Graeme Wearden 

Bond market turmoil eases as Treasury minister says ‘no need’ for government intervention – as it happened

Lib Dems say chancellor should stay and make emergency fiscal statement and also cancel planned national insurance hike
  
  

The Lib Dems said the chancellor should ‘cancel her counterproductive jobs tax’ .
The Lib Dems said the chancellor should ‘cancel her counterproductive jobs tax’ . Photograph: Vuk Valcic/SOPA Images/REX/Shutterstock

Closing post.

Time to recap.

The turmoil in the UK bond market has calmed today, as the government insisted there was no need to intervene to stem rising borrowing costs.

After an early jump, UK bond yields have fallen back, and are only slightly above last night’s levels, meaning the country’s borrowing costs are little changed today/

The pound, which hit 14-month low in early trading, has recovered some ground – and is down two-thirds of a cent today at $1.23.

Interactive

The recovery came after chief secretary to the Treasury, Darren Jones, told MPs that the government remained fully committed to its fiscal rules.

He said:

“In recent months, moves in financial markets have been largely driven by data and geopolitical events, which is to be expected as markets adjust to new information.

“UK gilt markets continue to function in an orderly way and underlying demand for the UK’s debt remains strong.”

Jones also denied that the government had made any emergency interventions, by releasing statements on the issue, and that there was no need for one anyway.

Jones was answering an urgent question in the House of Commons, called after the UK’s 10-year borrowing costs hit the highest since 2008, while 30-year gilt yields climbed to a 26-year high.

Bank of England deputy governor Sarah Breeden also struck a calming tone tonight, telling an audience at the University of Edinburgh Business School that moves in the gilr market had been “orderly”.

Economists have suggested that the recent rise in borrowing costs has all-but-eaten away the headroom left by chancellor Rachel Reeves to hit her fiscal goals.

Some have suggested she could cut spending, or potentially raise some taxes, in the spring statement scheduled for March.

The Liberal Democrats called for Reeves to cancel a planned trip to China this week, and instead deliver an emergency budget.

The BoE’s Sarah Breeden has also said that direction of travel on UK interest rates is clear – downwards.

Bank rate will be coming down. The question is the pace at which it comes down. And we will only know that as the data evolves and we get a clearer read on the nature of the shocks that we are seeing.”

My colleague Richard Partington has asked BoE deputy governor Sarah Breeden if the recent tightening of financial conditions strengthened the case for UK interest rate cuts.

She says:

“Of course we look at what’s happening to borrowing rates, look at them in the round, see what’s happening to demand in the economy, so the extent that interest rates have risen, and demand will be lower, we would expect to take that into account

“Let’s zoom out here. When i joined the MPC in November 2023 the 2 and 5 year rates at which people could borrow were more than 100bps higher than they are today [for fixed-rate mortgages].

So while we might have seen a tick-up recently, the big trend is downwards, that reflects the waves of adjustment of those external shocks, and we might expect that to feed into bank rate from here.”

Updated

The London stock market has closed higher tonight.

The FTSE 100 index of blue chip shares has ended the day up 0.8%, or 68 points, at 8319 points.

The smaller FTSE 250 index, which contains more UK companies, gained 0.3%, having hit a nine-month low this morning.

BoE's Breeden: 'so far so good' in gilt markets

Bank of England deputy governor Sarah Breeden has told her audience in Edinbugh that the central bank is watching the moves in the UK gilt market, and believes they have been “orderly”.

Breeden says:

Of course we’re monitoring what’s happening in the gilt market. It’s a core market, we care a lot about it.

A lot of the price moves reflect global factors happening in the US and Europe as well as here in the UK and that’s to be expected as markets react to news about what the outlook is for the fiscal position

We have a dashboard, we’re monitoring it, so far the moves have been orderly, we’ll continue to watch this space. So far so good.

Updated

Capital Economics, the City consultancy, are confident that UK government bonds will recover soon.

In a research note titled “A global bond market storm in a British teacup”, their senior markets economist Hubert de Barochez says:

UK Gilts have not only been embroiled in a global government bond sell-off, but they have fared worse than others. However, we think that bonds will recover before long, with yields in the UK falling particularly sharply by the end of this year.

Updated

BoE's Breeden: economic activity appears to be weakening

Bank of England deputy governor Sarah Breeden has warned that activity in the UK economy appears to be slowing, which reinforces the case to cut interest rates.

In a speech to University of Edinburgh Business School this afternooon, Breeden says data is pointing to a slowing in economic activity in the UK, citing the small falls in GDP in September and October.

While the energy price shock has faded, the economy has also facing new shocks – including the changes to employers’ National Insurance Contributions (NICs) and the increase to the minimum wage that will be implemented in April, Breeden points out.

She says:

First, as monetary policymakers we must always be analysing which shocks we think are hitting the economy and what their implications might be for the medium-term inflation outlook. We have to remain flexible and constantly challenge ourselves about how wrong we could be and what that would mean. We must always be reading between the lines.

Second, I have updated my views on the shocks that have been driving the economy recently. The demand environment has been more resilient in recent years than we initially thought – partly because the response to the energy price shock was less negative than we thought, and probably also reflecting weaker supply. There is now some tentative evidence that activity is starting to weaken, though we expect it to pick up again.

Third, the recent evidence further supports the case to withdraw policy restrictiveness and I expect to continue to remove restrictiveness gradually over time. The important questions as I look ahead are what combination of shocks explains the recent slowdown in activity and how will employers respond to higher employment costs. The answers to those questions will affect the outlook for medium-term inflation and so the speed at which restrictiveness needs to be removed.

Updated

Market turmoil: the key charts

These charts paint a picture of the key moves we’ve seen in the UK bond market, the foreign exchange market, and equities in recent days:

Interactive
Interactive
Interactive

What gilt sell-off might mean for you

It’s rarely good news when the UK bond market is headline news, so many Britons may be worried about the implications of the gilt market turmoil on their finances.

Financial services firm Hargreaves Lansdown has explained the impact on pensions and annuities.

