Graeme Wearden (until 2.15) and Nick Fletcher 

UK real wages rise, but drop in EU workers could hurt NHS – as it happened

Basic pay in Britain is rising faster than inflation, but Germany has suffered a growth slowdown
  
  

UK pay is rising faster than inflation
UK pay is rising faster than inflation Photograph: Alamy Stock Photo

Mixed day for European markets

Markets were struggling for direction for most of the day, with the exception of Wall Street which moved sharply lower on renewed worries about the US/China trade talks, a rising dollar and falling bond yields.

Several European markets suffered from a spate of profit taking, while the volatility of Brent crude - surging to new three and a half year highs, falling back then moving up once more - did little to help the FTSE 100. The closing scores showed:

  • The FTSE 100 finished up just 12 points or 0.16% at 7722.98
  • Germany’s Dax dipped 0.06% to 12,970.04
  • France’s Cac closed up 0.23% at 5553.16
  • Italy’s FTSE MIB edged up 0.31% to 24,297.17
  • Spain’s Ibex ended down 0.49% at 10,207.6
  • In Greece, the Athens market fell 2.04% to 799.37

On Wall Street the Dow Jones Industrial Average is currently down 210 points or 0.84%.

As for Brent crude, it is up 0.63% at $78.72 a barrel, having earlier touched $79.47.

On that note, it’s time to close for the day. Thanks for all your comments, and we’ll be back tomorrow.

On Wall Street, the Dow Jones Industrial Average is now down 246 points. David Madden, market analyst at CMC Markets UK, said:

Equity benchmarks are in the red as traders become more hawkish. The jump in US government bond yields is prompting traders to switch out of stocks and into bonds. US indices have reached multi-week highs recently on optimism about the US and China coming to a trade deal, and today investors are banking their profits.

With Wall Street down as the dollar rises, the FTSE 100 is not benefiting as much as might be expected from the weak pound. The UK’s leading index is up just 0.3%, perhaps because of the dip in the oil price. Connor Campbell, financial analyst at Spreadex, said:

A dominant dollar helped lead to a seriously down in the dumps Dow Jones this Tuesday, while the FTSE lost its lunchtime momentum.

Though not quite as strong as analysts’ were expecting, the latest US retail sales figures were solid enough to give the dollar a hefty hawkish boost. The greenback was propelled 0.7% higher against the pound, with cable nearing sub-$1.348 2018 lows, while against the euro it was up 0.8%, forcing the single currency under $1.185.

This, combined with the USA’s ambassador to China Terry Branstad stating that the two countries were still ‘very far apart’ on the issue of trade, caused the Dow Jones to have an absolutely miserable time of it after the bell. The index plunged nearly 200 points as the session got underway, trudging back towards 24700 having almost grazed a 2 month high of 25000 on Monday.

Normally the sight of a cable-collapse would be like catnip for the FTSE. And yes, the UK index did manage to climb 25 or so points as the day went on. However, that the FTSE can perhaps feel aggrieved that it couldn’t wring more juice from sterling’s slide.

Beyond the bearishness plaguing the Dow Jones, the fact Brent Crude has pulled back from its $79 per barrel is potentially responsible for the index not fully taking flight; but even then, BP and Shell are still up around 1.5% apiece, showing investors are still willing to drink down the oil colossi even if the black stuff is off its 3 and a half year peak. Investors may simply have slight reservations about sending the FTSE much higher than it currently is, given that it the index didn’t last long at its 7800-teasing peak back in mid-January.

The strengthening dollar after the retail sales figures has taken some of the shine off the oil price, with Brent crude now in negative territory for the day, down 0.17% at $78.10 a barrel.

At its peak during the day, Brent hit $79.47, which analysts saying $80 or even $100 could be on the horizon.

Back with the UK employment figures and the fall in EU workers, and the Press Association has more details:

Labour market data released by the Office for National Statistics showed the fall [in the number of EU nationals] was driven by a steep drop in the number of workers from the eight eastern European countries that joined the EU in 2004.

In the latest period, there were an estimated 917,000 nationals of the so-called EUA8 countries - Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Slovakia and Slovenia - in work in the UK.

This was down by 91,000 compared to January-March in 2017, the largest annual decrease since comparable records started in 1997.

Jonathan Portes, professor of Economics at King’s College London, said: “Today’s labour market statistics show a year-on-year fall in the number of European nationals working here, for the first time since the aftermath of the recession.

“A combination of factors - a slowing economy here combined with recovery on the continent, but also the political and psychological impact of the Brexit vote - have made the UK a significantly less attractive place to live and work.”

