Right, time to wrap up.
Here’s today’s main stories:
Goodnight. GW
The pound is falling back from its earlier one-year high against the US dollar, following some less-than-optimistic tweets:
The pound is still around 0.6% against the US dollar, though, at $1.344 (having jumped to virtually $1.35 earlier)
The end of the English lockdown, and the re-opening of non-essential stores, has meant a 40-hour shopping marathon at some Primark stores.
My colleague Lucy Campbell was at Brocklebank retail park, south-east London, at midnight, and reports....
Primark said it had anticipated higher demand before the festive season and was trying to keep queues under control by spreading shopping hours over longer periods of time. And in the early hours of Thursday morning, avoiding large crowds as the pandemic rumbled on seemed to be behind many customers’ thinking.
“I expected shopping in the middle of the night to be quieter, but it’s just as packed,” said 56-year-old Pauline Scotter, who said the queue to get in when she arrived had gone the length of the store.
Though she has a disability that affects her back and cannot stand for long periods of time, Scotter said she did not like online shopping – “the material’s never as nice as it looks”. So she welcomed the opportunity to go back in-store to pick up “cheap and cheerful” Christmas presents for her fast-growing grandchildren. She had loaded up her car, she said, with bags full of “wintry bits” – tracksuits, leggings and jumpers – and was ready to head home to nearby Kidbrooke before 1am.
FTSE 250 index hits nine-month high
Shares in smaller UK companies have rallied to their highest level since the end of February, and the early days of the pandemic.
The FTSE 250 index, seen as a good barometer of the health of the UK economy, has jumped by 1.3% today to end at 20,132 points.
That’s its highest level since the end of February, outpacing its big sibling, the FTSE 100, which only hit a six-month high today [although a nine-month closing peak]
Cinema group Cineworld, whose UK and US sites are currently closed, surged 15%. National Express, badly hurt by the slump in commuting, jumped 9%.
Cruise operator Carnival also rallied, ending 6% higher.
As Reuters puts it:
The FTSE 250 index, considered a proxy for Brexit sentiment, jumped on Thursday as investors hoped for a trade deal with the European Union before a year-end deadline, while miners rose as iron ore prices hit a record high.
The mid-cap FTSE 250 rose 1.3% to its highest since late February after Irish Foreign Minister Simon Coveney said he hoped for a deal in the next few days. However, EU officials see uncertainties as significant gaps remain on some main issues.
Today’s rally means the FTSE 250 has surged by 16% this quarter, since positive vaccine trial news lifted global markets, and is down 8% for 2020.
Updated
FTSE 100 finishes at nine-month closing high
Back in the City, the FTSE 100 index of blue-chip stocks has hit its highest closing level since the first week of March.
The Footsie has closed at 6,490 points, up 26 points or 0.4% today, which is its best closing point since mid-way through the market crash nine months ago.
On an intraday basis, the FTSE 100 has reached a six-month high as it was still higher (6511 points) in June.
Stocks have benefitted from a strong rally in recent weeks, largely due to optimism over Covid-19 vaccines, as this chart shows
Jet engine maker Rolls-Royce was top riser, jumping 15%. Hotel operator Whitbread, another company badly hit by the pandemic, rose by 4%.
Telecoms firm BT gained 6%, after the Financial Times reported that Ofcom had signalled support for its £12bn upgrade of Britain’s broadband network and said it would not introduce price controls on full fibre-optic services for at least 11 years.
Sainsbury’s jumped 4%, having said it would prioritise dividends over debt reduction after returning its business rates relief.
Mining companies also rallied, on hopes of an economic revival next year.
David Madden of CMC Markets explains:
A rally in mining stocks has helped the FTSE 100 outstrip the major indices in the eurozone. Rio Tinto, Anglo American, Glencore and BHP Group are adding a sizeable number of points to the index. Rolls-Royce is one of the biggest percentage gainers on the market on the back of a proposal to consolidate work at certain sites.