Here’s Helen Morrissey, their head of pensions analysis:

“Falling bond prices could cause concern for retirees who are coming up to retirement invested in lifestyling arrangements. These move the member out of equities and into bonds the closer they get to retirement. However, there’s no need for knee-jerk reactions. Those who intend to remain invested through income drawdown have the ability to hold fire on drawing an income until the markets have recovered. Those who are looking to annuitise some or all of their pension pot will also likely find that the spike in gilt yields can push the income available from an annuity upwards, softening the impact. It’s also worth saying that you don’t have to annuitise all your pension at once. You can do it in stages throughout retirement securing a guaranteed income as your needs evolve while leaving the rest invested in drawdown where it can grow.”

And on mortgages, Sarah Coles, head of personal finance. at Hargreaves Lansdown, says:

“The rise in gilt yields always raises the spectre of rising fixed mortgage rates, because they’re very responsive to changes in interest rate expectations. Rates have already crept up very slightly, but there’s no need for prospective borrowers to panic at this stage.

It’s worth noting that although the bond markets have thrown a wobbly, it hasn’t particularly altered expectations of what the Bank of England is likely to do to rates. The market is still pricing in just over a 60% chance of a rate cut in February – it has moved from 66% to 64%, but that’s nothing to frighten the horses.

Very slightly higher rates have been brought in by some mortgage lenders, who had to secure a fixed rate in the swap markets while they’re more expensive, but as yet there’s nothing more widespread. This is likely to filter into more deals, but it’s not yet clear how long this disruption in the bond markets will last.

The bond market in the UK reacted dramatically to news out of the US – more so than other markets around the world. In the coming days, this could subside if the bond markets decide they’ve got a bit ahead of themselves. There are no guarantees, but the strength of the immediate reaction means there’s room for the markets to gain a bit of perspective. If that happens, we’ll see yields drop again, and mortgage rates could ease.

Of course, there are no guarantees. If more worrying news comes out of the US, or fears of stagflation spread, bond yields could remain higher, and if this happens, there’s more of a chance it will be reflected in more widespread higher mortgage rates.”

Updated

HSBC have issued an interesting research note, explaining how the financial markets are pricing in “persistently higher” UK inflation.

They explain:

A big part of the fiscal problem is a lack of growth. But the UK isn’t alone in Europe in. facing persistently weak productivity growth. Yet its high short and long-term interest rates are comparable to those of the faster-growing US.

Moreover, despite tighter expected monetary policy, market prices suggest that longer-term UK inflation might be a bit higher than in the eurozone. It feels like the worst of all worlds.

HSBC also flag that the Office for Budget Responsibility’s ‘ready reckoner’ is that a sustained 1% rise in long-term yields raises debt servicing costs by about £10bn a year.

So, if sustained, the rise in yields since the 30 October Budget could have wiped out the Chancellor’s £9.9bn of fiscal headroom. Unless something changes, more tough choices on tax rises, spending cuts or tearing up the new fiscal targets loom over the 26 March Spring Statement.

Full story: Reeves’ fiscal rules non-negotiable in face of bond sell-off, deputy tells MPs

Rachel Reeves will not break her promise to borrow money only for investment, even as gilt yields rose to their highest levels since the financial crisis, her deputy has said.

Darren Jones, the Treasury chief secretary, told MPs the chancellor would not borrow to pay for day-to-day spending despite rising UK borrowing costs that threaten to make it much harder for her to meet her fiscal rules.

He was answering an urgent question in the Commons about the recent market turmoil, which has sent UK borrowing costs higher, the pound lower and prompted calls for Reeves to cancel her long-planned trip to China.

Jones told the Commons:

“There should be no doubt about the government’s commitment to economic stability and sound public finances, this is why meeting the fiscal rules is non-negotiable.”

Rachel Reeves has three possible courses of action from here, should we move forward with elevated interest rates and sluggish private sector growth, Morgan Stanley analysts argue.

  1. The first, “obvious”, option, is simply to hike taxes to counter rising spending – perhaps as early as March.

  2. Another option, is to commit to steep spending cuts beyond the current Spending Review period, while also spending more in the near term.

  3. The third option is some financial wizardry, to make near-term cuts to capex budget plans, and re-route the funds into current budgets where needed.

It’s true that the first option, of tax increases, would increase revenues, but Reeves ruled out many potential tax rises before the election.

The second option has been used by chancellors in the past to keep within their long-term fiscal targets, but is tricky this time, as the upcoming spending review should run until almost the end of the five-year forecast horizon.

Updated

Although UK bond markets have stabilised, there are still risks afoot, warns Kathleen Brooks, research director at XTB.

She points out that although bond yields have stabilised at last night’s levels, they’re still at elevated levels.

Brooks suggests a quieter US bond market may be helping UK gilts:

The halt to the UK bond sell off could be down to multiple factors. Some have wondered about official intervention; however, we think that this is unlikely.

Financial markets are quiet on Thursday, US equity markets are closed, and the Treasury market has shortened hours due to President Carter’s funeral.

Since UK yields have been moving higher along with US yields, the fact that US bond markets are quiet could spill over to the UK. However, this could be a short reprieve.

Brooks suspects the UK bond market will suffer more frequent bouts of volatility this year, as it remains “firmly in the bond vigilante’s sights,” adding:

A weak economic outlook, nervous investors who will be sensitive to news headlines and data releases and also the failure of the current government to firmly lay out their plans to get public spending under control, get people back to work, and boost growth without taxing the UK economy further, are all weak links for the UK bond market.

Stellantis hits UK EV targets, despite Luton factory closure

Vauxhall owner Stellantis has said that it has met the UK government’s electric car targets for 2024, despite blaming the rules for the planned closure of its van factory at Luton.

The carmaker on Thursday said that it sold 39,500 electric cars in 2024, up 59% compared with a year earlier. It said that “strong sales of the group’s extensive line-up of electric vehicles” meant it had complied with the UK’s zero-emission vehicle (ZEV) mandate for both cars and vans, without resorting to loopholes or buying “credits” from other manufacturers.

Under the mandate, carmakers must sell increasing numbers of electric vehicles every year. However, the industry has lobbied strenuously for the government to relax the targets, with changes expected by the spring.

