a time when the government is trying to control the public finances.
UPDATE: Sunak said:
I know that some in this house have argued for a VAT cut on energy, however, that policy would disproportionately benefit wealthier households.
There would be no guarantee that suppliers would pass on the discount to all customers and we should be honest with ourselves - this would become a permanent government subsidy on everyone’s bills. A permanent subsidy worth £2.5bn every year at a time when we are trying to rebuild the public finances.
Updated
Sunak says the eligiblity criteria for the warm homes discount (a benefit for low-income households) will be expanded so that it covers one-third more people.
And he says the government is spending £3bn helping poorer families become more energy efficient. He says this could save people £290 a year.
Updated
Sunak gives details of £9bn support package
Sunak says the total package will be worth around £9bn.
There will be three measures.
First, all households will get a £200 discount on their bills. It will be paid from October. The money will be repaid in instalments over five years, he says.
Second, people will get a £150 council tax rebate in April. This will not have to be repaid. It will not just help people on benefits. People in council tax bands A to D will benefit – around 80% of all households in England.
And, third, a discretionary fund worth £150m will be available to help people in homes in higher bands who need help, he says.
Updated
Sunak says majority of households will gain £350 from today's measures – offsetting half impact of price cap rise
Sunak says the actions being announced today will provide £350 to the “vast majority of households”.
That will cover just over half of the extra £693 people are having to pay because of the rise in the price cap.
Updated
Sunak says it would not be sustainable to keep prices artificially low.
For me to stand here and pretend we don’t have to adjust to paying higher prices would be wrong and dishonest.
But what we can do is take the sting out of a significant price shock for millions of families by making sure that increase in prices is smaller initially and spread over a longer period.
Sunak says the government will help people deal with energy costs.
Energy bills will go up by £693 for an average household because of this morning’s Ofgem announcement on the price cap, he says.
He says 80% of the increase has been driven by the rise in wholesale energy prices.
Gas prices are going up for global reasons, he says. Cold weather has depleted stocks, and disruption to energy sources like nuclear and wind has led to a surge in demand.
Updated
Sunak's statement to MPs in response to hike in fuel bills
Rishi Sunak, the chancellor, starts his statement to the Commons saying the recovery from the pandemic has been stronger than expected.
The Labour MP Ben Bradshaw, a former culture secretary, has announced he is standing down at the next election.
Keir Starmer claimed this morning that the conduct of Boris Johnson was contributing to a decline in trust in politcians. In a speech on trust, he said:
Trust in government is falling, trust in politics and politicians is falling, trust in the media is falling.
Two-thirds of the public think that the way politicians act undermines democracy. Six out of 10 people think politicians are likely to lie to them - six out of 10 - sadly that doesn’t surprise me, given recent events, but it does disappoint me, it frustrates me.
But honestly, I’m not surprised. It’s inevitable when we have a government that is misleading the public and covering up their own wrongdoing to save the prime minister’s job.
Sunak 'set to announce £9bn package of loans and council tax rebates' to lessen impact of fuel bills hike
According to the Times’ Steven Swinford, Rishi Sunak, the chancellor, will announce a £9bn package of loans and council tax rebates in the Commons shortly to lessen the impact of the energy bills hike.
David Davis, the former Brexit secretary who two weeks ago told Boris Johnson at PMQs that he should resign, told Times Radio this morning that he would consult his local party before sending a letter to the chairman of the 1922 Committee calling for a no confidence vote. “I will recommend that we send in a letter, but I will take their views first,” he said.
He was also particularly critical of Johnson’s comment on Monday suggesting Keir Starmer was partly to blame for the failure to prosecute Jimmy Savile. That was “not the sort of thing I would hope a prime minister would do”, Davis said.
It’s like many of the tactics that No 10 have come up with, they are sort of childish and tasteless and he should just have retracted it rather than trying to justify it.
Of course, Starmer did give an apology for the failure of his department, as it were, it doesn’t mean he was personally involved in the decision.
Updated
UK households face record 54% energy bill rise as price cap is lifted
Households will face a record energy bill increase of 54% from April after the regulator lifted the cap on default tariffs to £1,971, my colleague Jillian Ambrose reports.
Johnson was not smearing Starmer over Savile, but implying PM and Starmer had something in common, minister claims
Boris Johnson’s comment in the House of Commons on Monday that Keir Starmer “spent most of his time [as DPP] prosecuting journalists and failing to prosecute Jimmy Savile” was widely seen as a smear because it implied that Starmer was in some way personally responsible for the CPS’s decision not to prosecute Savile, when there is no evidence for that at all.
But in an interview on the Today programme this morning James Cleverly, the Foreign Office minister, rejected claims that the comment amounted to a smear. Pointing out that as head of the CPS Starmer subsequently issued an apology for the “shortcomings” of the organisation in relation to the Savile case, Cleverly suggested Johnson was making a comparison between Starmer’s situation and his own. Cleverly told the programme:
Keir Starmer apologised for the CPS’s failure to pursue criminal prosecutions ...
Keir Starmer has said that leaders should carry the can – his words. He has apologised for the CPS’s failure to prosecute whilst he was director of public prosecutions. The point is, if the criticism that Keir Starmer is laying at the prime minister is about taking responsibility for the actions of organisations he leads ...
When someone is laying criticism of the prime minister about events that went on in organisations that they run, highlighting the fact that Keir Starmer, in a position of leadership, also apologised on behalf of his organisation, also put a review in place and also drove changes, which is is exactly how the prime minister has responded to the issues raised in Sue Gray’s report ...