The civil aerospace sector has been hammered on account of the pandemic but the group wants to divert talent towards the defence unit. The rally in the FTSE is all the more impressive because of the move higher in the pound – which typically dents the index. Continental equity markets are underperforming as the vaccine selection process is relatively slow on account of how the EU handles the authorisation process.
Updated
The Mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, has urged the government to use the money being returned by supermarkets to support smaller firms, who have suffered badly in the pandemic.
“I welcome the decision by several supermarkets to repay the hundreds of millions of pounds they saved during the business rates holiday. I’m urging other major supermarket chains who have done well during the pandemic to follow suit.
“The business rates holiday has been a lifeline for many retailers and hospitality businesses which had to stop trading during the pandemic and for which trade will not return to normal any time soon – even with the vaccine on the horizon. They need the certainty of an extension of the business rates holiday to the next financial year.
“The Government should put the money returned by supermarkets to good use by providing additional support to small and independent retailers and hospitality businesses throughout the rest of the pandemic.”
B&M to hand back £80m in business rates relief
Discount chain B&M has announced it is also repaying its business rates relief, worth around £80m.
This follows similar u-turns from Tesco, Sainsbury’s, Asda, Aldi and Morrisons, and takes the total waived to around £1.8bn.
B&M says:
Although significant uncertainty remains, the Group believes it is now right to forego the business rates relief granted to B&M, which is approximately £80m this financial year.
Having voluntarily returned furlough money, B&M will now engage with local authorities on an appropriate mechanism to waive the business rates relief.
B&M has been classed as an essential retailer because it sells food and household goods, but it also sells homeware, toys, and electrical items.
It says that customer numbers have been “steadily improving” in the last nine weeks, with like-for-like sales slightly higher too.
It has already reported a surge in sales earlier in the year, leading to a £250m special dividend.
Chief executive Simon Arora also echoes Sainsbury’s and Tesco’s call for business rates to be reformed, to give the high street a fair battle against online retailers.
Arora says:
We request urgent reform of the outdated business rates system that is contributing to job losses across the retail sector and is acting as a deterrent to B&M and other potential occupiers taking up vacant space in many locations.”
Updated
Sterling’s rally against the dollar comes after Ireland’s Foreign Minister Simon Coveney said earlier today that there’s a good chance that Britain and the European Union would secure a trade deal within days.
“There’s a good chance we can get a deal across the line in the next few days,” he told Ireland’s Newstalk radio. “We are in the space of days not weeks.”
Connor Campbell of SpreadEx says this may have been enough to give sterling a pop higher, against the out-of-favour dollar.
Surging 1% against the dollar and 0.4% against the euro, the pound appeared to rise after Irish foreign minister Simon Coveney claimed that ‘there’s a good chance we can get a deal across the line in the next few days’.
It’s the kind of comment that has been heard before in the last couple of weeks, without anything materialising. Nevertheless, with the deadline looming, sterling will take what it can get.
Pound hits 12-month high vs US dollar
The pound has just hit its highest level against the US dollar in almost a year.
Sterling is on the brink of $1.35 for the first time since 13 December 2019 (the day after the Conservatives won the last General Election).
That’s a gain of over one cent today.
It’s partly driven by dollar weakness. The US currency is languishing at a 2.5 year low against a broad basket of currencies, as optimism over Covid-19 vaccines drives investors into riskier assets.
The new bipartisan push for a US stimulus deal, meaning government spending and borrowing, is also dragging on the US dollar, especially as the US Federal Reserve is also likely to keep policy very loose.
But there does seem to be some Brexit optimism in play too, and hopes of a breakthrough deal soon.
Neil Wilson of Markets.com explains:
Sterling rose to its highest against the US dollar in 2020 with the greenback coming under more pressure this afternoon in a repeat of yesterday’s moves as the weaker dollar narrative shows no signs of running out gas.
The moves are probably two-fold – one is clearly about dollar weakness with majors posting solid gains vs the buck. The other cause may be markets front-running a Brexit deal with indicators the UK and EU negotiators are heading towards the ‘big push’.