Stellantis blamed the mandate for its decision to put 1,100 workers at the Luton factory at risk of redundancy, in one of the last decisions overseen by Carlos Tavares before he was ousted as chief executive. The Guardian previously revealed that Stellantis had told investors that it was confident of meeting the targets, but Stellantis argued on Thursday that tightening electric car targets would cause a problem in the coming years.

Eurig Druce, group managing director of Stellantis in the UK, said:

Despite offering a very comprehensive line-up of popular electric cars and vans, and a strong will and focus on making our EVs as attainable as possible, the steep trajectories of the ZEV mandate are out of step from current demand. Put simply, if the UK is to achieve its transport emission ambitions, and for EVs to represent 80% of new cars sold in 2030, then consumers are going to need more encouragement from government to do so.

Andy Palmer, the former boss of carmaker Aston Martin and now a consultant, said:

Against all odds, at least according to pockets of the media, Stellantis has proved that the ZEV mandate is achievable by hitting targets in 2024. This is even more impressive after the automaker has been reported, potentially incorrectly, as one of the firms most outspoken about reforming the policy.

Or perhaps all they are asking for is a little help to get more bums on EV seats. The ZEV mandate is boosting choice for consumers and driving down prices.

Matthew Amis, investment manager at investment manager abrdn, has predicted that Rachel Reeves will have to outline cuts to government spending in her spring statement scheduled for late March.

Amis says:

“Weakness in GBP [the pound] and the gilt market feels like an inevitable consequence of a badly received budget and the proposed stage management of 2025’s fiscal events. Jeremy Hunt started the trend of leaving very little fiscal headroom and Rachel Reeves continued that trend in October’s budget.

As gilt yields rose into year-end (admittedly mostly driven by news from the US), the limited fiscal headroom has been eroded. We expect that Reeves will have broken her own newly drafted fiscal rules when the OBR present their updated forecasts at the end of March.

The UK is borrowing a lot this year, investors need confidence to buy that debt otherwise gilt yields will continue to move higher and the currency will continue to weaken.

What might Reeves do? The spending review is not due to be delivered until June, that’s a long time for the market to speculate with confidence continuing to erode. We ultimately expect to see a Spring budget alongside the OBR forecasts, where she signals greater cuts to government spending.”

Updated

In the media world, Bauer Media, the owner of magazines and radio stations including Grazia, Heat, Kiss, Magic and Absolute, has acquired the UK and northern European business of billboard advertising giant Clear Channel for $625m (£507m).

New York-listed Clear Channel is selling its operations in 12 markets including the UK, where it operates more than 33,000 outdoor sites including billboards, posters and screens, including more than 2,000 in Greater London.

Bauer Media said that under the deal the European operation, which employs 1,400 staff, will continue to be led by existing Clear Channel management.

Clear Channel UK, which is headquartered in Golden Square in London, employs more than 700 people across 14 locations.

“Bringing together our two companies’ offerings will enable us to reach 350m consumers through 200 magazine brands, 150 audio brands and 110,000 out-of-home [advertising] sites across Europe,” said Yvonne Bauer, chair of the board of the German media giant.

“By enhancing our core media and related businesses while investing in our digital transformation, this move broadens our capabilities and strengthens our position as a major player in the highly competitive media industry.’’

The deal, which is expected to close later this year following regulatory approvals, will see Bauer take control of Clear Channel’s operations in the UK, Belgium, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, Ireland, Latvia, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Norway, Poland and Sweden.

Bauer said that it already runs outdoor advertising operations in seven of the markets, and will become a new entrant in five.

Clear Channel has been seeking to sell its UK and northern European operations since 2023.

In November of that year the company announced the sale of its business in France to Equinox Industries, having previously sold its businesses in Switzerland, Italy.

In October, a deal to sell its business to a subsidiary of rival outdoor advertising company JC Decaux was terminated following a regulatory review.

The company has also conducted a strategic review of its business in Latin America, which includes operations in Mexico, Brazil, Chile and Peru.

Bauer Media’s lead adviser was LionTree while Moelis and Deutsche Bank held the remit to sell Clear Channel’s Europe-North operations.

Darren Jones pointed out to MPs today that the market for UK government debt is often influenced by a range of factors.

And it’s notable that today’s recovery in UK bond yields comes as US government debt also strengthens.

[yield rise when bond prices fall, and vice versa].

The yields on US Treasury bills have dropped today, in what will be a shortened session due to president Jimmy Carter’s funeral.

Government bonds often move in a sort of lock-step, as they react to the same sets of data covering – for example – inflation or growth, so it’s a worrying sign when just one country’s borrowing costs jump.

New programme for Ukraine commercial property reinsurance

Away from the drama in the government bond markets, McGill and Partners, a London based broker, has launched a programme to reinsure commercial properties in Ukraine against the risk of war damage.

The scheme is the first of its kind, my colleague Isaaq Tomkins reports.

They are collaborating with FortuneGuard, a Lloyd’s Lab insurance technology company, which will use AI to provide risk assessments for properties more than 100km from the front line.

Data on projectiles fired into the country will be used in order to provide businesses with a war-risk quote.

Since the outbreak of war, the international reinsurance market largely withdrew from providing war risk coverage in Ukraine. Now ARX, a local Ukrainian broker, will be able to underwrite policies up to $50m in value, with reinsurance provided by the London market and Lloyd’s syndicates. This is a hundred-fold increase on their previous policy limit of $500,000.

“We recognise the significant role of the insurance industry in supporting Ukraine’s economic regrowth.” said Steve McGill, CEO of McGill and Partners.

“By harnessing the power of AI and comprehensive data sets, we have been able to take a more informed approach to presenting and underwriting risk.”

Updated

Isabel Stockton, senior research economist at the IFS, says we shouldn’t be surprised if spending cuts, or tax rises, are needed to keep within the fiscal rules.

The problem, she points out, is that Rachel Reeves allowed herself very little headroom to keep within the rules back in October’s budget, so it doesn’t take much of a change to borrowing costs to put the debt trajectory off-course.

Stockton says:

“If recent rises in interest rates were to persist, they could easily erode most of razor-thin margin against the main fiscal rule. But the issue here is not so much that the past month has been especially eventful, but more that the margin was so small to begin with.