Lord Green of Deddington, chairman of Migration Watch UK, pointed to figures for EU-born workers, which he said were 155,000 higher than in the same quarter before the referendum. He said: “These new labour force figures dispose of any claim of a Brexodus.”

Madeleine Sumption, director of the Migration Observatory at the University of Oxford, said: “The employment rate of A8 migrants in the UK is close to record highs, at more than 85%. Despite that, the number of A8 migrants working in the UK has declined.

“These figures are consistent with the possibility that there has been net emigration of A8 citizens but don’t show it conclusively - we’ll need a few more months of data to see whether this is a short-term blip or a real trend.

“We do know from other migration figures that over the last couple of years, net migration from A8 countries has fallen proportionally more than it has from the other parts of the EU....”

The year-on-year dip in EUA8 workers was not mirrored across other groups of member states. There were 355,000 Romanians and Bulgarians employed in the UK between January and March, up from an estimated 297,000 in the first three months of last year.

It is the second highest figure recorded since restrictions on citizens of the two countries working in Britain were lifted in January 2014.

The number of nationals of 14 long-term EU member states including Germany, Italy, Spain and France also showed a slight increase - but remained at just over one million.

Wall Street slips on new trade worries

Donald Trump’s surprise move to support Chinese group ZTE over the weekend prompted hopes of progress in trade talks between the US and China. But ahead of new meetings in Washington, US ambassador to China Terry Branstad has said the two sides were still “very far apart,” prompting an opening fall on US stock markets.

So despite the reasonable US retail sales figures, the Dow Jones Industrial Average is currently down 151 points or 0.59% while the S&P 500 opened 0.42% lower and the Nasdaq Composite down 0.67%.

Updated

The retail sales figures have lifted expectations of a series of US rate rises this year, and helped push the dollar higher. Sterling has slipped to a new low for the year of $1.3457, down 0.7%.

A US spending boom could be getting underway, says Nordsea’s chief analyst:

US retail sales rise

US retail sales edged up in April with signs of wage growth and the recent tax cuts helping to offset some of the pressure on consumer spending from higher petrol prices.

Sales grew by 0.3% last month, in line with expectations, but the March figure was revised up to show a 0.8% surge compared to the initial estimate of a 0.6% rise.

Core retail sales, excluding cars, petrol, building materials and food services, climbed by 0.4% in April. Year on year, sales rose 4.7%.

Economist James Knightley at ING Bank said:

US retail sales have been heavily distorted over the past 6-9 month, but we are finally getting some “cleaner” data that suggests households are in good spirits and are spending in the new season.

US retail sales rose 0.3%MoM in April, which was in line with expectations, but there were some nice upward revisions to March’s data from 0.6% growth to 0.8% growth. Importantly, the “control” group, which excludes very volatile items such as food, autos, building materials and gasoline and supposedly better matches consumer spending within GDP, was up 0.4% after a 0.5% gain in March. February was revised up a tenth of a percentage point too.

Retail sales have been difficult to interpret for much of the past year. In particular, Hurricanes Harvey and Irma caused extensive damage that triggered a wave of spending as households replaced lost items in Sep-Nov 2017. In fact retail sales soared a cumulative 3.5% during the period only to fall back in Dec, Jan and Feb (although Feb has now been revised up to being flat).

Now that these distortions are out the way we expect upcoming data to show households continuing to spend strongly. Employment is rising, wages are growing and tax cuts means there is more cash in people’s pockets. With consumer confidence at strong levels, consumer spending growth is a key factor behind our above consensus 3% GDP growth forecast for the US this year. In turn, this leads us to look for a further three Federal Reserve rate rises in 2018.

Updated

Brent crude hits $79 per barrel

Over in the financial markets, the oil price has hit a new three and a half-year high.

Brent crude is changing hands at $79.30 per barrel, the highest since late 2014.

Prices have been rising since America pulled out of the Iran nuclear deal last week - a move likely to take some Iranian oil production off the market.

Crude prices have jumped by 75% since June 2017, which has led to higher transport costs and petrol price at the pumps. That in turn pushed up inflation, and is one reason why real wages in the UK had been shrinking (although not any more)

The drop in the number of EU workers in Britain could also be a warning sign for UK firms.

The UK labour market certainly looks tight, with inactivity and employment both at record highs - and employers facing 806,000 vacancies in the last quarter.

Gerwyn Davies of CIPD, the professional body for HR and people development, says bosses may find it harder to recruit staff:

“Employers need to be better prepared for a changing and tighter labour market. Labour supply looks set to fall further in the coming months, partly due to an abrupt plateauing in the number of EU citizens in employment in the UK, as this morning’s figures show.