The surge in Boeing’s share price has pushed the Dow Jones industrial average back over 30,000 points, and close to last week’s record highs.
Optimism over the new bipartisan push for a US stimulus deal is also lifting stocks on Wall Street, with the broader S&P 500 index and the tech-focused Nasdaq both at fresh record peaks.
US service sector growth fastest since 2015
Despite America’s escalating health crisis, its service sector has posted its fastest growth in over four and a half years.
The latest survey of US purchasing managers at service sector companies, from IHS Markit, shows that output and new business accelerated substantially last month.
This pushed the US services PMI up to 58.4 in November, from 56.9 in October, which signals the sharpest increase in activity since March 2015 (anything over 50 shows growth).
The survey also found the sharpest jump in employment since the PMI report began in October 2009, with some firms saying employees previously let go due to the pandemic had been rehired.
Tomorrow’s Non-Farm Payroll will show whether this trend extended across the economy last month.
Ryanair to buy 75 more Boeing 737 Max
Airline news: Ryanair has agreed a deal with Boeing to buy another 75 of its 737 Max jets.
That’s a boost for Boeing, after the US Federal Aviation Administration declared the jet was safe to fly again following two fatal crashes in which 346 people died.
Shares in Boeing have jumped 5% in early trading.
It may also suggests airlines are looking ahead more optimistically, with Covid-19 vaccines ready to rollout. The 737 Max offers lower fuel bills, and a higher capacity -which should add up to greater profitability.
Reuters has a good take:
Budget airline Ryanair on Thursday ordered 75 additional Boeing 737 MAX jets with a catalogue value of $9 billion, throwing a commercial lifeline to the embattled U.S. planemaker after regulators lifted a 20-month safety ban.
The order from the Irish airline, Europe’s biggest low-cost carrier and one of Boeing’s most important customers, is the largest for the jet since 2018 before two fatal crashes led to its grounding.
Ryanair already has 135 of the 197-seat MAX 200 on order, and expects to receive its first jet early next year.
Ryanair did not disclose the price it will pay, but traders say deals typically include discounts in excess of 50% of catalogue prices.
Updated
Twenty five US states received at least one thousand more jobless claims last week than in the previous seven days, today’s jobs report shows.
Many of them cited layoffs in the retail, accommodation and food services sectors -- a sign that the pandemic is hitting the hospitality economy again.
Diane Swonk, chief economist at Grant Thornton, is concerned by today’s unemployment figures:
Back in the markets, the pound has risen to a new three-month high against the US dollar.
Sterling is up a cent at $1.3470 against the greenback, which has sagged to its lowest level in over two and a half-years against a basket of currencies.
The dollar is weakening as traders anticipate a new US stimulus deal soon, and co-ordinated, loose, fiscal and monetary policy under president-elect Joe Biden and Treasury secretary nominee Janet Yellen.
On Tuesday a bipartisan group of US senators proposed a $908bn spending package to break the deadlock on Capitol Hill. Attempts to agree a stimulus deal floundered before the election, and have not resumed.
The pound’s also higher against the euro, up 0.4% at €1.108. That recovers Wednesday’s fall, as Brexit trade deal talks continue in London (with the clock ticking ever more urgently...)
The drop in fresh US unemployment claims last week may not show the true impact of the pandemic raging in America, warns Richard Flynn, UK Managing Director at Charles Schwab.
“Today’s positive U.S. jobs data may be a welcome boost to markets, but investors should continue to be wary of the impact of the further lockdowns. Selective lockdowns are being implemented in some states as case counts climb a second time and health care systems risk becoming overwhelmed. Europe’s secondary outbreak is ahead of the U.S. and some countries’ economies are already experiencing the negative effects of lockdowns.
“However, although the term lockdown is being used, it’s really “lockdown-lite” compared with the restrictions imposed last spring. Places such as schools, churches, manufacturing businesses and construction sites remain open, standing in contrast to the first lockdown, when all these areas of the economy were closed.