If continuing to meet the fiscal target requires new tax rises, or cuts to the already tight looking spending envelope for the subsequent spending review, then the Chancellor – and we – should not be surprised.”

Pound still down

Although UK goverment bonds have recovered from today’s losses, the pound is still weaker.

Sterling is down three-quarters of a cent at $1.2295, having earlier hit a 14-month low of $1.2240.

That will push up the cost of imports into the UK.

But, a weaker currency could also help the UK escape from a vicious circle of higher yields, lesser fiscal space and lower growth.

So argues Deutsche Bank analyst George Saravelos, who told clients:

A weaker pound does three things. First, it helps improve the country’s negative net international investment position by a mechanical revaluation of UK-owned foreign assets. Two, it cheapens up UK assets (= gilts) so eventually they become attractive to buy again for a foreigner. Third, it helps the current account deficit adjust, reducing the reliance on foreign funding.

To be sure, the Chancellor and central bank have an important job to do. The Bank of England needs to maintain the credibility of the inflation target. The Chancellor needs to signal sensitivity to the worsening global environment by potentially paring back some spending.

Both need to avoid any signal of fiscal dominance. But beyond a few tweaks here and there, it is largely the currency that will do the work of stabilizing the bond market combined with an eventual peak of US yields.

UK bond sell-off has calmed

Calm has returned to the UK bond market!

The yields on UK government debt, which had jumped again this morning, have now dropped back to their levels at the end of trading last night.

Investors have, perhaps, noted Treasury minister Darren Jones’s insistance that the gilt market has been functioning as normal and there is no need for the government to intervene.

The yield (or interest rate) on 10-year bonds, which hit its highest since 2008 this morning, has now slipped back to 4.796%.

Thirty-year bond yields have returned to 5.355%, having hit their highest since 1998 earlier today.

Updated

Urgent question: What we learned

With today’s urgent question over the rising cost of borrowing over, what did we learn?

1) The government is sticking to its fiscal rules, even though rising gilt yields are eating into their headroom

Chief secretary to the Treasury Darren Jones insisted that meeting the rules (to not borrow for day-to-day spending, and to have the national debt falling in five years) is non-negotiable.

2) No return to austerity.

If borrowing won’t increase further, and taxes won’t go again, isn’t cutting spending the only alternative to keep within the fiscal rules, several Conservative MPs suggested.

Jones said public spending will be “within the numbers set out in the budget”, and didn’t explicitly rule out tax rises.

3) No reason to panic!

Often a witty presence, Darren Jones seemed keen to exude calm from the dispatch box.

After days of rising borrowing costs, he declared:

UK gilt markets continue to function in an orderly way

And he wouldn’t accept that Treasury press releases to journalists counted as an ‘emergency intervention’, saying:

There has been no emergency statement or emergency intervention, these are make-believe words being propagated by members on the benches opposite….

There is no need for any emergency intervention, and there hasn’t been one.

Several Labour MPs argued during today’s urgent question that the Conservative Party should take responsibility for the state of the public finances.

John Slinger, MP for Rugby, argues they should be apologising, rather than criticising.

Darren Jones says it’s very important for the Conservatives to apologise. But the more they “grunt and groan” and claim everything was wonderful under them, the better for Labour, so “long may it continue”.

Tory MP Patrick Spencer, though, doesn’t sound very apologetic, accusing Jones of only wanting to talk about the past.

Spencer tells MPs that borrowing costs are up, busines confidence is down, and growth is going nowhere.

He tells MPs that it is time to admit that the “lefty economic experiment” is failing – the solution is to cut taxes and spending.

Jones insists that fiscal responsibility isn’t a lefty ideology – it’s what the British people expect.

Lib Dems call for emergency fiscal statement

The Liberal Democrat Leader, Ed Davey, has called on the chancellor to cancel her trip to China and instead make an emergency fiscal statement to parliament cancelling the national insurance hike planned for April, to boost economic growth and give the Bank of England more room to bring interest rates down.

The increase in employers’ national insurance costs is expected to push inflation slightly higher, as some companies have already signalled price rises (see earlier post), while the national minimum wage is also going up in April, by 6.7%.

Higher inflation will make it harder for the central bank to make further rate cuts. Markets are now expecting two quarter-point reductions this year, rather than three as forecast before December.

Davey said:

“Instead of jetting off to China, the chancellor should urgently come before the House of Commons to cancel her counterproductive jobs tax and set out a real plan for growth.

“The country is paying an ever-higher price for the total mess the Conservative Party made of our economy, and the chancellor needs to realise that she’ll never dig us out of this hole without a far more ambitious plan to grow our economy, including rebuilding trade with Europe.

The government’s misguided jobs tax is hurting businesses and hitting investment badly, meaning it will hold back growth while failing to raise the funding the chancellor claims for the NHS.

The chancellor should look instead at our plans to raise revenue without hitting jobs and growth, by raising taxes on the profits of the big banks, social media giants and online gambling firms – all of which are making eye-watering profits while ordinary families struggle.”

Liberal Democrat MP Max Wilkinson brings up Liz Truss’s decision to issue “cease and desist” letters to those who accuse her of crashing the economy.

He asks Darren Jones to compare and contrast Truss’s “disastrous” mini-budget with what’s being discussed today.

Darren Jones says he can’t comment on legal proceedings.

But, one of the “huge lessons” for the voting public is that the “hubris, the ego and the lack of focus on working people” frrom Conservative ministers had a direct impact, and “ruined the lives of people across this country”, he adds.

Updated

Harking back to the mini-budget crisis of 2022, Darren Jones says people across the country suffered from higher mortgage bills, as well as higher grocery bills.

Conservative MPs should observe “a period of silence while they learn the lessons”, he argues.

Speaking of 2022…Liz Truss has sent a legal letter to Keir Starmer demanding he stops making “false and defamatory” claims that she crashed the economy.

Labour MP Louise Jones tells MPs that many of her constituents (in North East Derbyshire) are “really struggling” with the cost of living crisis, which is why the government must rebuild the foundations of the economy.

Darren Jones agrees, saying that if you play fast and loose with the nation’s finances, you play fast and loose with the public’s finances too.