Greater investment in skills is needed to offset recruitment difficulties and increase productivity growth alongside more workforce planning activity.”

NHS could suffer from drop in EU workers

Britain’s hospitals and social services could be hurt by the 28,000 decline in EU workers in Britain over the last 12 months.

So warns Dr Heather Rolfe of The National Institute Of Economic and Social Research.

She explains:

This represents a reduction in arrivals and increase in departures of EU citizens, which employers explain by uncertain futures and hostility. The reverse trend is shown by non-EU nationals in employment who increased in number by 20,000. This may be explained in part by employers making more use of the visa system when faced with skills shortages....

“These trends, in particular the fall in EU nationals working in the UK, are likely to affect the UK’s economic performance and also services, with the NHS and social care under particular pressure”.

According to FullFact, EU immigrants make up about 5% of English NHS staff, and 10% of all doctors.

Updated

Britain's jobs market: the key charts

The Resolution Foundation have sent over some useful charts, showing the state of the labour market:

Stephen Clarke, Senior Economic Analyst at the Resolution Foundation, sums up the picture:

“Britain started 2018 as it has spent much of the last decade, with more impressive jobs growth but little prospect of recovering from its disastrous record on pay.

“Employment has hit a record high, driven by male employment breaking the 80 per cent barrier for the first time in nearly three decades.

“While the return to pay growth is very welcome it remains anemic and wages are still over £700 a year lower than they were a decade ago. The stark fall in productivity in recent months suggests that a strong pay recovery remain some way off.”

Hammond cheers pick-up in real wages

Britain’s finance minister has welcomed the news that wages are outpacing inflation.

Chancellor of the Exchequer, Philip Hammond said:

“Growth in real wages means that people are starting to feel the benefit of more money in their pockets; another turning point as we build a stronger, fairer economy.

“We can be proud of our record on jobs. The unemployment rate is at its lowest in over 40 years and with our National Living Wage we are making sure that the lowest-paid feel the benefit with an extra £2,000 a year.

“Now the focus has to be on ensuring that wages keep rising faster than inflation, so that living standards increase.”

I suspect that final sentence could be a coded warning about Brexit.

Hammond will attend a crunch meeting of the government’s Brexit sub committee this afternoon to discuss customs arrangements, where there’s no sign of agreement.

Theresa May’s ministers are split over two options -- a customs partnership, where the UK would collect tariffs on behalf of the EU, or a “max fac” model, which would use technology to police the border.

My colleague Andy Sparrow will be tracking all the action in his Politics Live blog:

Updated

Panmure Gordon analyst Simon French suspects Britain’s labour market may be peaking - chiming with the IoD’s warning earlier.

Number of EU nationals working in Britain has fallen

Nearly two years after the Brexit vote, we can now see that the number of citizens from other European Union countries working in Britain has fallen.

The ONS reports that the total EU workforce in Britain fell by 28,000 over the last year.

That’s the first annual decrease since January to March 2010, when the UK has fallen into recession after the financial crisis.

Here’s the details from today’s labour market report:

  • There were 28.73 million UK nationals working in the UK, 417,000 more than for a year earlier.
  • There were 2.29 million EU nationals working in the UK, 28,000 fewer than for a year earlier.
  • There were 1.25 million non-EU nationals working in the UK, 20,000 more than for a year earlier.
  • The employment rate (the proportion of people aged from 16 to 64 years who were in work) was 81.9% for EU nationals, higher than that for UK nationals (75.6%) and higher than that for non-EU nationals (63.0%)

There was a sharp fall in the number of workers from Eastern European countries who joined the EU in 2004.

The Press Association’s Ian Jones has the details:

Updated

The proportion of UK men in work has hit 80% for the first time since 1991 - despite fears that robots will eliminate millions of jobs:

The Institute of Directors fears that companies are now struggling to find properly skilled and qualified workers.

Seamus Nevin, the IoD’s head of policy research says:

“Yet again we’ve seen great employment figures as the number of people in work increased and the number of people without work decreased. All of this suggests, however, that access to staff may be peaking as the labour market tightens.

“Employers are finding it increasingly difficult to recruit the people they need. Given access to skills is currently one of the highest concerns for IoD members, today’s figures also highlight the imperative for government to reform the Tier 2 visa cap to allow employers to recruit the overseas workers they need to grow in the short term.”

UK productivity has fallen

Disappointingly, UK productivity is falling again.