The drop in US unemployment claims may be due to the Thanksgiving holiday.
Last week’s break will have meant less time for states to receive and process jobless claims (and also leads to temporary swings in the labor market).
Glassdoor Senior Economist Daniel Zhao explains:
Normal holiday hiring swings and anticipated seasonal furloughs in certain sectors like construction or retail could muddy the data on the extent of economic damage as COVID-19 cases rise. The tea leaves will be hard to decipher these next few months.
Tomorrow’s jobs report could expose deeper cracks in the recovery resulting from the recent surge in pandemic cases. While a repeat of the spring crash is unlikely, it revealed how quickly economic damage can accumulate. Promising vaccine news offers a light at the end of the tunnel, which makes it all the more important that Congress helps the economy hold onto gains made to-date. We don’t want to trip over our own feet with the finish line in sight.”
The number of Americans receiving unemployment support for at least a fortnight also fell.
The continuing claims total dropped to 5.52m in the week to November 21, from 6.08m the previous seven days.
That sounds positive (if people are moving back into work), but it may simply show that some families have simply used up their entitlement, so their benefits are expiring.
US jobless claims fall to 712k
Just in: the number of Americans filing new unemployment claims has fallen.
The closely-watched initial claims total dipped to 712,000 (seasonally-adjusted) last week, down from 787,000 in the previous seven days.
Economists had expected the figure to be higher, around 775,000, given the impact of surging Covid-19 cases and deaths in the US, and the latest restrictions.
But it’s still a worryingly high number of people seeking help -- and still higher than the pre-pandemic record of 695k (this year, the initial claims peaked at over 6 million one grim week).
A further 289,000 freelancers, self-employed workers and others who can’t file initial claims sought help under the PUA programme.
So overall, nearly one million Americans filed new claims for unemployment benefit last week, showing the long-term economic damage.
Asda to return £340m of business rates relief
Asda has joined the rush of supermarkets handing back their business rates relief.
Asda has just announced that it will pay its business rates of £340m in full to the UK Government and devolved administrations, waiving the relief granted back in March.
That means all the UK’s Big Four supermarkets have now decided to waive the money, plus discounter Aldi, taking the total to over £1.7bn.
In a statement, Asda says the relief was ‘vital’ in helping it keep the nation fed, shield vulnerable colleagues and invest in Covid-19 protection.
But it now wants the money to go to help those who “need to most”.
Asda President and CEO Roger Burnley says:
Throughout the pandemic we have always sought to do the right thing – fulfilling our role in feeding the nation, protecting our colleagues and supporting our communities.
But, as the hope of a vaccine and a more ‘normal’ life returning in 2021 grows, we have confidence that we are in a strong position to again do the right thing for the communities we serve. Almost half our customers are telling us they expect their financial position to worsen in the next 12 months and we recognise that there are other industries and businesses for whom the effects of Covid-19 will be much more long lasting and whose survival is essential to thousands of jobs.
We will therefore be discussing with the Government and Devolved Authorities the best mechanism to ensure the relief we have received can go towards helping those that need it most.
Updated
The Evening Standard is reporting that the first supplier casualty from the collapse of Topshop owner Arcadia Group may have emerged.
London firm Lloyd Shoe Company has lined up administrators, reports that Standard’s Joanna Bourke:
Hackney-based Lloyd Shoe Co employs 243 people and operates footwear concessions within some Arcadia stores, sourcing shoe ranges.
The firm continues to trade as normal however it has filed a notice to appoint an administrator, FRP Advisory, to seek a buyer for the business
The UK hospitality industry want the government to create a Hospitality & Tourism Recovery Fund, supported by the cash from Tesco, Sainsbury’s, Morrison’s and Aldi (so far...).
UKHospitality chief executive Kate Nicholls says the money would support businesses who haven’t been able to trade since the pandemic began:
“It is an admirable and altruistic gesture from a company that is clearly in a much better financial situation than the vast majority of the those in hospitality. The question now is what happens to this money, which the Government had intended to invest in supporting businesses.