Liberal Democrat Paul Kohler suggests the opposition MPs have an “incredible brass neck” for expressing concerns about the UK’s debt situation.

Isn’t the solution to growth to re-engage with Europe?

Darren Jones say the UK needs to improve trading relationship with countries around the world – that’s why Rachel Reeves is going to China.

Tice: We are heading towards a financial crisis

Reform MP Richard Tice has warned parliament that the UK is heading towards a financial crisis.

Tice points out that UK GDP fell in September and October (both by 0.1%), while sterling is “falling, almost collapsing”.

Confidence is falling and investors are fleeing, he warns, while the only things going up are “inflation, wasteful public spending, and the cost of debt”.

Tice says:

We are heading towards, be under no illusion, a financial crisis.

He asks Darren Jones to tell the chancellor to return from her ‘ridiculous’ trip to China, and cut daft spending and wasteful regulation to create growth.

Jones replies that he will not tell Reeves to come back from her trade trip to China.

Jones denies austerity will come back

Conservative MP Bernard Jenkins, argues that Darren Jones is making a significant announcement today – that austerity is effectively back.

Jenkins makes the point that if tax rises and borrowing increases are off the table, then the only lever left is spending cuts.

He says:

There is no way that the public finances can be remedied by another budget of wishful thinking, pretending that increased borrowing and spending will produce growth.

That has been proved as a false way to lead the economy, he argues.

Darren Jones says the government is not bringing back austerity – that was an ideological cuts to public finances and the size of the state, irrespective of what it meant for public services.

Chancellor Rachel Reeves announced the ‘opposite of austerity’ last autumn, the chief secretary to the Treasury insists, by making more money available for public services.

Darren Jones: No need for emergency intervention

Harriett Baldwin MP accuses Rachel Reeves of having ‘fled to China’ rather than face MPs over the rise in public borrowing costs, because she realises her budget means she is “the arsonist”.

Baldwin says yesterday’s statement from the Treasury (which said the government has an iron grip on the public finances) was an “extraordinary emergency” effort to calm the markets.

Darren Jones says these “inflammatory” comments are rather surprising, and don’t reflect reality.

The trip to China has been in the diary for weeks, he points out.

And he rejects claims that the Treasury has intervened in the markets, saying yesterday’s statement was simply a response to questions from the media.

Jones says:

There has been no emergency statement or emergency intervention, these are make-believe words being propagated by members on the benches opposite….

There is no need for any emergency intervention, and there hasn’t been one.

[as reported earlier, the Daily Telegraph reported last night’s statement as the Treasury stepping in to halt market mayhem.

Technically, an intervention actually involves a government or central bank actually buying or selling an asset to move the markets, not simply issuing a press release].

Updated

Conservative MP John Glenn says the government must either cut spending, raise taxes, or borrow more to keep within the fiscal rules.

If the cost of borrowing is rising, the decision comes sooner – so when will the government say what it plans to do?

Darren Jones repeats that the fiscal rules are non-negotiable, and that public services must live within their means.

Labour MP Torsten Bell points out that the opposition are keen on spending increases, but oppose tax rises to pay for it.

Q: Isn’t one of the lessons of the developments recent days that we must pay for day-to-day spending through tax rises, however tough that is?

Chief secretary to the Treasury Darren Jones agrees that day-to-day bills need to be paid by day-to-day income.

Conservative MP Sir Edward Leigh tries to nail down how the government will keep within the fiscal rules.

Q: Will the minister give an absolute assurance there will be no more increases in tax or borrowing?

Darren Jones says he can absolutely assure Leigh that the spending review will be developed within the envelope laid out in the budget.

Liberal Democrat Treasury spokesman Clive Jones warns MPs that the Labour government is making some of the same mistakes as its predecessors.

He says Rachel Reeves has a very difficult job, having inherited an economy “on its knees due to Conservative mismanagement” (cue much groaning from some Tory MPs).

Jones cites the “terrible trade deal with Europe”, “soaring inflation”, “stagnant growth” and the Liz Truss mini-budget which hit mortgage holders across the country.

Q: Is protecting the NHS and healthcare also non-negotiable, as the government tries to balance the books?

Darren Jones says the NHS is one of the government’s “key commitments”.

He also suggests the opposition have a nerve groaning at Clive Jones’s comments – the public should be groaning at them, he argues.

Labour MP Meg Hillier asks what notice departments will get of further cuts they may need to make to meet the fiscal rules.

Darren Jones says the second phase of the spending review, to set budgets from 2026-27, is under way. The review will be concluded by June.

Chief secretary to the Treasury Darren Jones repeats that the fiscal rules are ‘non-negotiable”.

He doesn’t explicitly say whether that would mean tax rises or spending cuts, but does say that public services will have to ‘live within their means’.

He points out that the UK debt burden rose steadily since 2010, to pay for day-to-day spending, under the previous Conservative government.

Mel Stride adds that “regrettably”, the government could be on track to breach its fiscal rules.

Does the government stand by Rachel Reeves’s pledge not to raise taxes further, and does this mean that government spending will be cut if the OBR concludes that the fiscal headroom has ‘evaporated’, he asks.

Stride: Higher debt and lower growth are worrying consumers, firms and the markets

Shadow chancellor Mel Stride responds, demanding to know where Rachel Reeves is to answer today’s question.

Stride blames the chancellor’s decisions for pushing long-term borrowing costs up to a 27-year high.

The economy is now flatlining, he says, as business confidence has “simply evaporated”.

He tells MPs:

Higher debt and lower growth are understandably now causing real concerns among the public, amongst businesses, and in the markets.

Stride brushes aside Darren Jones’s argument that international geopolitical factors are influencing the bond market, pointing out that the UK’s borrowing premium over German bonds recently hit its highest level since 1990.

Darren Jones concludes his statement by reminding the opposition that the Conservative party “crashed the economy” with unfunded tax cuts and unrealistic public spending cuts.

Families across the country are still paying the price with higher mortgages and bills, Jones adds.

He also cites the “£22bn black hole” which Labour says it found upon taking office.