Productivity (broadly, how much we each produced) shrank by 0.5% in the first three months of 2018, the ONS says.

That’s because Britain’s growth rate slowed in the last quarter (to a measly 0.1%), even though companies created more jobs - meaning the amount of hours worked in the economy rose by 0.6%.

Ergo, we were less productive:

John Hawksworth, chief economist at PwC, says the UK economy is a mixed picture -- job creation remains strong, but productivity is a mess.

“The great British job-creating machine kicked back into life in the first quarter of 2018, taking the employment rate to a new record high. Unemployment edged down further and regular pay growth continued to edge up as the labour market has tightened. Real pay growth, excluding bonuses, is now firmly back into positive territory.

“All of this good news stands in marked contrast to the subdued GDP growth of just 0.1% estimated for the first quarter. This estimate could be revised up later but, taken at face value, it suggests that productivity growth turned significantly negative again after a couple of quarters when it seemed to be perking up.

Updated

Geraint Johnes, professor of economics at Lancaster University Management School, is disappointed that total pay growth (including bonuses) slowed to 2.6% from 2.8% a month ago.

Professor Johnes, who is also research director at the Work Foundation, says this shows some weakness in the labour market:

This is a disappointing result, in that it represents a fall from the 2.8% figure achieved in February, and it means that we have to wait still longer for real wages to recover.

The single month measure shows a year-on-year growth of just 2.3%. This continued flatness in wages provides justification for the Bank of England’s decision not to raise interest rates – despite the buoyancy of the employment figures, the recovery in the labour market is quite simply not there, and rising wages clearly present no threat in terms of inflation.”

This chart, from Fidelity International, shows how Britain is emerging from its second pay squeeze in a decade:

Tom Stevenson, investment director for personal investing at Fidelity, say:

“British workers are feeling marginally better off after wages grew in real terms for the second month on a trot.”

Economists are welcoming the news that basic pay in Britain is accelerating.

It could even spur the Bank of England into raising interest rates by August - although, after policymakers left rates on hold last week, who knows for sure?

The percentage of people in Britain classed as ‘economically inactive’ has fallen to just 21%, its lowest level since records began 45 years ago.

That means that more people are either in work, or looking for a job.

The ONS says:

There were 8.66 million people aged from 16 to 64 years who were economically inactive (not working and not seeking or available to work), 115,000 fewer than for October to December 2017 and 171,000 fewer than for a year earlier.

Updated

Basic pay rising faster than inflation

Today’s jobs report also shows that Britain’s cost of living squeeze is easing.

Basic pay (excluding bonuses) rose by 2.9% in the first quarter of 2018, up from 2.8% a month ago.

That means that wages are rising faster than inflation (which fell to 2.5% in March).

So real basic pay (adjusted for inflation) is now growing at around 0.4%, after shrinking over recent months.

However, total pay (including bonuses) only grew by 2.6% during the quarter (again, down from 2.8%).

But before anyone celebrates, lets not forget that Britons are basically poorer than before the financial crisis.

The Office for National Statistics says:

  • average regular pay (excluding bonuses) for employees in Great Britain was £460 per week before tax and other deductions from pay, £13 lower than the pre-downturn peak of £473 per week recorded for March 2008
  • average total pay (including bonuses) for employees in Great Britain was £489 per week before tax and other deductions from pay, £33 lower than the pre-downturn peak of £522 per week recorded for February 2008

Updated

UK unemployment rate stays at 42-year low

Newsflash: Britain’s jobless rate remained at 4.2% in the first three months of 2018.

The latest Labour Force statistics, just released, show that unemployment is at its joint lowest level since 1975.

The report also shows that the employment rate is at a record high (the data goes back to Ted Heath’s reign as prime minister):

The Office for National Statistics says:

  • There were 32.34 million people in work, 197,000 more than for October to December 2017 and 396,000 more than for a year earlier.
  • The employment rate (the proportion of people aged from 16 to 64 years who were in work) was 75.6%, higher than for a year earlier (74.8%) and the highest since comparable records began in 1971.
  • There were 1.42 million unemployed people (people not in work but seeking and available to work), 46,000 fewer than for October to December 2017 and 116,000 fewer than for a year earlier.

More to follow!

Bulgaria and Poland have both posted solid growth figures:

German coalition talks may have hurt growth

The German Federal Ministry for Economics Affairs says the country’s economy remains strong, despite growth slowing in recent months.

In a statement, it says:

“Private consumption remains strong. Companies are upbeat on their trade prospects in the light of overall favourable conditions.”