“We are calling on the Government to earmark that money, to create a fund for those hospitality and tourism businesses that are at high risk of failure, have been closed since March or that have had no grant support, similar to the Cultural Recovery Fund. A Hospitality and Tourism Recovery Fund, including rent support to preserve the future of our high streets, would deliver a huge boost to businesses that are only just clinging onto life right when they need it most.”
Conservative MPs are pushing the government to use the supermarket’s money to support companies and individuals who were excluded from previous support measures.
Those who missed out on government support include people who were between jobs when the furlough scheme was announced, or had just started.
Self-employed people making over £50,000 per year were also barred from the Self Employment Income Support Scheme, as did the newly self-employed who hadn’t yet filed a tax return.
Anyone who was set up as a limited company were also blocked.
ExcludedUK, a campaign group, estimate that three million people are affected altogether.
The business rates relief being returned by supermarkets can be used to support struggling firms to recover from the economic shock of Covid-19.
One option is to extend the business rates holiday beyond next March for the hardest-hit companies.
Richard Churchill, partner at tax and advisory firm Blick Rothenberg, points out that some non-essential retailers have struggled to trade since the pandemic began, and need ongoing financial support.
Hopefully the Government will be able to build on this good news story and provide clarity to these hardest hit businesses in retail, hospitality and leisure as they seek to rebuild in 2021.
“Many of these businesses have exhausted the other support measures in place and have critically low cash reserves. Knowing that their rates bill will be reduced or extinguished would be a real boost to these small businesses and allow more of them to be viable and continue to trade in 2021. “
As other support measures come to an end and tax deferrals for 2020 become payable, cashflow will be critical for these businesses and Government should act now to provide further support and clarity for rates and give the targeted recipients of the relief time to plan.”
UK business confidence rises despite November lockdown
Optimism across UK companies has risen, despite the latest Covid-19 restrictions pushing activity down last month.
The latest PMI survey from data firm Markit shows the UK service sector contracted during November’s English lockdown and restrictions in other areas (to no-one’s surprise).
They say:
November data indicated a reduction in UK private sector output for the first time in five months, with weakness across the service economy more than offsetting robust manufacturing growth.
But the contraction was much more muted than in April, and less severe than expected.
Service providers often cited resilient spending among businesses in sectors that had remained open in November, says Markit, adding:
Both manufacturing and service sector companies recorded an improvement in business optimism towards the year ahead outlook.
Measured overall, the degree of positive sentiment across the UK private sector was the strongest since March 2015. Survey respondents mostly cited hopes that the impact of the pandemic on business operations would ease substantially over the next 12 month.
Overall, the service sector contracted last month, with the service PMI index dropping to 47.6 from 51.4 in October (where 50 = stagnation).
That’s better than the ‘flash’ estimate of 45.8, indicating the speed of the downturn was not as steep as first feared.
This knocked the overall private sector into a small decline, despite strong factory growth.
Tim Moore, Economics Director at IHS Markit, says vaccine optimism lifted business confidence last month.
“New lockdown measures and tighter pandemic restrictions unsurprisingly tipped UK private sector output back into decline during November. However, the collateral damage on areas outside of hospitality, leisure and travel has been far more modest than in the first lockdown period. Back in April, nearly 80% of all service providers reported a monthly drop in business activity, while the equivalent figure was only 30% in November.
“Hopes that the pandemic will be brought under control from an effective vaccine resulted in a sharp improvement in business optimism during November.
Retail analyst Mark Brumby tweets:
Tesco CEO: Give us more Brexit trade deal clarity
Ken Murphy also warned that Tesco needs more clarity from the UK government about how products will move across the border after the Brexit withdrawal agreement ends.
The supermarket CEO told Sky News the supermarket has taken preparations to keep operating whether or nor there is a UK-EU trade deal, but would really like more information about the movement of stock:
“The biggest challenge we face really is the movement of product between borders, the movement of product between Great Britain and Northern Ireland and of course between mainland Europe and the UK.