Updated

Jones: Government is committed to economic stability, sound public finances, and the fiscal rules

Darren Jones then tells MPs that he will not preempt the forecasts which the OBR will deliver for the spring statement on 26th March (which will show whether or not the UK is meeting the fiscal rules).

He adds:

There should be no doubt of the government’s commitment to economic stability and sound public finances.

This is why meeting the fiscal rules is non-negotiable.

MPs hear urgent question about rising borrowing costs

Shadow chancellor Mel Stride is asking an urgent question in the House of Commons now, about “the growing pressure of borrowing costs on the public finances”.

He is asking it on a morning in which the UK’s 10-year borrowing costs hit the highest since 2008, while 30-year bond yields reached the highest since 1998.

Although Stride is asking the question to chancellor Rachel Reeves, it will be answered by her deputy Darren Jones, chief secretary to the Treasury.

Jones tells MPs that financial markets are “always evolving”, and cites the long-standing convention that the government does not comment on specific market movements. He won’t break that convention today.

Jones says that changes to bond yields are determined by many factors, both international and domestic.

In recent months, financial market moves have been largely driven by “data and global geopolitical events”, Jones says, as they adjust to “new information”.

He declares:

UK gilt markets continue to function in an orderly way. Underlying demand for the UK’s debt remains strong, with a generally well-diversed investor base.

Jones cites an auction of five-year gilts yesterday, which received bids for three times as much debt as was on sale.

This morning’s market gyrations are moving the London stock market.

The domestically-focused FTSE 250 index of medium-sized companies has dropped to a nine-month low this morning, down around 0.6%.

But the more internationally-focused FTSE 100 share index has risen by 0.6%. It’s been driven by multinational firms, such as miners, whose overseas earnings become more valuable in sterling terms when the pound falls.

Retailers are among the fallers, following this morning’s Christmas trading updates, as are house-builders who will suffer lower demand if interest rates remain high.

The current market moves are not a repeat of the panic of 2022, says Kit Juckes, currency expert at French bank Société Générale.

He points out that the moves are smaller than after the Truss/Kwarteng mini-budget, and due to different reasons:

The similarity between what has gone into folklore as the ‘Truss Crisis’ and the current situation is that sterling and gilt yields have moved sharply in opposite directions.

The extent of the move is much smaller so far, and I doubt it will become as critical. In 2022 a new PM, with her new Chancellor, came up with a bafflingly ill-considered set of Budget proposals and triggered a crisis of confidence. Even then, the September 2022 fall in GBP/USD from 1.16 to 1.05 was fully reversed by the end of October and so was the spike in gilt yields.

What has happened this time, is that the increase in employers’ national insurance contributions announced at the Budget appears to have put the brakes on growth to a greater extent than (I, for one) expected. Deteriorating public finances may force unhelpful fiscal tightening sooner than expected.

A global bond sell-off doesn’t help and gilts having a worse time than others support the idea that the pool of investors who will step in to ‘buy the dip’ in gilts isn’t what it was pre-Brexit. Especially in thin post-New Year markets.

UK firms plan to raise prices and cut workers after Nics increase

More than half of UK firms are planning to raise prices or cut jobs in response to Rachel Reeves’s increase in employers’ national insurance contributions, a new survey from the Bank of England shows.

The Bank has polled chief financial officers from small, medium and large UK businesses, and asked how they expect to respond to the increase in employer National Insurance contributions that were announced in the Autumn Budget.

It found that 61% of firms expect to lower profit margins, 54% expect to raise prices, 53% expect lower employment and 39% expect to pay lower wages than they otherwise would have done.

Firms were allowed to select more than one option, the Bank says.

Parliament to hear urgent question on bond market turmoil

The bond market sell-off will be discussed in parliament today.

Shadow Chancellor Mel Stride has been granted an urgent question, “to ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if she will make a statement on the growing pressure of borrowing costs on the public finances’.

The parliamentary discussion is expected to begin around 10:30am, Reuters reports.

Bond trading giant Pimco has thrown Rachel Reeves a lifeline, saying it is still positive about UK government debt.

Pimco economist Peder Beck-Friis told Reuters last night that much of the increase in UK yields has been driven by the market for US debt.

Beck-Friis says:

“Although UK-specific factors, such as the budget, have contributed to the rise, most of the increase has been driven by rises in U.S. Treasury yields during the same period.”

Beck-Friis added, though, that chancellor Rachel Reeves may need to find new savings as a result of the rise in borrowing costs, to keep within her borrowing rules

He points out:

“Both weaker growth and higher interest rates put pressure on public finances.

If the current trends of rising yields and slowing growth persist, the chances of spending cuts or tax increases will increase for the government to adhere to its new fiscal rules.”

Bond yield sell-off eases, amid 'crisis of confidence' in gilt market

The sell-off in UK government debt is easing slightly.

The yield on 10-year UK gilts is now up just 4bps at 4.834% (from a close of 4.795% last night). It had earlier risen by over 10 basis points to a new 16-year.

But even so, Kathleen Brooks, research director at XTB, says there is no doubt that the market for UK gilts (government debt) is experiencing “a crisis in confidence”.

Brooks says the UK’s fiscal position continues to look perilous this morning, adding:

The sell off in UK bonds this week, is a warning shot from the bond vigilantes. The UK is reliant on investors to fund its deficit.

The UK is not unique in needing this, however, the US can fund its deficit more easily because the US dollar is the reserve currency, and the Eurozone as a whole runs a surplus.

Since the market’s focus so far in 2025 has turned to the sustainability of public sector finances, the UK is understandably in the firing line.

Brooks adds that were are “not in a Liz Truss style moment”, because pension funds have changed their structures so they are less exposed to a rapid and unexpected rise in Gilt yields.

After the 2022 mini-budget, a ‘doom loop’ broke out as pension funds were forced into a fire sale of bonds as prices fell, which fuelled the sell-off.

One City analyst said last night the Treasury’s unusual step to comment on the bond market could be being taken by hedge fund investors as “the scent of blood in the water” as Reeves battles to maintain authority.

Brad Bechtel, global head of foreign exchange at Jefferies, said the sell-off in the pound showed the UK was seeing a “micro version” of the bond market meltdown witnessed after Liz Truss’s 2022 mini budget.