This is the first time a minister has advanced this argument in public. Cleverly seems to be arguing that, far from smearing Starmer, Johnson was in fact expressing solidarity with him, as someone who has also had to take the rap for mistakes made by underlings.
It is an ingenious argument, although marred by two flaws. First, it did not sound as if that was what Johnson was saying to anyone who heard him in the Commons on Monday. And, second, Johnson is widely seen as being at fault personally in relation to partygate, in a way that Starmer isn’t in relation to Savile.
Updated
The decision by a DUP minister to halt all Brexit checks on food and animals entering Northern Ireland has been described by Ireland’s European commissioner as “an absolute breach of international law”, my colleague Lisa O’Carroll reports.
There are three statements in the Commons today, after business questions. Here is the timetable.
10.30am: Jacob Rees-Mogg, leader of the Commons, takes questions on next week’s Commons business.
Around 11.30am: Rishi Sunak, the chancellor, makes a statement on his response to rising energy bills.
Around 12.30pm: Edward Argar, a health minister, makes a statement.
Around 1.30pm: Victoria Prentis, an environment minister, makes a statement on Northern Ireland (where a DUP minister in the executive is trying to stop checks on food and animals going from Britain to Northern Ireland).
Rachel Reeves, the shadow chancellor, has posted a thread on Twitter attacking the government’s response to the cost of living crisis. It starts here.
She is particularly critical of the reported plan to offer loans to energy companies, to allow them to cut the cost of fuel bills now, but on the basis that the loans would be repaid.
Northern Ireland's DUP first minister set to resign, in bid to collapse power-sharing executive
Paul Givan, the DUP first minister of Northern Ireland, is set to resign, leading to the probably collapse of the power-sharing Northern Ireland executive, the BBC reports. This is part of the DUP’s ongoing fight to get rid of the Northern Ireland protocol, at least in its current form. A DUP minister in the executive, Edwin Poots, has already ordered officials not to enforce the checks required under the protocol.
The BBC’s Jayne McCormack has a good Twitter thread explaining the consequences of Givan’s resignation. It starts here.
Rishi Sunak set to respond to huge rise in fuel bills amid cost of living crisis
Good morning. While partygate has dominated the headlines for weeks, most politicians believe that the cost of living crisis is the story that will affect lives most this year and frame the battleground for the next election. And today it is bursting right to the top of the news agenda.
Ofgem, the energy regulator, will this morning announce a rise in the cap on energy bills that will effectively amount to the steepest increase in the amount people pay for heating ever recorded. The announcement has been brought forward so that it can be timed to coincide with a parallel announcement from Rishi Sunak, the chancellor, about what the government is going to do to help.
As Jillian Ambrose and Rowena Mason report in their overnight story, Sunak is expected to announce a series of measures, combining loans to energy companies to allow them to offer consumers discounts - a measure that should help everyone - plus targeted measures for poorer families, which are likely to involve council tax discounts and the extension of benefits that help with fuel costs.
However, for most consumers, these measures are only expected to lessen the impact of rising bills; people are still expected to face soaring costs.
This morning Labour has renewed its calls for a windfall tax on the profits of energy companies to help fund measures that would help families pay their bill. After Shell declared that 2021 had been a “momentous” year for the company as it announced its latest earning figures, Ed Miliband, the shadow secretary of state for climate and net zero, said:
With oil and gas profits booming in recent months because of the spike in energy prices, it is clearer than ever that the North Sea oil and gas producers who have made a fortune recently should be asked to contribute.
Labour would keep energy bills low, and we wouldn’t be landing costs with bill payers as they head into a spring of higher taxes and rising prices.
Our plan, part paid for with a one-off windfall tax on North Sea oil and gas profits, would save most households £200 off their bills, with targeted support of up to £400 on top of that to the squeezed middle, pensioners and the lowest earners.
Labour will reform our broken energy system so we deliver the green transition we need, energy security, and bills that are affordable.
It was Miliband, of course, who first proposed an energy price cap when he was Labour leader in 2013. At the time the Conservatives rubbished the ideas as Marxist, but Theresa May subsequently adopted the proposal and now it is one of those policies (like the minimum wage, devolution or gay marriage) that has gone from being highly controversial to having such strong cross-party support that it is probably here for good.
I shall be covering the political aspects of this story, but my colleague Graeme Wearden will be covering the business side, including the probable announcement of a rise in interest rates from the Bank of England, his business live blog. It’s here.
Here is the agenda for the day.
9am: Keir Starmer gives a speech on trust at Edelman.
10am: Tony Danker, the CBI director general, gives a speech to the Centre for Policy Studies.
After 10.30am: Jacob Rees-Mogg, the leader of the Commons, takes questions from MPs on next week’s Commons business.
11am: Ofgem makes its announcement about the energy price cap.
11am: Downing Street holds a lobby briefing.
Around 11.30am: Rishi Sunak, the chancellor, makes a statement to MPs on measures to help households with the cost of living.
12pm: Nicola Sturgeon, Scotland’s first minister, takes questions in the Scottish parliament.
5pm: Sunak holds a press conference.
Also, Boris Johnson and Michael Gove, the levelling up secretary, are on a visit in the north-west.
I try to monitor the comments below the line (BTL) but it is impossible to read them all. If you have a direct question, do include “Andrew” in it somewhere and I’m more likely to find it. I do try to answer questions, and if they are of general interest, I will post the question and reply above the line (ATL), although I can’t promise to do this for everyone.
If you want to attract my attention quickly, it is probably better to use Twitter. I’m on @AndrewSparrow.
Alternatively, you can email me at andrew.sparrow@theguardian.com
Updated