“That is the one area where we really would urge the government to give us some clarity and to allow us to prepare even better for the end of December.
Tesco’s new chief executive, Ken Murphy, has been explaining yesterday’s decision to hand back £585m of business rates relief on Sky News.
Murphy says that “the world was in chaos” in March, and the “decisive action” by the government helped it invest.
That meant shielding 26,000 vulnerable staff, hiring more than 50,000 new colleagues, and creating 1.5m delivery slots to look after 700,000 vulnerable, self-isolating customer.
So at the time, Tesco felt it was ‘completely justified’ in keeping the money, as it had spent “every penny and more” on its Covid-19 costs.
But it’s now clear that the pandemic isn’t a temporary crisis.
As time when on, and we saw that this crisis was going to linger and keep going, we went into a second lockdown, we were able to trade through it....and many, many businesses, smaller businesses were not able to open, we saw communities suffering and of course the young were really hard hit by this in terms of unemployment.
So we felt that, at this point the right thing to do was to give the money back.
Q: You’re due to declare a special dividend following the sale of your businesses in Thailand & Malaysia -- that wouldn’t have been a good look while accepting this relief, would it?
Murphy insists the two issues are “completely disconnected”, and didn’t influence the decision.
Q: There’s some speculation that you’ve done this because it’s slightly easier for you than for some competitors, and puts them in a bind. Any truth in it?
Handing back nearly £600m of money that some shareholders might think is theirs is never an easy decision, says Murphy.
When we made the decision we didn’t really think about the competition at all.
We were really focused on what was the right thing for the Tesco brand, what was the right thing for Tesco customers and Tesco communities, and that’s why we took the decision.
Murphy also argues for business rates reform, saying Tesco’s bill has gone up 80% in the last decade while sale at some stores are flat or declining due to the growth in online shopping.
We are seeing a massive penalisation of the retail sector.
An online sales tax is “absolutely the right thing to do”, he insists, even though Tesco is the UK’s largest online grocer.
Updated
Tesco’s announcement yesterday morning may have caught rivals on the hop (although they must have known the issue wasn’t going away).
Here’s Hugh Radojev of Retail Week:
Aldi’s move means around £1.4bn of business rates relief has now been waived by supermarkets, since Tesco announced its u-turn yesterday morning.
Here’s how much is being paid:
- Tesco: £585m
- Sainsbury: £440m (£410m this year, £30m in 2021-22)
- Morrisons: £274m
- Aldi: more than £100m
Pressure had been building for some time -- indeed, the decision to give supermarkets 100% relief from business rates was criticised back in April:
The situation became stickier once supermarkets began paying dividends on the back of strong trading this year.
Sainsbury was especially vulnerable, as its dividend bill for the first half of the financial year pretty much equalled its business rates relief (although some of the dividend was for pre-Covid trading...):
A former minister, Esther McVey MP, piled on the pressure last month after Altus calculated that the supermarkets would save £1.9bn between them.
The second English lockdown has provided another sales boost to supermarkets, while vaccine rollouts should reduce the economic risks in 2021.
But hospitality firms face a struggle to simply survive until next year, and unemployment is expected to rise sharply.
Tesco’s chairman John Allan saw the writing on the wall yesterday, when he said:
We are financially strong enough to be able to return this to the public, and we are conscious of our responsibilities to society.
We firmly believe now that this is the right thing to do, and we hope this will enable additional support to those businesses and communities who need it.”
Aldi to repay business rates relief too
Newsflash: Aldi, the UK’s fifth-largest supermarket, is also returning its business rates relief.
Over £100m will be paid back to the UK Government and the Devolved Administrations, it says (so, less than Tesco and Sainsbury. Still, every little helps).
Giles Hurley, Chief Executive Officer at Aldi UK, says:
“Thanks to our amazing colleagues, we have been able to remain open during lockdowns and despite the increased costs we have incurred during the pandemic, we believe returning the full value of our business rates relief is the right decision to help support the nation.