Bechtel said:

“UK gilts continue to melt down and that has so far not impacted the currency as much as it did during the Liz Truss episode, that is until today.

“The pound seems to be reacting to gilts more and more and that means we are spilling further and further into fiscal emergency territory.”

“We don’t ‘feel’ like we are in the same Liz Truss zone right now, mostly because we haven’t seen an LDI blow up, but we are in a micro version of that for sure.”

However, other analysts said the comparisons with the short-lived prime minister’s tenure were overblown.

“It’s nice to talk about this as being a Truss moment. Those comparisons are easy and obvious. But we’re a long way from that,” said Mark Capleton, an analyst at Bank of America.

“Though in level terms we’re higher than then, there has since been a big global sell off, and it has been far more gradual by comparison.”

He said nine of the top 10 daily movements in the gilt market since 1992 had come during 2022. “We’re a long way from that.”

However, he added:

“Obviously people are concerned about a vicious circle with the fiscal arithmetic and the possibility that a further rise in yields could create the need for tightening measures from the chancellor in March.”

The drop in the pound may make it trickier for the Bank of England to lower interest rates as soon as hoped in 2025.

Two two quarter-point cuts to Bank Rate are priced in for this year, bringing rates down from 4.75% to 4.25% by December, but the odds on a cut as soon as February have dipped slightly this week.

Jim Reid, an analyst at Deutsche Bank, explains:

“With sterling weakening, that meant growing questions were asked about whether the Bank of England could cut rates as fast as expected.

“Indeed, investors dialled back their expectations for rate cuts this year by four and a half basis points compared to the previous day, so they now only see 48.5 basis points by the December meeting.

“So collectively, this rise in yields is adding to the risk that the Government will breach their fiscal rules and have to announce further consolidation (tax rises and/or spending cuts), whilst the weaker currency will add to inflationary pressures at the same time.”

Greggs warns lower consumer confidence is hitting sales

Baking chain Greggs has warned that it faces ‘headwinds’ as UK consumer confidence falls, in a fresh blow to the economic outlook.

Greggs reported that sales growth slowed at the end of last year. In the final quarter of 2024, sales at its company-managed shops rose by 2.5%, weaker than the full-year sales growth of 5.5%.

Greggs says that it faced a “more challenging market backdrop” in the second half of 2024, as weaker consumer confidence hits footfall on the high street, meaning fewer visits to its stores.

Chief executive Roisin Currie says:

Whilst lower consumer confidence continues to impact High Street footfall and expenditure, our value-for-money offer and the quality of our freshly-prepared food and drink position us well to meet the headwinds we expect to see in the year ahead, and we remain confident in the significant long-term opportunity for growth.”

Shares in Greggs have fallen by 9.5% this morning.

Tesco and M&S shares fall despite strong Christmas trading

A flurry of top UK retailers are revealing how they performed over the crucial Christmas period – and seeing their shares fall.

Tesco, the UK’s largest supermarket, declared it enjoyed its “biggest ever Christmas”, with sales at established UK stores rising by 4% in the six weeks to 4 January. But shares have dropped by 1.6% this morning.

Marks & Spencer says it also had a good Christmas, with like-for-like food sales up 8.9% in the 13 weeks to 28 December.

M&S warns, though that “the external environment remains challenging, with cost and economic headwinds to navigate”. Its shares have fallen by 6% this morning.

Discount retailer B&M reported a 2.8% increase in UK sales in the last quarter of 2024, with CEO Alex Russo saying “the business remains undistracted by the current economic headlines”.

B&M has also narrowed its forecast for profit growth this year, knocking its shares down by 10% this morning.

Bond panic makes the front pages

The bond market mayhem makes the front pages of several UK newspapers today.

The Daily Telegraph splashed on last night’s statement from the Treasury that they have an ‘iron grip’ on the public finances, calling it an intervention designed to stabilise the markets:

The Daily Mail says the rise in borrowing costs is a ‘red alert’ warning for chancellor Reeves, who may have to cut spending or lift taxes to keep within her fiscal rules.

The i picks up on that point too, saying Britain’s borrowing costs have turned ‘toxic’.

UK bond sell-off continues

UK borrowing costs are rising again this morning, despite the government’s efforts to calm the markets last night.

The yield, or interest rate, on benchmark 10-year UK debt rose by 12 basis points (or 0.12 percentage points) in early trading in London to 4.921%, the highest since 2008.

Thirty-year bond yields, which hit 28-year highs this week, are rising again too – up over 10 basis points to 5.474%.

These moves suggest investors are still fretting about the outlook for the UK economy, given concerns about low growth and inflationary pressures.

It also shows the Treasury’s insistence last night that they have an ‘iron grip’ on the public finances has not eased the pressure….

Britain’s bond turmoil invokes memory of 1976 debt crisis

Former Bank of England policymaker Martin Weale has suggested that we should look to 1976, rather than 2022, for a comparison with the current market anxiety.

1976 was an infamous year in UK economic history, when a plunge in the value of the pound forced the Labour government to turn to the International Monetary Fund for a bailout, with strict spending cuts attached.

Weale has told Bloomberg that this week’s rise in borrowing costs and fall in the value of sterling echo the 1976 debt crisis “nightmare”.

Weale, a professor of economics at King’s College London, says:

“We haven’t really seen the toxic combination of a sharp fall in sterling and long-term interest rates going up since 1976. That led to the IMF bailout.

So far we are not in that position but it must be one of the chancellor’s nightmares.”

The 1976 crisis was highly dramatic; chancellor Denis Healey was forced to abandon a flight to the IMF’s September 1976 meeting in Manila, to return to the Labour party conference in Blackpool and deliver a memorable speech defending his planned spending cuts as negotiations began with the Fund over the the bailout.

Updated

Rachel Reeves heading to China this week to build bridges

The pound’s tumble comes as Rachel Reeves prepares to fly to China in a bid to build closer ties with Beijing.

The chancellor, who is travelling with a delegation of City bigwigs, is holding the visit as part of a concerted effort to build bridges with China, as part of the government’s push for growth.