The ministry also suggests that the drop in government spending may be due to the five-month hiatus of negotiations to form Angela Merkel’s new coalition.

The Netherlands has slowed too

Just: The Netherlands economy has slowed, but not as sharply as Germany.

Dutch GDP rose by 0.5% in the first three months of this year, down from 0.7% in October-December 2017.

Finland has outperformed Germany, by posting 1.1% growth in the last quarter.

This suggests the eurozone’s most northerly neighbour is shaking off its recent stagnation, despite the slowdown in other countries.

Shares in some of Germany’s biggest companies have dipped in early trading.

The DAX index has dropped by 0.3%, or 38 points, to 12,939 in Frankfurt, following this morning’s disappointing growth figures.

Pharmaceutical giant Merck is the biggest faller (-2.8%), followed by industrial conglomerate Thyssenkrupp (-2.4%, despite reporting higher profits this morning).

ING: It's a black eye for Germany

At just 0.3%, this is Germany’s weakest quarterly growth since the third quarter of 2016.

ING economist Carsten Brzeski says Germany had a ‘stumbling start’ into 2018, for a variety of reasons:

Trade and government consumption were a drag on growth. Also, don’t forget that a couple of one-off factors like the cold winter weather, early Easter vacation and strikes probably distorted first quarter data.

Brzeski says we shouldn’t panic - he thinks that Germany’s economy still has underlying strength, including its manufacturing base:

Despite some minor leveling off, capacity utilisation is still close to record highs, assured production in the industry is close to all-time highs and the high stock of orders and historically low inventories all bode extremely well for industrial production in the coming months.

So this growth slowdown is “no more than a black eye”, Brzeski concludes.

Germany slows: What the experts say

The news that Germany’s growth rate halved in the last quarter is causing a stir.

Economist Ulrik Bie blames the drop in exports by German firms:

Tom Barfield of the AFP newswire says it will raise fears about the health of the European economy:

Pantheon Macroeconomics’ Claus Vistesen believes the eurozone will tick along at a more steady rate this year:

Oliver Rakau of Oxford Economics warns that Germany has lost momentum, and may struggle to bounce back in the coming months.

German growth slows as trade weakens

Newsflash: Germany has suffered a growth slowdown after being hit by weak trade.

The eurozone’s largest economy expanded by just 0.3% in the first three months of this year, official figures show.

That’s a sharp slowdown compared to Germany’s 0.6% in the final quarter of 2017. It is also below the 0.4% which economists had expected.

The Federal Statistics Office says:

The German economy continued to grow at the beginning of the year, though at a slower pace.

The slowdown was triggered by “less dynamic” foreign trade, as “both exports and imports decreased compared with the previous quarter”.

Government spending also fell, for the firs time in five years, dragging growth back.

But capital investment did rise during the quarter, suggesting companies are still investing in equipment and factories. Domestic consumption also made a positive contribution.

Although Germany is obviously still growing, these figures do indicate that the eurozone economy has lost some steam in recent months.

They also suggests that fears of a trade war, triggered by Donald Trump’s tariffs on steel and aluminium, are causing worrying ripples in the global economy.

Reaction to follow....

Updated

The agenda: UK wage data, eurozone growth update

Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.

Today we get a new healthcheck on Europe’s economy, with a fresh estimate of eurozone GDP for the first three months of this year, plus growth figures from Germany and the Netherlands.

Last month’s ‘flash’ data showed the eurozone economy grew by 0.4% - investors will be concerned if this is revised downwards today.

Britain’s labour market is also in focus. The latest unemployment figures are expected to show the jobless rate remains at just 4.2%, its lowest level in over 40 years.

But will there be any progress on wages? Economists predict that basic pay growth rose to 2.9% in the first three months of this year - up from 2.8%.

A strong reading might give the pound a lift, and reignite speculation that interest rates might rise in August.

Jasper Lawler of London Capital Group says:

Given that inflation in March was 2.5%, wages growth of 2.9% or higher would be an encouraging sign that domestic inflation will slowly start to pick up, potentially reviving the possibility of a Bank of England rate rise later in the year and pushing sterling back towards $1.37.

Traders will also be tracking events in Italy, where talks to form a new government are still continuing.

The agenda:

  • 7am BST: First estimate of German GDP in Q1 2018
  • 8.30am BST: First estimate of Netherlands GDP in Q1 2018
  • 9.30am BST: UK unemployment and wage growth figures for January-March 2018
  • 10am BST: Updated estimate of eurozone GDP in Q1 2018
  • 10am BST: ZEW survey

Updated

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*