Our continued investment for our colleagues and our customers will remain unchanged.”
Updated
Services slump pulls eurozone economy into downturn
Over in the eurozone, the latest Covid-19 restrictions have pulled the economy into reverse.
The latest PMI survey from data firm IHS Markit shows a sharp (and predictable) fall in services activity, meaning the eurozone’s private sector economy returned to contraction during November for the first time in five months.
The clampdown on hospitality businesses, and the rise in Covid-19 cases, led to a drop in business at services companies, and a rise in job cuts in most countries (although Germany held up better).
But, the slump isn’t as severe as in the spring, as the latest restrictions were less severe.
- Final Eurozone Composite Output Index: 45.3 (down from October’s 50, which showed stagnation)
- Final Eurozone Services Business Activity Index: 41.7
Also, business confidence has “improved noticeably”, given recent encouraging news on Covid-19 vaccines.
Chris Williamson, Chief Business Economist at IHS Markit explains:
“The eurozone economy slipped back into a downturn in November as governments stepped up the fight against COVID-19, with business activity hit once again by new restrictions to fight off second waves of virus infections.
“However, this is a decline of far smaller magnitude than seen in the spring. Unlike earlier in the year, manufacturing has so far continued to expand, buoyed in part by recovering export demand, and the service sector is also seeing a much shallower downturn than during the first lockdowns.
Waiving business rates relief means it will take Sainsbury’s longer to hit its debt reduction targets.
It tells the City that shareholders shouldn’t bear the “full short-term financial impact” of making “the right decisions for customers and colleagues”*
Therefore, when considering free cash flow allocation this year the Board will prioritise payment of dividends to shareholders over net debt reduction
As a consequence, while we expect to make good progress towards our target of at least £750 million net debt reduction in the three years to March 2022, we now expect to achieve this target by March 2023
Shares in Sainsbury’s have risen 1.5% in early trading, recovering some of yesterday’s 2.8% drop (after Tesco’s move).
[* -- Sainsbury points out it has hired 56,000 people, paid 13,000 vulnerable staff to self-isolate for 12 weeks and made nearly nine million grocery deliveries to elderly, disabled and vulnerable customers]
Ministers should heed Sainsbury’s call for business rates to be reformed, says Michael Hewson of CMC Markets:
While the move is welcome it doesn’t change the fact that the government needs to look at a business rates model that is outdated, and penalises bricks and mortar retailers in a way that on-line retailers don’t have to contend with.
It’s all very well criticising the supermarkets for taking taxpayers money, but let’s not forget that the retail sector wouldn’t be in anywhere near as much trouble, if it wasn’t for government procrastination over reforming business rates policy.
Business rates are charged based on the estimated rental value of a property. Last year, MPs said the system was ‘broken’, and putting an unfair burden on high street firms.
Asked on Wednesday if it would match the Tesco pledge, the Co-op said the amount spent on protecting staff and customers outweighed the savings, the Press Association reports:
“Given the huge uncertainty we’re facing... and the ongoing costs we are incurring, we’ll consider our approach in terms of the Government support we’ve received at year end.”
A spokesman for Waitrose-owner the John Lewis Partnership said:
“We are incredibly grateful for this vital support because we have lost significant sales while our John Lewis shops have been closed, and have invested heavily to keep our partners and customers safe.
“The outlook remains incredibly uncertain and Government support remains crucial to help us navigate the crisis.
“We’re a business owned by our employees - our partners, not external shareholders - and we don’t intend to pay a bonus this year.
“Whenever we make any money, it is invested in our partners, our business and charitable giving.”
Last month, John Lewis announced that 1,500 head office jobs are to be cut, as it tries to return to profitability. And it did have to shut stores during this year’s lockdowns.
Overall, the one-year suspension of business rates for retailers, pubs, restaurants, cinemas, gyms and hotels was expected to cost £10bn (before supermarkets bowed to pressure and started handing their share back).