Our economics editor Heather Stewart explains:

City businesses have urged Reeves to help ensure China is not placed on the higher, more stringent, tier of a new “foreign influence registration scheme” – a decision ultimately to be made by the Home Office.

Lobbyists for overseas governments will have to declare their role under this new regime, but the “enhanced” tier will force companies carrying out any activity on behalf of another state to make themselves known – something business groups fear could prevent closer ties.

The chancellor will take the Bank of England governor, Andrew Bailey, with her on the visit to Beijing and Shanghai, as well as the FCA chief executive, Nikhil Rathi, and a string of senior banking figures, including HSBC’s chair, Mark Tucker.

Reeves will meet China’s vice-premier, He Lifeng, in Beijing before flying to Shanghai for discussions with UK firms operating in China.

Enhanced cooperation on financial services is at the heart of the Treasury’s hopes for the trip. Reeves lavished praise on the sector in her Mansion House speech last year, calling it the “crown jewel” of the UK economy.

Pound falls below $1.23 to 14-month low

The pound has dropped to a 14-month low in early trading in London, as the bond-market sell-off fuels anxiety over UK assets.

Sterling has lost a cent against the US dollar, extending its recent losses, falling to around $1.226.

That’s its lowest level since November 2023, suggesting that the jump in UK borrowing costs this week is continuing to worry the markets, at a time when the dollar is generally strengthening.

Michael Brown, senior research strategist at brokerage Pepperstone, has warned that “things are also getting rather ugly” in the UK.

Brown told clients this morning:

This dynamic, of yields moving higher, as the respective currency falls, is a classic sign of fiscal de-anchoring taking place, and of participants losing confidence in the Government in question’s ability to exert control over the fiscal backdrop.

We’re not at the Truss/Kwarteng stage just yet, but things are clearly on very shaky ground indeed.

Brown added that his preference is to be ‘short GBP’ – ie, betting that the currency will continue to fall.

Despite recent losses, the pound is still comfortably above the record low hit after the 2022 mini-budget, when it plunged to near-parity against the US dollar.

Updated

Introduction: UK bond sell-off fuels fears of another Truss moment

Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of business, the financial markets and the world economy.

After two days of sharp rises in UK borrowing, City experts are harking back to previous episodes of financial panic – including the dark days after Liz Truss’s mini-budget of 2022.

Britain finds itself in the eye of a global bond market storm at the moment, with the pound also weakening. Yesterday, the yield (rate of return) on 10-year UK government debt hit its highest since the 2008 financial crisis, a day after the 30-year bond yield hit its highest level since 1998.

Last night, Rachel Reeves insisted she had an ‘iron grip’ on the nation’s finances, with a Treasury spokesperson declaring:

“No one should be under any doubt that meeting the fiscal rules is non-negotiable and the Government will have an iron grip on the public finances.

“UK debt is the second lowest in the G7 and only the OBR’s forecast can accurately predict how much headroom the government has - anything else is pure speculation.

“Kick-starting economic growth is the number one mission of this Government as we deliver on our Plan for Change. Over the coming weeks and months, the Chancellor will leave no stone unturned in her determination to deliver economic growth and fight for working people.”

It’s not exactly ‘pure speculation’, though, to point out that rising bond yields eat into the relatively small headroom available to the chancellor to hit her fiscal rules (to not borrow to fund day-to-day spending, and to show debt falling in five year’s time).

If the headroom has vanished by the spring statement in March, it will leave the chancellor with an unpalatable choice – cut government spending, despite demands from the public and cabinet colleagues for better services, or raise taxes further.

The borrowing costs of other governments have also been rising in recent sessions, inculding the US, where there are fears that Donald Trump’s presidency will drive up inflation, making interest rate cuts less likely.

But the situation in the UK feels more acute.

Ipek Ozkardeskaya, senior analyst at Swissquote Bank, says “the UK’s demons are back”, driven by heightened fiscal concerns – which are “evoking memories of Liz Truss’s chaotic ‘mini-budget days.’”

Ozkardeskaya added:

Back then, markets lost confidence in the government’s spending plans, triggering an aggressive selloff that forced the BoE to intervene. The fallout toppled Truss’s government, setting the stage for Labour’s strong electoral win.

But now, the newly elected Labour government, which promised to rescue the country, improve finances, and boost growth, faces its own reckoning. To deliver on its ambitions, it needs market support – a resource proving elusive. Without it, borrowing costs will spiral higher, forcing tougher choices: more taxes, less spending, and weaker growth. And none of that bodes well for the pound.

The sell-off in 2022, after chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng delivered a budget of unfunded tax cuts, was certainly more aggressive than what we’ve seen this week. But long-term borrowing costs are now higher than in the Truss panic.

Kyle Rodda, senior financial market analyst at Capital.com, fears the tumble in UK asset prices could be a sign of another “simmering financial crisis”:

There’s a mini-crisis brewing in UK markets amidst a broad-based sell-off in the country’s assets. For no explicable reason aside from already known factors like weak growth, elevated inflation, and unsustainable fiscal settings, stocks, bonds and the Pound plunged, in moves reminiscent of the 2022 Truss meltdown.

The moves indicate a looming crisis of confidence in the UK and reflects expectations of ongoing and long-term economic malaise which will only be addressed by massive reform.

Dutch bank ING say that several factors are pushing up UK bond yields, including Labour’s spending ambitions, sticky inflation, higher US rates and supply pressures.

But in cheering news for the Treasury, IN’s senior european rates strategist Michiel Tukker is confident that we’re not facing a “sovereign crisis”.

Tukker told clients:

It’s important to note that the demand from foreign buyers remains strong, which reduces the repeat risks of a Liz Truss moment. So whilst rates can stay higher, we don’t expect any steep sell-offs on the back of sovereign risk.

Also, keep in mind that the Truss turmoil was exaggerated by a liquidity crunch among pension funds due to interest rate hedges suddenly moving against them. This time the move up is more gradual, which should prevent such a spiral higher in gilt yields.

The agenda

  • 10am GMT: Eurozone retail sales for November

  • 12.30pm GMT: Challenger survey of US job cuts in December

  • 4pm GMT: Bank of England policymaker Sarah Breeden gives speech

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*