Real estate adviser Altus Group has calculated that £3bn went to ‘essential retailers’ - such as superstores, supermarkets, fascia convenience stores and food warehouses.
They kept trading through the pandemic (and often kept paying dividends too).
Robert Hayton, Head of Property Tax at Altus Group, adds:
“It is crucial that Government ensures future support is targeted to where it is needed including funding the Valuation Office so it can expedite settlement of the tens of thousands of formal Challenges against business rates assessments that must now be reduced to reflect the impact of COVID ahead of next year’s bills.”
Updated
Retail analyst Nick Bubb writes:
Well, the news that Tesco wants to repay the Business Rates relief it received from the Government soon bounced Sainsbury and Morrisons into following suit, but the decision by Sainsbury to retain the Argos relief is a possible route that mixed Food/Non-Food retailers like Marks & Spencer and the John Lewis Partnership could go down…
Sainsbury: Now sort out business rates
Simon Roberts is also urging the government to review the business rates system, to give physical retailers a better chance of competing against online rivals:
Sainsbury’s CEO says:
“We remain focused on delivering the plan we set out at our half year results.
We continue to urge government to review the business rates system to create more of a level playing field between physical and online retailers.”
Updated
Sainsbury’s CEO Simon Roberts says it is “fair and right” to return the business rates relief, given that “regional restrictions” are likely to remain in place for some time.
Roberts also hopes that businesses that were forced to close in the second Covid-19 lockdown will benefit from this move:
“We have been proud to play our part in feeding the nation in this extraordinary year and every one of our colleagues has gone above and beyond to support each other, our customers and our communities. While we have incurred significant costs in keeping colleagues and customers safe, food and other essential retailers have benefited from being able to open throughout.
With regional restrictions likely to remain in place for some time, we believe it is now fair and right to forgo the business rates relief that we have been given on all Sainsbury’s stores. We are very mindful that non-essential retailers and many other businesses have been forced to close again in the second lockdown and we hope that this goes some way towards helping them.
Introduction: Sainsbury's to forgo business rates relief
Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.
Christmas is a time for giving. And Sainsbury has just become the third UK supermarket chain to give back its business rates relief to the government.
Twenty four hours after Tesco got the ball rolling down the aisle, Sainsbury has decided to forgo a total of £440m of business rates relief, which was granted by the UK Government and the Devolved Administrations since March to support retailers.
That’s on top of Tesco’s decision to return £585m, with Morrisons following suit last night by pledging to hand back £274m.
This takes the total waived by these three major supermarkets to £1.3bn.
The decision means Sainsburys will give up around £410m of business rates relief this financial year -- it had received £450m in total, but is keeping the £40m on its Argos stores (which, to be fair, were closed in the lockdown).
It is also planning to forgo another £30m in the 2021-22 financial year.
Sainsbury argues that it took the decision because its sales and profits at its supermarkets have been stronger than expected since the second English lockdown, last month.
It says its base case had originally been that the cost of protecting customers and colleagues, and the loss of clothing, fuel, general merchandising and financial services sales would be balanced out by the business rates relief.
However, lockdown restrictions have remained in place for longer than originally expected and throughout the pandemic all Sainsbury’s stores have been deemed essential retail.
Almost all have been open and trading strongly, with the exception of a small number of convenience stores. As a result of this, Sainsbury’s sales and profits have been stronger than originally expected, particularly since the start of the second national lockdown in England and we have therefore taken the decision to forego the business rates relief on all Sainsbury’s stores.
However, the move also follows criticism that the supermarkets should never have received such a windfall.
They received around £1 in every £6 of business rates relief, even though they kept running through the crisis, saw a jump in sales, and - crucially - kept paying dividends to shareholders.
The agenda
- 9am GMT: Eurozone service sector PMI for November
- 9.30am GMT: UK service sector PMI for November
- 1.30pm GMT: US weekly jobless claims
Updated